1 / 28

Measuring Cosmic Shear Sarah Bridle Dept of Physics & Astronomy, UCL

Measuring Cosmic Shear Sarah Bridle Dept of Physics & Astronomy, UCL. What is cosmic shear? Why is it hard to measure? The international competition Overview of conventional approaches Our approach. Gravitational Lensing.  = 4 G M / (c 2 b). b. . M. Extremely rare!.

flavio
Download Presentation

Measuring Cosmic Shear Sarah Bridle Dept of Physics & Astronomy, UCL

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Measuring Cosmic ShearSarah BridleDept of Physics & Astronomy, UCL What is cosmic shear? Why is it hard to measure? The international competition Overview of conventional approaches Our approach

  2. Gravitational Lensing  = 4 G M / (c2 b) b  M

  3. Extremely rare!

  4. Distribution of matter • According to simulations • NB. is mostly dark

  5. Cosmic Shear: Qualitative Tyson et al 2002 • Massively exaggerated

  6. Cosmic Shear: Quantitative • Gravitational lensing by typical patches of Universe • ~~ matrix distortion of each galaxy image • / gravitating mass density • i(x) = ∫(x’) Wi(x-x’) dA • Cosmic shear:  ~ 0, i ~ 0.01 • e.g. circular galaxy → ellipse with a/b ~ 1.01

  7. What do we want to learn from cosmic shear? • Distribution of dark matter • And hence infer • Amount of dark matter • Clumpiness of universe after inflation • Amount of dark energy • Equation of state of the dark energy • But is the current model right? • 95 per cent of the Universe is a mystery • Dark energy does not make sense • We hope to gain clues to help a new Einstein

  8. Deep optical images William Herschel Telescope La Palma, Canaries

  9. Typical galaxy used for cosmic shear analysis Typical star

  10. Variable background Diffraction spikes Typical galaxy used for cosmic shear analysis Saturated star Typical star

  11. Why is this hard? • Galaxies are not circles or ellipses • Galaxy orientations may align during formation • Telescope and atmosphere convolve image = point spread function (psf) • spatially varying • time varying • CCD responsivity, cosmic rays, metors, unresolved sources, variable atmosphere, saturated stars • Pixelisation of images (~sum of light over pixel) • Partial and patchy sky coverage • We don’t have galaxy distances • Mass distribution is not Gaussian

  12. Why is this hard? • Galaxies are not circles or ellipses • Galaxy orientations may align during formation • Telescope and atmosphere convolve image = point spread function (psf) • spatially varying • time varying • CCD responsivity, cosmic rays, metors, unresolved sources, variable atmosphere, saturated stars • Pixelisation of images (~sum of light over pixel) • Partial and patchy sky coverage • We don’t have galaxy distances • Mass distribution is not Gaussian

  13. Ellipticities of the non-saturated stars WHT Bacon, Refregier & Ellis 2000

  14. Ellipticities of the non-saturated stars WHT Bacon, Refregier & Ellis 2000

  15. CTIO BTC Jarvis & Jain 2005

  16. CTIO BTC Jarvis & Jain 2005

  17. Conventional approach: Split into several parts • Find convolution kernel using stars • Measure galaxy shapes using kernel • Obtain noisy shear estimate per galaxy • Apply statistic • Averages out intrinsic galaxy shapes • e.g. mean shear in circular aperture • Predict statistic from theory • Calculate 2 between observation and prediction • Estimate cosmological parameters

  18. Conventional approach: Split into several parts • Find convolution kernel using stars • Measure galaxy shapes using kernel • Obtain noisy shear estimate per galaxy • Apply statistic • Averages out intrinsic galaxy shapes • e.g. mean shear in circular aperture • Predict statistic from theory • Calculate 2 between observation and prediction • Estimate cosmological parameters

  19. Weakly Lensed Galaxies

  20. Shear TEsting Programme (STEP) • Started July 2004 • Is the shear estimation problem solved or not? • Series of international blind competitions • Start with simple simulated data (STEP1) • Make simulations increasingly realistic • Real data • Current status: • STEP 1: simplistic galaxy shapes (Heymans et al 2005) • STEP 2: more realistic galaxies (Massey et al 2006) • STEP 3: difficult (space telescope) kernel (2007) • STEP 4: back to basics

  21. Heymans et al 2005

  22. STEP4 simplifications • Kernel is constant across the image • Star positions are known approximately • Galaxy positions are known approximately • No overlapping galaxies • Galaxy/star classification known • Shear is same for all galaxies • Stars and galaxies have elliptical isophotes • Noise level constant across the image

  23. How STEP4 images are made • Decide galaxy, star positions and profiles • Convolve galaxies with kernel • Pixelise (integrate light over square pixel) • Add random Gaussian noise to each pixel • ~1,000,000 galaxies in total

  24. Kaiser, Squires & Broadhurst 1995 • The only currently widely used method • Interpolate Psh and Psm using polynomial

  25. Shapelets – a popular bet for the future • Laguerre polynomials • Nice QM formalism • Lensing distortion has simple effect • psf convolution can be removed by matrix multiplication Massey & Refregier 2004

  26. Our approach • Use other software to locate stars and galaxies • chop out e.g. a 16x16 postage stamp • Fit a sum of elliptical Gaussians to each star • Fit a sum of concentric elliptical Gaussians to each galaxy image • convolved with average shapes of ~5 nearest stars e.g. Bridle, Kneib, Bardeau, Gull 2001

  27. Conclusions • Cosmic shear → the nature of dark energy / other • Images of the sky → cosmic shear • The statistics problem is what limits us • Cosmic shear community is relatively small • Benchmark simulations now exist • Many astronomers and cosmologists doubt that these problems will ever be overcome

More Related