1 / 16

Evaluating the success factors for establishing a thriving social enterprise in Scotland

Evaluating the success factors for establishing a thriving social enterprise in Scotland. Scottish Third Sector Research Conference. Jonathan Coburn Director, Think! Research for Social Change. Format. The rationale for the research About the study

cadence
Download Presentation

Evaluating the success factors for establishing a thriving social enterprise in Scotland

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Evaluating the success factors for establishing a thriving social enterprise in Scotland Scottish Third Sector Research Conference Jonathan Coburn Director, Think! Research for Social Change

  2. Format • The rationale for the research • About the study • Identifying the factors that underpin success • The importance of resilience and adaptability • Examining the influence of the economic downturn • The case of ethnic minority social enterprises • Policy contribution of the research

  3. Rationale for the research • Research commissioned in late 2009 in a context of substantial investment in social enterprise • At the cusp of a time of transition and change – entering the age of austerity • Issue of targeting/prioritisation of Government support to social enterprise … identifying and rewarding success rather than failure • The understanding gained was to be used to critically assess the Enterprising Third Sector Action Plan (2008-2011) and post 2011 support

  4. Research Objectives • Overall aim to identify success factors • How these are defined by social enterprises? • Are they different in a time of recession? • What enables success? • What are challenges for ethnic minority social enterprise? • Emphasis on allowing social enterprises to define success and success factors in their own terms • Focus on gaining an in-depth understanding of the issues facing a diverse sample of social enterprises

  5. Study method • A literature review • Interviews with 28 key informants • Scoping interviews with 25 social enterprises • Case study research in the story of 11 ‘successful’ social enterprises • Desk-based research • Organisational ‘life history’ interviews with the leaders • 106 follow-up interviews across the cases • In-depth interviews with 5 ethnic minority led social enterprises

  6. Eleven different stories of ‘success’ • Skye Ferry CIC • Kibble Education and Care Centre • Pollok Credit Union • Impact Arts • The North Harris Trust • ACE Recycling • The Claverhouse Group • Dial a Community Bus Buchan • Out of the Blue • Aberdeen Foyer • The Breadmaker

  7. Critical success factors

  8. The essence of success • Success is usually relative and case-specific • You can’t compare apples with oranges or pears • What constitutes ‘success’ varies over time and can be fleeting • ‘Success’ is usually in the eye of the beholder • Success comes down to achieving a balance between • Social objectives – delivering on your core social purpose • Financial objectives – the business of staying in business • … also the ‘right’ balance of internal traits or critical success factors • This balance changes over time, as the social enterprise develops and its environment changes

  9. The typical path to ‘success’

  10. Resilience and adaptability • A steep learning curve; initially and throughout life • Many ‘make or break’ moments along the way e.g. • when the rules of the game change • when growing pains arise and infrastructure creaks • when founders and leaders withdraw • Resilience and adaptability can depend on … • Stabilising operations • Taking personal responsibility • Listening to the right advice • Refocusing on the earned income strategy • Staying true to the social mission • During good and bad times, socially entrepreneurial leadership is key – passion, charisma, self-reliance, risk-taking, etc.

  11. Understanding the main external influences

  12. Influence of the economic downturn • Uneven and unpredictable results • Depends on the market rather than the organisation • Buoyancy and optimism coming through from the research • Must separate out the short-term from the longer-term effects • Some tactics to weather the initial storm • Spotting and managing the risks • Drawing on the right support and advice • Stripping out unnecessary costs • Maintaining tight cash control • Remaining responsive to changing customer needs • Longer-term • Fundamental shockwaves through public sector finances • Successful social enterprises have a clear strategic focus and remain in control of the critical aspects of their business

  13. The case of ethnic minority social enterprises

  14. Some policy recommendations... • Focus onpeople as well as organisations • Ensure a ‘pipeline’ of business support • Use all of the public sector levers of influence • Embrace the potential for failure as well as success • Help to avoid the avoidable mistakes • Offer support during difficult economic conditions • Encourage social innovation and change • Ensure social enterprise is an option for all

  15. Informing policy? • Continuing commitment to value and support a capable, sustainable social enterprise sector • Work underway to build on the Enterprising Third Sector Action Plan (2008-2011) • Ongoing themes: • Business support • Opening public sector markets • Funding and investment • Approach (2011-14) to delivering support through overarching outcomes-focussed contracts • Are these focused on fostering and rewarding success, not failure? … time will tell

  16. Thank you! w: www.thinkresearch.org.uk t: 0141 352 7419 e: jonathan@thinkresearch.org.uk

More Related