Hero or Villain?

1. The guillotine Write down: 5 things you notice about this painting Hero or Villain?

2. Pre-Guillotine Forms 0f Execution"Why was the guillotine invented?”“Was the guillotine a good thing?”

3. Hanging Reserved for the lower classes Resulted in a slow strangulation Neck breaking techniques had not been developed yet

4. Burned at the Stake All religious heretics were burned at the stake A merciful executioner would strangle the condemned before the flames engulfed them

5. Broken on the Wheel Condemned would be strapped to the wheel and tortured or put to the “Question” Used on murderers and bandits to determine whether or not they acted alone

6. Drawn and Quartered Used for criminals convicted of assaulting the King or a member of the clergy It was the final blow in the condemned’s execution They were first put to the question Then hanged till near death When near death they were drawn and quartered as a final insult Often required the executioner to sever the victims tendons before the horses could accomplish the task

7. Beheading Reserved only for nobility Performed with either a sword or an axe Often took multiple swings resulting in a gruesome and painful experience for all involved

8. Humanitarian Intentions

9. Dr. Joseph Ignace Guillotin Invented the most famous execution devise of the French Revolution. He left the Jesuit order in 1763 to pursue the study of medicine In 1770 he received his doctorate

10. Guillotin's Six Articles • Article 1. Crimes of the same kind shall be punished by the same kinds of punishment, whatever the rank or estate of the criminal. • Article 2. Offenses and crimes are personal, and no stain shall attach to the family from the criminal’s execution or loss of civil rights. The members of the family are in no way dishonored and remain, without exception, eligible for all kinds of profession, employment and civic dignity. • Article 3. Under no circumstances whatever may order be made of the confiscation of the goods of a condemned man. • Article 4. The body of the executed man shall be returned to the family, should the family so request. Normal burial shall in all cases be permitted and the register shall not specify the circumstances of the death. • Article 5. No one may reproach a citizen with the execution or loss of civil rights incurred by a relative. Should anyone dare to do so, he shall be reprimanded by a judge. • Article 6. The method of punishment shall be the same for all persons on whom the law shall pronounce a sentence of death, whatever the crime of which they are guilty. The criminal shall be decapitated. Decapitation is to be effected by a simple mechanism.

11. Birth of the Guillotine • Guillotin’s sixth article was passed 3 June 1791 • Despite passing it would be nearly a year before the guillotine would take its place as France’s official method of execution • After much delay, Dr. Antoine Louis, the permanent secretary of the Academy of Surgery, was enlisted to design the simple mechanism • Design was given to Tobias Schmidt a German harpsichord maker • Guillotine was first tested on three corpses at Bicêtre Hospital on 17 April 1792 • It failed to sever the neck of the last corpse a particularly large man due to the convex shape of the blade • There is an ironic story that says Louis XVI suggested that the blade should be oblique • Story was told by Clément-Henri Sanson and later it is included in Alexandre Dumas’ book, The Tragedies of 1793

12. Guillotine 1792 Designed by Dr. Antoine Louis Permanent Secretary of the Academy of Surgery Machine was originally called louison or louisette in his honor Painted red to hide the blood Was placed on a tall scaffold in order for crowd to have a better view

13. Diagram of the Guillotine

14. The Guillotine at Work

15. The Last Day of the Condemned The condemned is not told ahead of time and instead are dragged from their cell the morning of while still asleep They are allowed a final meal and a chance to write a letter to loved ones Next they are given the toilette du condamne The collar of the shirt is removed and their hair is cut above the neck Loaded in cart and paraded through Paris on their way to the Guillotine Once there it takes only seconds from the moment they step on the stairs

16. 25 April 1792 the guillotine takes its’ first live victim, Nicolas Jacques Pelletier, an armed robber At the guillotines first appearance a massive crowd gathered to witness the event From the time the condemned mounted the scaffold till his death was less than a minute Crowd was disappointed by this. This attitude would quickly change as the number of executions rapidly grew During the revolution it is estimated that nearly 40,000 people were executed by the guillotine The Spectacle

17. The End of the Grand Show • The Guillotine would remain a public spectacle well into the 20th century • The government tried to reduce the visibility of public executions • First by removing the guillotine from atop the scaffold • Painting it a dark brown instead of the bright red of revolutionary times • Executions began to take place in the early morning in an attempt to lessen the crowds • In 1939 the government finally put a halt to public executions and moved the guillotine inside the walls of the prison • The guillotine would remain in use until capital punishment was abolished in 1981 • The last execution took place on 10 September 1977

