1 / 19

Eugenia Mpande, Tree of Life & Craig Higson-Smith, Center for Victims of Torture

The Efficacy of Treatment Approaches for Victims and Survivors of Organised Violence and Torture within Community-Based Settings in Zimbabwe. Eugenia Mpande, Tree of Life & Craig Higson-Smith, Center for Victims of Torture. Zimbabwe: Southern Africa.

dalcorn
Download Presentation

Eugenia Mpande, Tree of Life & Craig Higson-Smith, Center for Victims of Torture

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The Efficacy of Treatment Approaches for Victims and Survivors of Organised Violence and Torture within Community-Based Settings in Zimbabwe Eugenia Mpande, Tree of Life & Craig Higson-Smith, Center for Victims of Torture

  2. Zimbabwe: Southern Africa

  3. Organised Violence and Torture in Zimbabwe Experts estimate that over 1 million Zimbabweans are living with trauma caused by violence, torture and other human rights violations. (RAU:2009) • Liberation Struggle: 1965-1980 • Gukurahundi – Southern Region of Zimbabwe: 1981-1984 • Student protests and food riots in 1990s • Land reform and land “invasions”: 2000-2006 • Operation Murambatsvina: 2005 • Election related violence: 2000, 2002, 2005, 2008 • Civil protests: 2016

  4. 2015 – 16: Torture & Violence • Increased reports of abduction & torture • > 660 cases of torture reported 2016 • 3,383 cases violations July - Sept 2016 • 47% violations by Police • Sept 2016: • 9 torture, • 57 assault, • 5 abductions

  5. Impact of OVT in Zimbabwe Long term impact on the individual • Unhealed trauma-disempowerment, apathy, helplessness, self blame, shame, depression, anxiety, anger and feelings of vengeance. • Struggling to cope and unable to function normally. • Continuous fear due to (intimidation) threats of present and future violence.

  6. Long term impact of OVT on the Community • Traumatised communities- disempowerment, fragmentation, polarisation, paralysing fear, mistrust. • Social disintegration – increased cycles of domestic violence and criminal behaviour. • Resentment, conflict – conflicts escalate. • Disengagement with community development and traditional leadership. • Culture of impunity means that perpetrator often still in community.

  7. FRAGMENTATION COMMUNITY MACRO-GRP MICRO-GRP DISEMPOWERMENT IND.

  8. About the Tree of Life Trust Tree of Life is a survivor-driven Zimbabwean organisation which provides culturally appropriate, community-based trauma healing to victims of OVT. Our Vision A healed and empowered society that puts its efforts into peace, recovery and reconciliation Who we are: We are a team of 16 core staff (“Small Tree”) & over 100 volunteer community based facilitators (“Big Tree”) spread across 16 Districts in 7 provinces. What we do: • Healing & Empowerment workshops • Psychosocial Awareness & Coping Skills (PACS) workshops • Training and Technical support to communities and to CSO’s • Support to cultural and socio-economic development initiatives • Action Research and Reflection • Collaboration with other CSO’s

  9. Conceptual model of healthy communities

  10. Two Key Interventions • HEALING WORKSHOPS • Group aims and process • Individuals is social and natural systems • Personal histories and ancestries • Formative childhood experiences and important childhood figures • Revisiting past traumatic experiences individual and shared • Connections to people and the natural world • Inner and inter-personal resources • Moving forward with life • PSYCHO-SOCIAL AWARENESS AND COPING SKILLS (PACS) • Group aims and process • How stress affects individuals, families and communities • Introduction to traumatic stress • Community reactions to traumatic events • Individual strengths and coping • Self-care strategies • Social support and helping others • Closing

  11. The impact study AIM: To estimate the impact of two TOL interventions on emotional and interpersonal functioning of torture survivors. HYPOTHESES Healing intervention > PACS workshop Both interventions > no treatment comparison MEASURES Emotional Functioning- Self-Report Questionnaire (SRQ-20) (α=0.8) Interpersonal Functioning – Zimbabwe Community Life Questionnaire (ZCLQ) (α=0.85)

  12. The impact study (cont.) THE COMMUNITIES 194 survivors from two neighbouring rural communities with a high incidence and similar histories of organized violence and torture. (Intact groups design) ASSESSMENTS Intake, 2 month and 5 month follow up Conducted by blind assessors ANALYSIS Repeated measures ANOVA with post hoc, multiple comparisons Cohen’s D effect size estimates

  13. Conclusions • The no treatment group showed a slight positive effect on emotional functioning. • Benefits of assessment and contact with caring others • Both interventions demonstrated strong positive effects on emotional functioning. • Both interventions demonstrated modest positive effects on interpersonal functioning. • Harder to shift interpersonal relationships, • Ceiling effect on the ZCLQ • TOL intervention did not demonstrate stronger effects than the PACS intervention • Common therapeutic factors – empathy, support, listening, etc. • Same facilitator team unable to unlearn core counselling behaviours

  14. Recommendations • Acknowledging that trauma is collective and societal, there is a clear need for community-based trauma healing interventions to complement the conventional clinical/ medical model, especially in communities with nested historical harms. • Funders in the trauma healing sector (and others!) should support community-based trauma healing for long term impact. • The ToL survivor-driven approach, which is structured and mentored, works because survivors have the personal experience that leads to commitment and sustainability. • In Zimbabwe, that Government adopts this model, which can be scaled up for national healing, peace-building and reconciliation.

  15. Testimony A traumatised woman who was tortured and also witnessed the brutal murder and dismemberment of her uncle reflected: “My situation got better when I attended the TOL workshop … I got to share and listen… I am now a leader and apply the skills I learnt. Every individual is important and becomes stronger if we cooperate as a family and community”.

  16. Eugenia MpandeCraig Higson-Smith Programme Manager, Tree of Life Director of Research, CVT Email: eugeniampande@tolzim.org Email: chigsonsmith@cvt.org Website: http://www.tolzim.org Website: http://www.cvt.org Thank You

More Related