1 / 22

Communication in Primary Health Care Teams

Communication in Primary Health Care Teams. Jean Carletta University of Edinburgh Human Communication Research Centre. Project context. DOH-funded work to find the determinants of teamworking effectiveness Primary, secondary, and community mental health teams.

carter
Download Presentation

Communication in Primary Health Care Teams

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Communication in Primary Health Care Teams Jean Carletta University of Edinburgh Human Communication Research Centre

  2. Project context • DOH-funded work to find the determinants of teamworking effectiveness • Primary, secondary, and community mental health teams Communication in Primary HCT

  3. Communication research questions • Good cross-disciplinary communication is difficult, especially with status differences and where some members report to different authorities. Where teams manage it, does it make a difference? • How can we get good cross-disciplinary communication? Do whole team meetings work? Communication in Primary HCT

  4. Data Sources • questionnaire for team members measuring effectiveness, team processes (TCI), and mental health/stress (GHQ) • practice manager interviews detailing team practices, including meetings • “whole team” meeting observation [external ratings of effectiveness and innovation] Communication in Primary HCT

  5. Self-report effectiveness measures • how well the team works together • patient-centredness of the practice • general organizational efficiency Communication in Primary HCT

  6. Self-report team process measures • how willing members are to work as team • clarity of/commitment to team objectives • emphasis on quality • degree of support for innovation • amount of reflection on team practice • degree of member task interrelatedness • extent of innovation in objectives/practices Communication in Primary HCT

  7. Meeting data from interviews Communication in Primary HCT

  8. Categorization of PHCT staff • GP • practice management • practice nurse • attached staff (HV, district nurse, ...) • admin staff (secretarial, reception, ...) • miscellaneous Communication in Primary HCT

  9. Overall meeting practice Communication in Primary HCT

  10. Communication in Primary HCT

  11. Communication measures • general: • total meeting time • GP meeting time • cross-disciplinary: • attached meeting time • meeting time combining attached with GP • freedom of interaction Communication in Primary HCT

  12. Freedom of interaction maximal minimal Communication in Primary HCT

  13. Communication in Primary HCT

  14. Interview results • General communication is not related to team climate or self-reported effectiveness • Cross-disciplinary communication is related to team climate, teamworking effectiveness, and organizational efficiency • It isn’t just that less stressed/easier task teams talk more • but it’s not because of whole team meetings Communication in Primary HCT

  15. “Whole team” meetings • weekly or monthly • often cancelled or rearranged • vague agendas which predominantly reflect practice manager’s concerns • most time spend on AOB • logistical content (clinic management, audit, building fabric, Christmas parties) Communication in Primary HCT

  16. Communication in Primary HCT

  17. Communication in Primary HCT

  18. NB: There is no relationship between team size and this effectiveness subscale. Communication in Primary HCT

  19. Communication in Primary HCT

  20. Whole team meeting results • Weak: Teams provide a better patient focus when attendance at whole team meetings is good. • Strong: Teams support change better when more disciplines attend whole team meetings, and especially when attached staff are represented. Communication in Primary HCT

  21. Why? • not because of what happens at the meetings, but what happens around them before, after, on the side, in defiance of agenda • patient orientation is better when individual patients are discussed • whole team meetings are a poor way of getting attached/GP contact, but the only one most teams have Communication in Primary HCT

  22. Recommendations • Better bi-lateral communications in the team • Phone? Voice-mail? Email on “the” computer? but that doesn’t mean people have time, or culture of using them • Coffee room! Communication in Primary HCT

More Related