1 / 12

Compatibility of National Policies and Trade Agreements: Concepts, Issues, and Approaches

Compatibility of National Policies and Trade Agreements: Concepts, Issues, and Approaches Julian M. Alston and Daniel A Sumner Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics University of California, Davis Silverado Symposium on Agricultural Policy Reform Napa, California

ecaron
Download Presentation

Compatibility of National Policies and Trade Agreements: Concepts, Issues, and Approaches

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Compatibility of National Policies and Trade Agreements:Concepts, Issues, and Approaches Julian M. Alston and Daniel A Sumner Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics University of California, Davis Silverado Symposium on Agricultural Policy Reform Napa, California January 19, 2004

  2. Key Points • Policy compatibility requires policy reform • Political economy – influences on • Current policies • Possibilities for reform • Compensation as an element of reform • Feasibility • Efficiency and Equity • Policy reform complements • Transparency institutions • Adjustment assistance

  3. Achieving Compatibility • EEC/EU Common Agricultural Policy • Common external tariff • Harmonized national policies • CUSTA and NAFTA • Some adjustments (e.g., ???) • Some exemptions (e.g., supply managed) • Some trade disputes (e.g., wheat)

  4. Explaining Policies:Efficient Redistribution • Interest-group theory • Policy serves to redistribute income to relatively powerful interest groups • Efficient redistribution • Transfers involve net social costs • Policies chosen to minimize cost of given transfer • Implications for policy reform • Nature of feasible reforms • Prescriptive role for economists (and others)?

  5. PS DWL A PSA ΔPSA E PSE 45o Line STC 0 CTSA CTSE CTS ΔCTS Efficient Redistribution through Commodity Programs PS 0

  6. Extensions to the Model • More than two groups • Other elements of costs • Introduction and implementation of policies • Administration and enforcement of policies • Costs of change • Policy inertia • Dynamic version of efficient redistribution

  7. PS A PSA IC ΔPSA E PSE A’ F STC 0 CTSA CTSE CTS ΔCTS Policy Choice PS 0

  8. Implications of Free Trade • Change in STC • Feasible instruments • Economy-wide, general-equilibrium effects • Dynamic efficiency gains • Changes in political “preferences” • Change in equilibrium

  9. PS E’ F’ E F STC STC’ 0 CTS Effects of Free Trade on STCs and Policy Equilibrium PS 0

  10. Economics of Compensation • Actual versus potential compensation • Least-cost compensation – Quotas • R = [r + p + g(p)]V • R/V = 20-30 % (V = 3-5 times R, say) • p + g(p) = 15-20 %? • Other issues • Capitalization more generally • Efficiency and fairness • Implementation problems (compensation seeking) • Source and form of compensation

  11. Other Policies • Transparency institutions • Australia’s Industries Assistance Commission • IAC versus other factors in Australia • ABARE • Adjustment assistance • Australia’s Rural Adjustment Scheme • RAS as a foil for ad hoc assistance

  12. Conclusion • Redistributive commodity policies involve net social costs • Compensation should be feasible • Partial compensation may be sufficient • Policy reform may be facilitated by institutional innovations • Transparency institutions • Adjustment assistance

More Related