1 / 9

Child work and labor. India case study

Child work and labor. India case study. Children in Developing Countries Renata Serra – March 1st. Child labor vs. child work. Child labor: ‘detrimental’ to child health and development See ILO definition Child labor: economic/productive activities

danton
Download Presentation

Child work and labor. India case study

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Child work and labor. India case study Children in Developing Countries Renata Serra – March 1st

  2. Child labor vs. child work • Child labor: ‘detrimental’ to child health and development • See ILO definition • Child labor: economic/productive activities • Child work: household, own-farm work, subsistence • NOTE: If I have not followed consistently this terminology, it is because I do not believe in it myself. But you should know it!!

  3. Is this terminological distinction important? • Yes • Need to identify the situations most at risk • Consensus is wide when fighting against labor • Child work regarded as integral part of life in many contexts (‘child socialization’) • No • Too narrow definition of the problem: child work may be exploitative too • Rigid definitions: better to look at specific instances than at broader and faulty categories • Children’s contribution to the informal economy is made invisible and unrecognized (Burra’s reading)

  4. Categories of children • Studies use different number of categories: • 2: Children working or in school • 3: Children working, in school or idle • 4: children at work only, at school only, both working and at school, idle • Defining working children as all those who are not at school thus fails to see the complexities of the situation

  5. Idle children • Children neither at school nor working • Is “idle children” a useful category? • Burra clearly is against: • Idle children are working children in disguise • Children not at school are deprived/exploited • However, data show that truly idle children exist! • Economic studies show the idle children are a product of low HH wealth, poor nutrition and health, poor quality schooling, low child ability

  6. The invisibility of child work • Large and increasing informal economy • Children’s unpaid work should be recognized as much as women’s work • Children work enables adults to take up other work (it is more productive than it appears) • Global economy is founded on sub-contracting • Most producers work in households and use child labor • Hence, attention should be paid to what happens within the household production sphere • Children may be exploited and controls are inexistent

  7. Policy implications • Different policy implications emerge according to how data are collected and interpreted: • Restrict all forms of child work • Eliminate child labor first • Improve and expand schooling • Improve child health and nutrition (to make schooling more feasible and attractive)

  8. Is a ban on child work effective? • A total ban on child work may be counterproductive as it may: • Increase the pool of “idle” children • Decrease schooling for children both at work & school • Increase poverty in the short term and thus diminish future child potential • More effective interventions are: • Increasing household productivity and income • Improving schooling quality • Improving labor markets (esp. for the young) • Introducing technology that substitutes for child work

More Related