1 / 20

Lolke J. van der Veen DDL/Lyon 2

The western Bantu expansion Some implications for Bantu Historical Linguistics drawn from a recent multidisciplinary study. Lolke J. van der Veen DDL/Lyon 2. The WBE: implications for linguistics. The “ Language, culture and genes in Bantu ” (LCGB) project

claire
Download Presentation

Lolke J. van der Veen DDL/Lyon 2

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The western Bantu expansionSome implications for Bantu Historical Linguistics drawn from a recent multidisciplinary study Lolke J. van der Veen DDL/Lyon 2 New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  2. The WBE: implications for linguistics • The “Language, culture and genes in Bantu” (LCGB) project • Carried out as part of the OHLL & OMLL programmes (2000-2007) • Developing a multidisciplinary approach combining • Linguistics • Population genetics • Cultural anthropology • Archaeology • History New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  3. The WBE: implications for linguistics • An major contribution to the study of the populations of west-central Africa (WCA) • WCA: • The presumed homeland of the (Proto-)Bantu-speakers • A region with considerable linguistic and cultural diversity • A good test case for the “Languages and genes debate”: a fairly good understanding of the linguistic situation of the region, limited time-depth, etc. New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  4. The WBE: implications for linguistics • WCA: no longer a blank spot on the genetic map • Well-defined and very rigorous criteria were used for sampling • Extensive fieldwork (4 field missions in Gabon) • Informing the authorities and the public • (Blood) sampling in the field • Ethnolinguistic and anthropological questionnaires • 960 DNA samples + 444 from a similar project coordinated by E. Heyer & S. Bahuchet: a total of 1404 samplesfor the Gabon and Cameroon area • 980 agriculturalists (20 pops) • 420 hunter-gatherers (9 pops) New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  5. The WBE: implications for linguistics • Innovative research that has given rise to several important studies based on uniparental genomes (mtDNA, Y-chromosome) and autosomal markers • Cf. Quintana-Murci et al. (2008): Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA (PNAS) • Cf. Verdu et al. (forthcoming): relationships between the various Pygmy groups of the area New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  6. Populations and numbers of individuals sampled in Gabon Total: 960 samples from 21 populations (i.a. 1 non Bantu-speaking pop.) New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  7. The WBE: implications for linguistics • What we have been looking at • Linguistic diversity, cultural diversity and population genetic diversity (i.e. synchronic PATTERNS) • Inferences about the progressive peopling of the area based on linguistic analysis and oral tradition, submitted to population geneticists (Barcelona, Paris) • Linguistic groupings based on shared phonological, morphological and lexical innovations • Evidence of contact from the ongoing study of specialized lexicon New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  8. The languages of Gabon • Centres of gravity of indi-vidual languages and lan-guage varieties • Boundary between north-western and central-western Bantu • Eleven clusters represented (colour code) • Baka (Ubangian) ignored here! New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  9. One example of cultural diversity of Gabon: masks New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  10. The peopling of Gabon: inferred dispersal paths Bantu expansion (schematic representation and relative chro-nology) Peopling of the Gabon area by Bantu-speaking villagers as sug-gested by language studies and oral tradition (relative chronology: (1)2-5) New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  11. The WBE: implications for linguistics • What we have been looking for • Correlations between the different types of patterns (as a possible result of coevolution between languages, cultures and genes) • Scenarios capable of explaining the present human diversity (i.e. diachronic PROCESSES) • Matches between the scenarios emerging from the linguistic, cultural and genetic analyses New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  12. The WBE: implications for linguistics • The results from the genetic analyses are compatible with: • A “recent” Bantu expansion • 4,000 YBP according to the most recent archaeological findings • A Bantu homeland in the vicinity of Mount Cameroon • Cf. Quintana et al. (2008) • A western Bantu dispersal that moved southward towards the Angola / Namibia area New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  13. The WBE: implications for linguistics • There is also evidence for: (1/3) • A clear Central African origin for all the populations examined • Extensive exchange between Bantu-speakers during and following the expansion • High genetic homogeneity, no clear correlations with the current linguistic classification(s) • One exception for mtDNA: The MYENE-TSOGO (B10-B30) cluster shows a partial correlation between languages and genes • This exception can easily be accounted for by a massive integration of TSOGO female individuals into MYENE groups (known from history) • The extent of multilingualism, language replacement and language merger (and death) has clearly been underestimated New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  14. The WBE: implications for linguistics • There is also evidence for: (2/3) • Ancient and ongoing exchange between the Bantu-speaking farming villagers and the groups of hunter-gatherers • Clear signs of asymmetric paternal gene flow, from villagers to hunter-gatherers • Ancient common ancestry (cf. Quintana-Murci et al. (2008)) • Contact with *R1b-carrying populations (i.e. an non-African Y-chromosome lineage) in Central Africa before and/or during the expansion • Evidence for Fang, Punu, Teke and some other Bantu populations • This finding sheds new light on the movements and the contacts of these groups • Any linguistic traces of these contacts??? New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  15. The WBE: implications for linguistics • There is also evidence for: (3/3) • Strong social and cultural determination of the ethnolinguistic groups examined • Lineages are biologically more relevant entities • Influence of matrilineal/patrilineal descent… • Influence of polygyny… • Influence of patrilocality… New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  16. The WBE: implications for linguistics • And there is evidence against • A Sudanic (“Egyptian”) origin frequently claimed for the Bantu-speaking Fang population (Cameroon, Gabon) • The R1b* marker, which is fairly well attested among Fang male individuals, has a much older origin (contact with pops come from northern regions) • No linguistic or cultural evidence either New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  17. The WBE: implications for linguistics • Recent evidence from archaeology • Clist (2005) ; Oslisly • Ancient occupation by very small groups of hunter-gatherers • Gradual peopling by new type of population • Slow, wave-like, demic spread • Small groups of villagers practising some rudimentary form of agri-culture • Favourable environmental conditions (regression of the forest, etc.) • Effective communication networks • Different cultural traditions: pottery, ironwork, … • Migrations following the Atlantic coast and/or inland migrations New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  18. According to Clist (2005), following Maley (2001): 2,800 YBP: a sudden de-forestaton due to period of severe drought A savanna corridor and other pathways… Reforestation from 2,100 YBP on (Arrows added here.) New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  19. Ongoing and future research • Several new perspectives and challenges • The importance of taking into account the ecology of language and the sociocultural environment • Population size and population density • Geographic position (isolated, etc.) • Networks for exchange • Nature of exchange: mating, technologies, etc. • Extent of multilingualism and language replacement • Impact of cultural factors: marriage strategies, descent systems, residence strategies, local (traditonal) slavery, war and conflict, mobility, lifestyle, food resources, etc. • Etc. New Directions in Historical Linguistics

  20. Acknowledgments The organizers of NDHL ESF Funding organisms of the LCGB project (CNRS, MEC, DFG) New Directions in Historical Linguistics

More Related