1 / 32

Industrial Organization I

Industrial Organization I. Product Differentiation (I). Logistics . Homework 3 is posted (2 problems), due tomorrow. Read Nevo 2000 (posted) for tomorrow Project 3 coming up, due next week, we will start working on project 3 tomorrow @ lab. Logistics .

adanna
Download Presentation

Industrial Organization I

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Industrial Organization I Product Differentiation (I)

  2. Logistics • Homework 3 is posted (2 problems), due tomorrow. • Read Nevo 2000 (posted) for tomorrow • Project 3 coming up, due next week, we will start working on project 3 tomorrow @ lab.

  3. Logistics • Homework 3 is posted (2 problems), due tomorrow. • Read Nevo 2000 (posted) for tomorrow • Project 3 coming up, due next week, we will start working on project 3 tomorrow @ lab.

  4. Logistics • Homework 3 is posted (2 problems), due tomorrow. • Read Nevo 2000 (posted) for tomorrow • Project 3 coming up, due next week, we will start working on project 3 tomorrow @ lab.

  5. Logistics • Homework 3 is posted (2 problems), due tomorrow. • Read Nevo 2000 (posted) for tomorrow • Project 3 coming up, due next week, we will start working on project 3 tomorrow @ lab.

  6. Differentiated Products: Introduction • Until now: • One firm, or • All firms produce the exact same product • Examples of homogeneous goods (?): • Gas/electricity • Agricultural products • Gasoline • Phone

  7. Differentiated Products: Introduction • Differentiation dimensions: • Geographic • Product characteristics • Service • Subjective differentiation (advertising) • Most markets exhibit differentiation: • Gasoline: location, services (snacks, ATM, car wash), brand • Cell phone service: distributors’ locations, coverage, customer service, advertising, phones.

  8. Types of Demand • Representative consumer: population demand has a “representative” consumer • Traditional demand curve with negative slope (multiple-unit demand) • Consumers heterogeneous but there is a way to represent all of them with a single demand curve • Discrete choice demand: Consumers have different tastes (heterogeneity is important) • Consumers purchase 1 unit of the good that provides the highest utility (eg.: car, cell phone, computer)

  9. Types of Differentiation: Horizontal • Consumers have different product rankings: • Consumer A prefers a light-colored car: UA=1-|A-x| • Consumer B prefers a dark car: UB=1-|B-x| UB=1-|B-x1| 0 A x1 UB=1-|B-x2| x2 1 (black) 0 (white) B UA=1- |A-x1| UA=1-|A-x2|

  10. Horizontal Differentiation • Consumer A prefers car X1, B prefers X2 • Geographic differentiation is a type of horizontal differentiation • Most common type of product differentiation

  11. Vertical Differentiation • Consumers agree on product ranking (more is better): 1 (max) UA= UB=x1 UA= UB=x2 x1 x2 0 (min)

  12. Vertical Differentiation • Both (and all) consumers prefer X1 (given same price) • Quantity is an example of vertical differentiation • Examples: • Computer processors • “Homogeneous” goods: rice, gold, iron

  13. Representative Consumer Product Differentiation

  14. Representative Consumer • Every firm can now charge a different price • There is some “market power” because increasing price does not mean you lose all the demand • Each firm faces a different market demand, but demands are inter-related (rival’s price influences q) Substitutability Parameter

  15. Representative Consumer p1 p2 Product 1 Product 2 100+ αp2 100+ αp1 Π1>0 Π2>0 p*1 p*2 D1 D2 MC MC q1 q2 q*1 100+ αp2 q*2 MR1 MR2 100+ αp1

  16. Representative Consumer Product 2 “More differentiated” Product 1 “Less Differentiated” p1 p2 • Greater differentiation=greater profit (all else equal) • Price elasticity decreases (absolute value) • Cross-price elasticity decreases (less substitutability) Π1<Π2 Π2>0 p*1 p*2 D2 D1 MC MC q1 q2 q*1 q*2 MR1 MR1

  17. Price Competition • Assuming constant mc: • Under Bertrand-Nash (price competition) conjecture=0 • BUT: equilibrium price is no longer equal to MC Conjecture

  18. Price Competition • Mark-up depends on price elasticity (as with Cournot competition) • Reaction functions can be derived p1(p2) and p2(p1) • From i’s FOC solve for pi as a function of pj