18. The Reign of Terror • The Reign of Terror began in June of 1793 • It would transform the guillotine, which had been derived from humanitarian intentions, from a machine of justice into a tool the revolutionaries would use to spread fear • The revolutionary tribunal would use the guillotine to dispatch all enemies of the revolution including: • Nobility • Clergy • Anyone not sharing their views • The Terror would witness the rise and fall of many prominent French revolutionaries and ultimately their death beneath the blade • It would end with the execution of Maximillien Robespierre, the architect of the Terror

19. Maximilien Robespierre Born in Arras in 1758 He was a prominent lawyer and orator Originally argued to abolish capital punishment During the Revolution he rapidly put himself in a prominent position as the leader of the Jacobins During the Reign of Terror he acted as a de-facto emperor Used the guillotine to eliminate anyone he saw as an enemy of the revolution After the fall of the Jacobins he too fell to the guillotine on 27 July 1794

20. Essay • Argumentative Writing: • “Do you believe that the guillotine should be remembered as a symbol of horror, or as a symbol of the new equality in France? 8-10 sentences Ticket out the door

21. The Head Lives On

22. Charlotte Corday She killed Jean-Paul Marat He was known for his radical journal “The Peoples Journal” A leading member of the revolutionaries who was loved by the people She was taken to the guillotine dressed in red, which was normally reserved for those who commit regicide After being beheaded the assistant executioner lifted her head from the basket and slapped it It is said that her face blushed and became filled with indignation This led to the belief that the head survives for some time after decapitation

23. Tales of Living Heads • Allegedly from an account of Sanson • Two opposing members of the National Assembly were executed on the same day. Their heads were placed in the same sack at which point one bit the other so hard that their heads could not be separated • In 1880 Dr. Dassy de Ligniéres went as far as to pump blood from a living dog into the severed head of Louis Menesclou • He witness the face redden and the lips swell at which point he announced, “This head is about to speak” • In 1905 Dr. Beaurieux addressed a recently severed head by calling his name • On the first time he witnessed the eyelids open and the pupils focus on him • He called out a second time and again the eyelids opened and the head looked at him with “unmistakably alive eyes” • The doctor attempted a third time but received no reaction • As late as 1956 similar experiments were being carried out on recently severed heads

24. Guillotine Parody

25. Victim's Ball In order to attend one had to prove they had a family member that was guillotined People would forge documentation Guests dressed à la victime Women wore dresses with large red x’s across their upper back Both women and men would were red ribbon or red thread around there neck They also cut there hair to imitate the toilette du condamne They would greet each other by abruptly dropping their head- as if it had just been cut off

26. Hairstyles à la Victime

27. Guillotine in French Literature

28. Victor Hugo In 1820 he wrote “The Last Day of a Condemned Man” It is written as if it was a manuscript written by a condemned man and left behind in his cell It describes what he felt would be a truly nightmarish ordeal It also plays an ominous role in Hugo’s “Les Miserables”

29. Alexandre Dumas Wrote “The Tragedies of 1793” “The Woman With the Velvet Collar” In which a man falls in love with a beautiful stranger wearing a velvet collar He spends the night with her and in the middle of lovemaking her head falls off It was only held on by the collar

30. Villiers de L'Isle Adam He wrote the “Eleventh Hour Guest” A story in which a guillotine enthusiast pays to perform the duties of the executioner Took a contrasting position to Hugo and Dumas Believed that by removing the guillotine from the scaffold you cheapened the condemned’s death and robbed them of their stage

31. Work Cited Arasse, Daniel. The Guillotine and the Terror. Trans. Christopher Miller. London: The Penguin Press, 1989. "Axe, Wheel, Guillotine: Seven Generations of Executioners." New York Times 4 June 1876: 10. Fife, Graeme. The Terror: Under the Shadow of the Guillotine. New York: St. Martin's Press, 2004. Gerould, Daniel. Guillotine: It's Legend and Lore. New York: Blast Books Inc., 1992. Opie, Robert Frederick. Guillotine. Phoenix Mill: Sutton Publishing Limited, 2003. Soubiran, André. The Good Dr. Guillotin and His Strange Device. Trans. Malcolm MacCraw. London: Souvenir Press, 1964.