1 / 13

Corporate Counsel Seminar Alternate Billing Practices: Thinking Outside of the .10 Increments November 10, 2010 Miami,

Corporate Counsel Seminar Alternate Billing Practices: Thinking Outside of the .10 Increments November 10, 2010 Miami, Florida. Moderator & Panelists. Moderator & Panelists. Moderator Richard Montes de Oca, Esq. Associate Vice President and Assistant General Counsel

angelo
Download Presentation

Corporate Counsel Seminar Alternate Billing Practices: Thinking Outside of the .10 Increments November 10, 2010 Miami,

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Corporate Counsel Seminar Alternate Billing Practices: Thinking Outside of the .10 Increments November 10, 2010 Miami, Florida 1

  2. Moderator & Panelists Moderator & Panelists • Moderator • Richard Montes de Oca, Esq. Associate Vice President and Assistant General Counsel Global Compliance & Ethics Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd. • Panelists • Joseph Nuñez, Esq. Senior Group Counsel Target • Luis Consuegra, Esq. Contract Attorney Chevron Products Company • Mario D. Carballo, Esq. Assistant General Counsel LNR Partners, LLC • Stephanie Chin, Esq. Senior Associate General Counsel Section Head Tort Litigation Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. CABA Corporate Counsel Seminar November 10, 2010 2

  3. Introduction • Economic crisis has forced corporate legal departments to cut costs • Despite economic conditions, law firms continue to increase rates • South Florida law firm rates at $785 p/hour; NY rates at $1,000 p/hour • Corporate counsel placing increased focus on value vs. hours • Alternate billing is improving efficiency and cost effectiveness • Many law firms remain unwilling to “play ball” or put “skin in the game” • Alternatives to traditional law firms are becoming increasingly attractive CABA Corporate Counsel Seminar November 10, 2010 Source: POSTLEWAITE, SUSAN: “Riding A Wave Of Misfortune” at dailybusinessreview.com 3

  4. Alternate Billing Practices Discounted Hourly Fees Hybrid Fees Blended Rates Alternate Billing Practices Flat Fees “Waterfall” Discounts Discounts Based on No. of Matters & Total Spend CABA Corporate Counsel Seminar November 10, 2010 4

  5. PROS CONS Discounted Hourly Fees • Discounted Hourly Fees • Description • Across-the-board reduction in the standard hourly fees • Percentage reduction on all bills • Usually, 5% to 15% discount • Types of Matters • International Work (e.g. Chevron) • Judicial Foreclosures (e.g. LNR) • Personal Injury (e.g. RCL) • Incentive to employ firm • Reward clients with larger billings, number of matters • Advance efficiencies of practice • Drive business • Precedent-setting concerns • Administrative concerns • Managing expectations • Risk to “standard” billing rates CABA Corporate Counsel Seminar November 10, 2010 5

  6. Concerns about quality of work • Administrative concerns • Risk to “standard” billing rates • Encourage more efficient staffing and lower rates • Promote simpler record-keeping and billing by outside counsel • Simplifies bill review and budgeting Blended Rates • Blended Rates • Description • Attorneys’ time is billed equally, regardless of seniority • Require close management of attorneys to ensure oversight • Approx. $350 per hour (e.g. partners $500; associates $275) • Types of Matters • Tort Litigation (e.g. Wal-Mart) • Real Estate Litigation (e.g. LNR) PROS CONS CABA Corporate Counsel Seminar November 10, 2010 6

  7. Greater administrative concerns • Managing expectations • Apportionment by client across different matters • Risk to “standard” billing rates • Greater incentives to employ firm • Reward clients with larger billings, number of matters • Great incentive for client to pool legal resources in one firm • Drive business “Waterfall” Discounts • “Waterfall” Discounts • Description • Stepped discounts – the percentage of discounts increases as the amount of money billed on the matters increases (e.g. 5% discount on first $100k, 10% on next $200k, 15% on anything over $300k) • Types of Matters • Real Estate Transactions (e.g. Target) • Commercial Litigation CONS PROS CABA Corporate Counsel Seminar November 10, 2010 7

  8. Discounts Based on No. of Matters & Total Spend • Discount Based on Number of Matters • Description • Discount of 5% if more than X number of matters • Discount Based on Total Spend • Description • Discount of 5% upon $100K in billings • Types of Matters • Workouts and Foreclosures (e.g. LNR) CONS PROS • Greater incentives than regular discounts • Reward clients with larger volume of matters and billings • Drive business • Advance efficiencies • Administrative concerns • Apportionment by client across different matters • Risk of inconsequential file openings CABA Corporate Counsel Seminar November 10, 2010 8

  9. Flat Fees • Drive business • Advance efficiencies • Advance expertise/SME proposition • Easing of administrative concerns • Predictability • Concerns about quality of work • Managing expectations within firm • Careful analysis on an ongoing basis • Flat Fees • Description • Specific services for a set price during the course of a specified period • Ceiling on what the client pays the law firm for specific services • Straight (e.g. $5k for retail lease negotiation) or graduated (e.g. $5k for first 5, $4k thereafter) • Types of Matters • Labor and employment (e.g. Wal-Mart; RCL) • Corporate Secretarial Services (e.g. RCL) • Uncontested Non-Judicial Foreclosures (e.g. LNR) • Real Estate Closings (e.g. Banks and Financial Services) • Real Estate Files Reviews (e.g. Target) PROS CONS CABA Corporate Counsel Seminar November 10, 2010 9

  10. Hybrid Fees • Hybrid Fees • Description • Combination of a discounted hourly rate and contingency fee arrangement • Types of Matters • CommercialLitigation • Class Action Litigation • Anti-trust • Intellectual Property CONS PROS • Easy to negotiate and administer • Client’s control of litigation expenses • Incentives to both the firm and the client • Concerns about quality of work • Managing expectations within firm • Careful analysis on an ongoing basis CABA Corporate Counsel Seminar November 10, 2010 10

  11. DO’S & DON’TS • DON’T send inaccurate bills or nickel and dime (e.g. bills for .10 hours) • DON’T automatically increase bills (e.g. focus on merit, expertise and inflation) • DON’T be afraid to be creative (e.g. reverse auctions; travel time, contract attorneys) • DO make billing statements, relationships and discussions easy • DO promote diversity within the law firm • DO consider using technology (e.g. Serengeti) CABA Corporate Counsel Seminar November 10, 2010 11 11

  12. QUESTIONS & ANSWERS CABA Corporate Counsel Seminar November 10, 2010 12

  13. Corporate Counsel Seminar Alternate Billing Practices: Thinking Outside of the .10 Increments November 10, 2010 Miami, Florida 13

More Related