  19. Bertrand-Nash Equilibrium p2 r2 (p1) NE: both choices are simultaneously optimal p2*(p1*) r1 (p2) p1 p1*(p2*) Upward sloping reaction functions: “strategic complements”

  20. Quantity Competition • Invert demand system so that p is a function of q • Under Cournot and differentiated products: conjecture=0 • Again we have: Conjecture

  21. Cournot Equilibrium q2 r1 (q2) NE: both choices are simultaneously optimal qM r2 (q1) q2*(q1*) qM q1 q1*(q2*) • Reaction functions q1(q2) and q2(q1) can be derived in a similar fashion: • From i’s FOC solve for qi as a function of qj

  22. Theoretical Models ofDiscrete Choice Differentiation (aka “Location” Approach)

  23. Hotelling: Fixed price X1=0.3 X=0.45 X2=0.6 • “Location” or Hotelling model • Consumers are uniformly distributed (Ui(j)=G-t|yi-xj|-pj): • Each consumer has a “favorite” color and purchases from the closest firm • Transportation costs: less utility the farther away • Fixed price = 1 • Firms choose differentiation (location) 0 (white) 1 (black) Π1=X1+(X2-X1)/2=0.45 Π2=(1-X2)+(X2-X1)/2=0.55

  24. Hotelling: Fixed Price X2=0.6 X1=0.6-e • Equilibrium? • Strategies: [0,1] • Profit: Π1(X1,X2), Π2(X1,X2) • X1 has an incentive to relocate to 0.6-e. Is this an equilibrium? • X2 has an incentive to relocate to the left of x1 • Rival relocates to the left if x>0.5 and to the right if x<0.5 0 (white) 1 (black) Π1=0.6-e Π2=0.4

  25. Hotelling: Fixed Price X1=X2=0.5 0 (white) • Equilibrim is the middle location • “Principle of minimum differentiation” • When does it hold? • Why does it not hold? Variable price. 1 (black) Π1=0.5 Π2=0.5

  26. Hotelling: Fixed location p1+|yi-X1| p + |y-x| = 2.5 p2+|yi-X2| • Firms choose p1, p2 • Consumers minimize cost: t|yi-xj|+pj (t=1 to illustrate): • Example: X1=0, X2=1; p1=p2=2 • Π1= Π2=p10.5=1 p1=2 p2=2 X1=0 X2=1 y=0.5 Π1=1 Π2=1

  27. Hotelling: Fixed location p1+|yi-X1| p2+|yi-X2| p=2.25 • Firm 1 captures larger share and larger profit by offering a lower price: • p1=p2=2 is not an equilibrium • Firm 2 can also improve profits p2=2 p1=1.5 X1=0 X2=1 y=0.75 Π1=1.13 Π2=0.5

  28. Hotelling: Fixed location p1+|yi-X1| p=1.5 p2+|yi-X2| • In this example, there is an equilibrium: • If p1=p2=1, changing p does not improve either firms’ profits p1=1 p2=1 X1=0 X2=1 y=0.5 Π1=0.5 Π2=0.5

  29. Hotelling: Fixed location π1 • In general, there are 2 types of equilibria: • If X1=X2, p1=p2=0 is an equilibrium • If X1 and X2 are not too close: p1=[3+X1-(1-X2)]/3; p2=[3+(1-X2)- X1]/3 • If X1 y X2 are too close: no equilibrium (in pure strategies), there is always incentive to change price Firm 1’s profit when p2=1 p1 p1=0 p1=1 p1=2

  30. Hotelling: Variations and Important Points • With variable price and location there is no equilibrium • Advantages: • With fixed price: it predicts geographic location of vendors • With fixed location: many markets exhibit large degree of differentiation (Ej.. clothing, arts, etc.) • Limitations: • Unidimensional (geographic distance, 1 product dimension) • Equilibria with more than two players are difficult/impossible to calculate • Consumers have linear transportation costs • With quadratic transportation costs there is an equilibrium: maximum differentiation

  31. Hotelling: Variations and Important Points • Circular Model: • All firms face competition on both sides

  32. Hotelling: Variations and Important Points • Examples: • Price per minute depends on time of day • Circular highway (around cities) • Trains, planes, buses that provide 24 hour service • Equilibrium (look at Shy’s book chapter, if interested): • Several firms enter the market (differentiation) • Firms locate at equally spaced intervals • Number of firms depends on fixed costs

More Related