1 / 12

Services Trade as a Catalyst for Regulatory Reform

Services Trade as a Catalyst for Regulatory Reform. Anja Gomm and Ceferino Rodolfo Trade Policy and Promotion Project, Philippines Asia Regional Consultative Conference Bangkok, 29 November to 1 December 2006. Introduction.

amos-young
Download Presentation

Services Trade as a Catalyst for Regulatory Reform

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Services Trade as a Catalyst for Regulatory Reform Anja Gomm and Ceferino Rodolfo Trade Policy and Promotion Project, Philippines Asia Regional Consultative Conference Bangkok, 29 November to 1 December 2006

  2. Introduction • Why we think services trade and the respective trade negotiations entail a strong link to business environment regulatory reform. • Trade in Services negotiations can be utilized for focused analysis and Public Private Dialogue (PPD) on urgent regulatoray issues • At the same time, we see a role for specific and customized Technical Assistance (TA) support to foster this link.

  3. Unique Characteristics of Services Requires physical proximity between service provider and consumer • Services are typically invisible and intangible; hence, non-storable. • This requires that they are produced andconsumed at the same time. • Therefore, the service provider and consumer need to be physically proximate. • Technological advancements, especially in Information and Communication Technology (ICT), have made it possible for Services to be traded internationally • This has implications for the competitiveness of a country’s services sector Requires simultaneous production and consumption Non-storable Invisible Intangible

  4. Services and Competitiveness • Services are deeply imbedded in the whole economy, providing critical support to other sectors. • Cross-sectoral impact of services make it critical to the competitiveness of the whole economy Over-all National Competitiveness Agriculture & Industry • Basic Services: Provide Basic Infrastructure and Facilitate Transaction Flows • Construction services • Communication services • Financial services • Distribution services • Transport services • Business services • End-user type of Services: Developing Human Capital • Educational services • Health-related and social services • Recreational, cultural & sporting services • Tourism and travel-related services • Sustaining Growth • Environmental services

  5. Globalization introduced intense competition in industrial goods and agricultural products. Services Trade is a rapidly growing sector As countries seek to be more competitive, the importance of having a very efficientservices sector is highlighted. Drivers for International Trade in Services

  6. How is International Trade in Services regulated? Domestic Regulation of Services • Rationale: • Public interest • Private (group) interest • Coverage: • Standard setting • Price controls • Entry controls • Public / private monopolies • Others Regulation of Trade in Services refer to the same regulations, applied differently (more restrictive) to foreign providers.

  7. Trade in Services negotiations and Domestic Regulation SERVICES REGULATION cover: • Investment Policy • Immigration Rules and Regulations • Quality and Performance Standards • Banking and Financial Regulations, including Foreign Exchange • E-Commerce Laws • Competition Policy • Price Setting and Regulation • Others These are cross-sectoral rules that impact on the Economy, as a whole. In Services Trade negotiations, trading partners request and offer the removal of barriers. The process requires: (a) Introspection and (b) Cross-sectoral Public and Private Consultations. Introspection is needed, to understand own strategic interests (offensive and defensive). • Analysis of the Competitiveness of the specific Services sector, including its Strengths and Weaknesses; • The sector’s linkages with the whole Economy. • The impact of virtually all relevant cross-sectoral and sector-specific policies. Consultations (Public-Private dialogues) are necessary in order to identify the national strategic interests and pinpoint the regulations that pose impediments.

  8. Contribution of Trade in Services Negotiations to the Regulatory Reform • Reality is: the overwhelming complexity of developing countries’ tasks and the capacity gap to handle them. Hence: 1) Trade in Services Negotiations provides the Focus (i.e. In ternational Negotiations in Trade in Services) for Capacity Building and analysis; • Reality is: that private group interests dominate in policy making. Hence: 2) Trade in Services Negotiations provides the Context (i.e. Competitiveness of the country vis-à-vis another country) for Public-Private Consultations; 3) Provides the Analytical Framework (i.e. determining regulations according to the GATS four modalities of supplying services) for research; and 4) Provides a sense of Urgency (i.e. the timelines of multilateral, regional and bilateral negotiations) for decision making and action

  9. Lessons from the Project Need for cross-sectoral Consultations • Introspective analysis of the impediments is not enough • Backing of negotiating positions is needed from public and private stakeholders • Wider perspective required, due to • Cross-cutting nature of services • Sectoral nature of Agency mandates Cross-sectoral approach: • Supports transparency • Allows for understanding of relevance and nature of issues • Opportunity to extend beyond the limits of existing structures Role of Technical Assistance in supporting Public-Private Dialogues

  10. Conditions for a successful process • Domestic Situation will dictate pace and path of liberalization: • The Role of the State • If too weak then chances for reform are bleak • Role of the Private Sector • An active private sector can compensate for a weak state • And be leveraged in response to vested interests—which may be even more difficult to hurdle than global challenges • Benefits of liberalization do not accrue automatically but require certain preconditions, such as the preparedness to review the regulatory framework and capacity building • To enable the link between services trade negotiations and a regulatory reform agenda, there needs to be a sense of urgency.

  11. How feasible and relevant is services trade to effective regulatory reform? • The applicability of such an approach is a function of : • the importance of Services to the total economy (especially in view of the private sector) • the degree of inter-linkages with other sectors • the extent to which it is regulated, and dominated by vested interests • an institutional framework sufficiently capable of policy review and change

  12. Conclusion • Continued barriers to exports and supply constraints prevent developing countries from reaping benefits of services liberalization • Business environment reforms benefit from focused analysis of current state and reform needs to enhance the country’s competitiveness. • Services trade negotiations • offer urgency for such a task • entail helpful focus AND analytical framework, • give the process the necessary guidance. • Negotiations do not per se lead to the introspection called for. • Need to shift from prevailing sectoral perspectives to cross-cutting analytical and consultative process. • Introspective process must weigh options for liberalization of services trade carefully. • The aim is for policy makers to balance prevailing private interests with broader public interests  greater benefit of whole economy and society.

More Related