1 / 18

Active Pension Participation & Household Wealth Accumulation:

Active Pension Participation & Household Wealth Accumulation:. Evidence of Learning by Doing. Jason S. Seligman Carl Vinson Institute of Government University of Georgia & Rana Bose Department of Economics University of Georgia. Pension Savings Risk & DC Plans.

gervaise
Download Presentation

Active Pension Participation & Household Wealth Accumulation:

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Active Pension Participation & Household Wealth Accumulation: Evidence of Learning by Doing Jason S. Seligman Carl Vinson Institute of Government University of Georgia & Rana Bose Department of Economics University of Georgia

  2. Pension Savings Risk & DC Plans Protect workers from some DB risks • Greater mobility for workers • Less dependence on firm as trustee Have emerged as equity market participation increased • Empirics Suggest Lack of Perfect Information • Persistent Non Participation Puzzle however (50%) • Less than optimal use of risky assets • Average balances in DC Plans may be smaller… Big question remains: What are totalimpacts of these plans for savings?

  3. DC Impacts on Non-Pension Savings? Two Related Questions: -1- Do DC Plan Participants Save Differently? -2- Do Particular Plan Features Impact Savings? • Self Direction (Choice) • Plan Sponsored Education Efforts Two Basic Outcome Measures: -1- Portfolio Allocations -2- Wealth Outcomes

  4. Pension Savings Literature -- Common Themes CHOICE: underutilized -- misapplied Inertia -- Default Bias Madrian & Shea (2001) Naïve (1/N) Diversification Benartzi & Thaler (2001) EDUCATION: some promise of improving Participation Bernheim & Garrett (1996) Participation & Diversification Choi Laibson Madrian (2002) DC & PRIVATE SAVINGS impact outside of plan Increases in Equity Holdings Weisbrenner (2002) Impact on Allocations Friedberg & Webb (2006)

  5. Data • HRS RAND version D -- Public Use Data • Self Reported Pension Characteristics: • Plan Type • Choice • Financial Education (in 1992, and 2000) • Respondent Characteristics: • Risk Preferences (Low, Med, High) • Planning Horizon • Bequest Probabilities • Subjective Retirement Age Probabilities • Usual Socio Economic Controls • Follow a sample from the Initial Cohort through 6 Waves (‘02)

  6. Basic Correlates Risky Asset Ownership & Plan Features Risky Assets ≡ stocks, bonds, mutual funds

  7. Non-Plan Financial Asset Levels at RetirementDistributions by Plan Attributes

  8. Random Effects Probit Estimator Where: -1- yit measures ownership of an asset class: {risky, safe, retirement} -2- Xincludes: age, wealth quartile, income, income squared, age cohort, socio-economic characteristics, pension plan participation by type, IRA ownership, occupation, industry, Census region, and time dummies -3- Di is our binary indicator for attending financial education or having choice in the individuals DC plan (s). -4- With the RE Probit we have: and:

  9. RE Probit Results Impacts of Employer Plans by Plan Type Notes: -1- t statistics reported below estimated correlates. -2- Controls included from model in previous slide.

  10. RE Probit Results Interacting Choice & Financial Education • Notes: • -1- t statistics reported below estimated correlates. • -2- Saving preference controls do not significantly impact patterns above: • Risk Preference • Planning Horizon • Bequest Motive.

  11. Multivariate ProbitSimultaneous Asset Allocation Decisions Notes: -1- SE’s statistics reported below estimated correlates. -2- Controls again included but suppressed in presentation above. -3- Estimation employs Geweke, Hajivassiliou &Keane (GHK) simulator,

  12. Multivariate ProbitSimultaneous Asset Allocation DecisionsHousing Included Notes: -1- t statistics reported below estimated correlates. -2- Controls again included but suppressed in presentation above. -3- Estimation employs Geweke, Hajivassiliou &Keane (GHK) simulator,

  13. Propensity Score Matching Estimator Ideally we wish to measure the average treatment effect: E(Y1|D = 1) − E(Y0|D = 0) Where Y1 is the treated subset of households Y. However the treatment should not be assumed to be random. We thus first estimate a household’s probability of treatment, given its observed covariates. Propensity Score Estimator

  14. PSM: Matching Observations • We match our treated and untreated households on: • age cohort, education, race; • marital status; • a binary indicator for dual earner couples; • DC plan, DB plan, and/or IRA plan participation; • an indicator for poor health; • preferences for risk, and financial planning horizon; • earnings, and net household wealth. • We employ kernel matching: • This weights our match so as to make the very best use of a relatively large non-treatment group to create composites

  15. PSM Estimation Simultaneous Asset Allocation DecisionsHousing Included Notes: -1- t statistics reported below estimated correlates.

  16. Summary of Findings • Exposure to pension plans and their features are associated with changes in savings habits outside of plan. • increases in portfolio diversity • positive impacts on wealth • Impacts are found with a variety of methods and controls • Implications: • ‘Failing to Plan => Planning to Fail’ • Low levels of saving and inertia • Concern for how different groups might manage public pension program changes

  17. Thank You Please contact us with further comments and questions Corresponding Author: Jason Seligman seligman@cviog.uga.edu 706. 542. 6252

More Related