1 / 16

Linguistic Rights Today in Three Spheres of Justice:

Linguistic Rights Today in Three Spheres of Justice:. Balancing Practices and Policies in University Contexts Yvonne Hébert (U Calgary & Wilfrid Denis ( U Sask ) 2012 Conference, Canadian Sociology Association. Linguistic Rights in Three Spheres of Justice.

eve
Download Presentation

Linguistic Rights Today in Three Spheres of Justice:

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Linguistic Rights Today in Three Spheres of Justice: Balancing Practices and Policies in University Contexts Yvonne Hébert (U Calgary & Wilfrid Denis ( U Sask) 2012 Conference, Canadian Sociology Association

  2. Linguistic Rights in Three Spheres of Justice • Presentation by Wilfrid Denis (St. Thomas More College, U Saskatchewan) and Yvonne Hébert (University of Calgary) • Session on Academic Freedom, with Terry Gillin, Chair. • Annual Conference of the Canadian Sociology Association • 29 May – 02 June, 2012 • University of Waterloo & Wilfrid Laurier University

  3. INTRODUCTION Part one

  4. 1. Introduction • Recognition of linguistic rights for OLM in Canada - educ reform • Charter and Official Lgs Act silent on access to post-secondary education in OLM • Issues of recognition, organization & delivery of French language instruction vary across English-dominant Canada • Tripartite model of social justice (N. Fraser, 2009) • Focus: embedded faculty member & program in AB & SK

  5. Justice as a meta-framework Part two

  6. Fraser’s types of justice & Remedies, 1995

  7. Tripartite model of social justice (2009, 2010) • Redistribution in the economic sphere - issues of misdistribution • Recognition in the socio-cultural sphere - issues of misrecognition • Representation in the political sphere - issues of misrepresentation, misframing • Who? What? How? - criteria for decision making • All subjected principle

  8. Purpose of our Paper • To apply the three-part Nancy Fraser model (2009, 2010) at a medium range or institutional level, rather than at the abstract, global level • Anticipated problems of categorization into types • Questions of who, what and how difficult to establish • Incomplete hegemony, open to slippage • Institutional incoherence, contradictions • Who has right to make claims & nature of such claims

  9. National Context of Post-sec institutions • Two official languages enshrined in the Canadian constitution • Section 23 on official minority language rights • AUCC, University Affairs operate in both official languages • CAUT/ACPPU also supportive - bilingual national organization (Allain, 2008) • Tangible support over the years for French language in university and post-secondary institutions • CAUT – only 5/45 presidents were Francophones • CAUT instituted a Francophone Committee & designated a Francophone position on its Executive, both in 2004 • Parallel movements in Québec & Canada • CSA ceased French language communication in 2012 with office move, QC to ON

  10. Sorting out 3 questions: who, what, how ? • WHAT? • Nature, extent, significance of justice claims increase as faculty members move on continuum from #1 to #5 • Direct impact on working conditions • Teaching, research & publication, and community service tend to be reduced in significance on continuum, #1 to #5 • Lack of weight given to Francophone faculty member’s dossier • WHO ? • ~ 2000-3500 individuals teaching in French in Anglophone Universities • Institutional arrangements between oppressed & oppressor • Continuum of institutional settings: • 1. Stand alone U • 2. Bilingual U • 3. Federated College • 4. Minority Units • 5. Embedded units/persons

  11. Sorting out 3 Questions: Who, What, How? • Four dimensions: • Absence of French lg services pertaining to research • Absence of Frlg services for students • Obligation to translate towards English • Erasure of Francophone presence, participation and worth • HOW? • Course & program approval structures; • Performance Reports; • Merit, tenure, promotion procedures; • Two cases: • U Calgary, U Saskatchewan

  12. Interpretation

  13. Interpretation • Three dimensions to be emphasized in considering two cases: • Difficulty of determining instances of misdistribution or economic penalties, i.e., so serious as to attract an appeal; possible silencing of such possible claims; invisibility of French language issues in these universities; • Anti-hegemonic forces may be more astute in their strategies and frame these in a broader framework, unforeseen by Fraser; • Efforts to reframe these issues so as to raise the profile of French as a national language on Anglophone universities, a political gesture that challenges Anglo-dominant hegemony; • Governancestructures tend to reduce scope, scale of those subjected whereas oppressed groups tend to prefer broader definitions

  14. conclusions Part six

  15. Conclusions • Interplay between economic, political & cultural dimensions are very complex • Issues of recognition seem to impact on economic and political issues • Tendency for issues to take on a collective dimension, not just the sum of isolated individual experiences • All subjected, all affected principles need more reflection as the benign takes on greater proportions in hindsight (or with greater insight?) • Effects of limitations discussed herein amount to forms of surveillance and control of French and Francophone scholars, in the ‘conduct of conduct’ • Scholars & students are disciplined to accept to be minoritized, to being subject to lacks of representation, recognition & redistribution

  16. Linguistic Rights Today in Three Spheres of Justice: Balancing Practices and Policies in University Contexts Yvonne Hébert (U Calgary & Wilfrid Denis ( U Sask) 2012 Conference, Canadian Sociology Association

More Related