1 / 39

CH 13: The Bureaucracy

CH 13: The Bureaucracy. Ms. Bittman’s AP Government. The Nature of Bureaucracy. Presidents can affect them v. little. AKA “The 4 th branch of government” No mention in the Constitution Art. II, Sec. 2, prez appoints all other officer of US.

barton
Download Presentation

CH 13: The Bureaucracy

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. CH 13: The Bureaucracy Ms. Bittman’s AP Government

  2. The Nature of Bureaucracy • Presidents can affect them v. little. • AKA “The 4th branch of government” • No mention in the Constitution • Art. II, Sec. 2, prez appoints all other officer of US. • Art. II, Sec. 3, “laws be faithfully executed, and shall commission all the officers of the US” • Bureaucracy: large organization that is structured hierarchically to carry out a specific function.

  3. Public and Private Bureaucracies • What can be considered a bureaucracy? • Private corporation: single set of leaders (board of directors), complex problem, division of labor. • Microsoft…? • Public bureaucracy: no single set of leaders, President (administrator) + Congress (funding, staffing) • Serve the citizen, not the stockholder. • Perform functions, no making profit.

  4. Bureaucracy v. Bureaucracy • Some bureaus are rather autonomous. • National bureaus -> $ to State bureaus. • Lots of administrative agencies: regulate private companies, even though they have no ownership. • Environmental Protection Agency • Nuclear Regulatory Commission • Securities and Exchange Commission

  5. Theories of bureaucracies

  6. The Weberian Model • Model of public or private bureaus developed by German Max Weber. • Views them as rational, hierarchical orgs where power flows downwards, and decisions are based on logical reasoning and data analysis, not “gut” feelings and guesswork. • Individual advancement based on merit. • Apolitical.

  7. The Acquisitive Model • Top-level bureaucracies seek to constantly expand the size of their budgets and staffs. • Want to gain greater power and influence in the public sector.

  8. The Monopolistic Model • Compares bureaus to monopolistic business firms. • Lack of competition ->inefficient and costly operations. • No incentives to reduce costs or use resources more productively. • Some argue for privatization.

  9. The Garbage Can Model • Characterized as loose, with little formal organization. • Solutions are found based on trial and error. Not rational policy making. • Choosing the right policy is hard, usually have to try several policies

  10. Organization of the federal bureaucracy

  11. Cabinet Departments • Major service orgs of the federal gov. • Aka, line organizations: directly responsible to the prez and are responsible for performing public functions. • Printing money, training troops. • Created by Congress. • Prez can ask, but has no power to create or destroy • Headed by Secretary (except for Justice) • Several levels of undersecretaries, assis. sec, ect. • Below the top, permanent staff. Prez .

  12. Independent Executive Agencies • Report to Prez. • Congress decides location w/in bureaucracy • Prez often ask that new agency be separate. • Ex • Environmental Protection Agency

  13. Regulatory Agencies • Independent of all 3 branches. • Congress felt it could not handle complex, tech required. • Combine some functions of all 3 branches • Legislative: make rules w/ force of law. • Executive: enforce rules. • Judicial: decide disputes concerning rules they made • Head is appointed by prez. Members cannot be from same party.

  14. Regulatory Agencies Continued… • Prez influence by appointing people • Cant remove except by causes specified in the law created the agencies. • Agency Capture: gaining direct or indirect control over agency personnel and decision making by the industry that is being regulated. • Less competition • Higher prices • Less choices

  15. Regulatory Agencies • Deregulation and Re-regulation: Reagan deregulation happened. • Bush 1, calls for reregulation occurred. • Clinton, deregulation of banking and telecommunications. Regulation to protect environment.

  16. Government Corporations • Different than the private corps. • Private has shareholders who elect a board of directors-> corporate officers. • Pay taxes. Profits go to shareholders. • Government corp has board of directors, managers. No stockholders. • If it profits, those go back into the corp.

  17. Staffing the bureaucracy

  18. Summary • 2 categories. Political appointees and civil servants. • Present makes the political appointments • Also appoints ambassadors (patronage) • Called “political plums”

  19. Political Appointees • To fill the positions in the “plum book” (Policy and Supporting Positions) prez solicits suggestions. • Politicians, businesspersons, prominent ppl. • Consider work experience, party, intelligence, character. • Ambassadorships used as reward for campaign contributions. • Ave. term is less than 2 years.

  20. Civil Servants • Make up the civil service. • May not feel compelled to carry out a political appointee’s directives. • V. hard to fire. • Less than 1/10 of 1% for imcompetance. • Can appeal • Under the Civil Service Reform Act of 1978, senior employees can be transferred, and get bonuses as incentives for productivity.

  21. History of the Federal Civil Service • 1789: amateurs, almost all Federalists. • Thomas Jefferson fired more than 100 and staffed it with the natural aristocracy (small ruling clique of societies ‘best’ citizens) • Next 25 years, grew more professional and more expert. • Administrators stayed in office regardless of prez.

