150 likes | 438 Views
Summary .
E N D
1. Institutional Design and Democracy in
Post-Communist Countries
Florin Fesnic
fesnic@uiuc.edu
www.florinfesnic.us
2. Summary · I focus on the impact of institutional design on democracy
Political Institutions:
Regime type: parliamentary vs. presidential systems
Electoral system: proportional representation vs. single-member district majoritarian systems
3. What is “democracy”? Robert Dahl, “Polyarchy” (1971):
Two dimensions:
- inclusiveness (participation)
- public contestation (liberalization)
Democracy (“polyarchy”) is high on both dimensions
5. Institutional design & democracy Some institutions are more conducive to democracy than others:
Parliamentarism ? Democracy
Proportional representation ? Democracy
6. Puzzle · Negative relationship between economic development and democracy across Orthodox post-Communist countries
· Why? An institutional explanation: less developed countries have made better institutional choices
7. What makes democracy work? Three types of explanations:
Economic
Cultural
Institutional
8. Testing the impact of Economy, Culture, and Institutions on Democracy Post-Communist region:
- large N (28 cases)
- variability on E, C, and I
- same previous regime ? control
- same starting point: 1989-91
? good setting for testing E, C, I
9. How? Economic development in 1990 ? Democracy in 2004
Economic development = GDP per capita
Democracy = Freedom House score
Political rights & civil liberties, modified 0 to 6 scale
“full autocracy” = 0
“full democracy” = 6
11. Development ? Democracy? Positive relationship
Fit is rather weak
Cultural-religious clusters: Protestant-Catholic, Orthodox, Muslim
13. The “Orthodox Puzzle”:An Institutional Explanation Less developed - better institutional choices: parliamentarism + party list proportional representation
More developed - worse institutional choices: presidentialism + mixed/majoritarian electoral systems
Evidence?
15. Institutional Design & Democracy in Eastern/Orthodox Countries
16. Discussion Institutional design ? democracy
Institutions matter
Evidence? Development & democracy in Orthodox post-Communist countries:
- effect of religion is controlled
- negative relationship btw development & democracy
- institutional explanation?
Yes. Different institutional choices