  22. History of the Federal Civil Service • 1828: Andrew Jackson shocked by how many hated him and the Dem • Ego grew, aristocracy. • Jackson responded by firing. Instituted the spoils system

  23. History of the Federal Civil Service • Civil Service Reform Act of 1883: spoils system eventually became corrupt. • Bureaucracy increased by 300% b/t 1851-81 • Looked at European merit system • 1883 the Pendleton Act was passed • Principle of employment based on competitive exams. • Created the Civil Service Commission • 10%->90% now

  24. History of the Federal Civil Service • SC Cases • Elrod v. Burns1976 and Branti v. Finkel of 1980 • First amendment to forbid gov officials from firing or threatening solely for not being supporters of the party unless it’s a requirement. • Rutan v. Rep Party of IL of 1990 • Prevents party considerations as a basis for hiring most public employees. Except for senior policy.

  25. History of the Federal Civil Service • Hatch Act of 1939: potential for political manipulation. • FDR’s hiring= loyalty to Dems • Civil Service hiring cannot take an active part in the political management of campaigns. • Prohibits the use of federal authority to influence nominations or elections. • 1972 and 1973, Hatch Act can prohibit political activity.

  26. History of the Federal Civil Service • The Civil Service Reform Act of 1978: abolished the Civil Service Commission, created the… • Office of Personnel Management • Recruit, interview, and test potential gov. employee • Merit Systems Protections Board • Oversees promotions, employee’s rights, wrong-doing.

  27. Modern Attempts at Bureaucratic Reform • Sunshine Laws: 1976, All multi-headed federal agencies, hold public meetings. • Any gathering, formal or informal. • Exceptions: court proceedings, personnel problems. • Sunset Laws: would place government programs on a definite timetable. • Would be terminated automatically.

  28. Modern Attempts at Bureaucratic Reform • Contracting out: gov replaced by private sector. • Private firms operate prisons. • Always argue effieciency • Vouchers are another way. • Schools, housing.

  29. Modern Attempts at Bureaucratic Reform • Efficiency and Productivity • Performance based bonus when coming under budget. • Government Performance and Results Act of 1997: goals w/ methods. • Gov is too simple for complex econ. • Aberbach and Rockman: has changed and will continue too. • More an issue of new people at the top.

  30. Modern Attempts at Bureaucratic Reform • Helping the whistleblowers: gross governmental inefficiency or illegal actions. • 1978 Civil Service Reform Act • Prohibits retaliation. • Whistleblower Protection Act of 1989: further protection. • False Claim Act of 1986: can receive money when reporting fraud against the US gov.

  31. Yes, the person at Very Demotivational who created this image made a typo. Someone should probably create a system whereby there are three proofreaders, each of whom fill out a form documenting that they've checked for errors and then...oh, wait. Never mind.

  32. Bureaucrats as Politicians and Policymakers • Congress must delegate • Enabling Legislation: pwr given to agencies to implement leglis. • Cong=vague, agencies make it specific. • Lacks tech skill • Fills in the gap b/t law and practice. • Agency becomes an unelected policymaker.

  33. Bureaucrats as Politicians and Policymakers • Rulemaking Environment: proposed regs published in the Federal Registrar. • Must wait 60 days. • Individuals/companies that are unhappy… try and change it. • Persuade to withdraw or change. • Challenged in court • Can ask Cong to overturn it.

  34. Bureaucrats as Politicians and Policymakers • Negotiated Rulemaking: want business and IGs to get involved. • Prevents court battles • Negotiated Rulemaking Act of 1990 • Must publish in the Federal Registrar. • Parties then apply to be on the negotiating commit. • Proposed rule then published. • Usually prevented from challenging in court then.

  35. Bureaucrats as Politicians and Policymakers • Agency does everything… • Fills out forms, who gets what, evaluation of whether the policy works. • Often called the “Iron Triangle” or Issue Networks: try and balance conflicting demands. • Divided gov does not help. • Issue networks include legislators, staff, IGs, bureaucrats, scholars, media. • Try and influence prez, cong.

  36. Congressional Control of Bureaucracy • Authorizes $- can terminate or be renewed automatically (SS). • Once it is created, authorize $ as a formal declaration by the legis commit $ will be there. • When it has to be authorized periodically= more cong pwr • Permanent authorization= almost no pwr.

  37. Congressional Control of Bureaucracy • Appropriate Funding- after $ is authorized, appropriations commit of H and S, forward spending to full H and S. • Appropriations of $ when final bill is passed. • Can authorize less $ if it wants.

  38. Congressional Control of Bureaucracy • Cong Investigations, Hearings, Review • Oversee agency’s actions, comply with cong intentions. • Officers and employees can be ordered to testify • Congress indicates is position on programs and issues. • CBO also oversees. • GAO or CBO study can lead to cong action. • Can formally disapprove of agency actions through the Congressional Review Act of 1996. • Used only 8 times out of 15,000. Never by H & S.

More Related