1 / 12

Marlene Zuk – Feminist Biologist

Marlene Zuk – Feminist Biologist. Use of animal models in evolutionary theory Extreme variation among animals Precludes simplistic generalizations about sex roles Argues against gender stereotypes Maternal ‘instinct’ Harlows ’ experiments with monkeys

illias
Download Presentation

Marlene Zuk – Feminist Biologist

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Marlene Zuk – Feminist Biologist • Use of animal models in evolutionary theory • Extreme variation among animals • Precludes simplistic generalizations about sex roles • Argues against gender stereotypes • Maternal ‘instinct’ • Harlows’ experiments with monkeys • Mothering is learned, not instinctive • Natural ≠ good • Use of cultural terms to describe animal behavior • Anthropomorphizing  tautology • Cultural prejudices & stereotypes

  2. Evolutionary Psychology • Multiple, rather than single gene • Brain evolved in separate parts • Environment of evolutionary adaptedness (EEA) • Evolved brain interacts with modern environment • Both ‘nature’ & ‘nurture’

  3. The Gene as Cultural Icon • Political agendas and personal biases • History of misuse • ‘Sexiness’ of genetic explanations • Human brains evolved to be flexible, rely on learning • Biology may set broad parameters • No uniform or universal implications of biological differences • Social factors more often used to explain gender differences

  4. Feminist anthropology 1970s • Focus on women to correct androcentric ethnographic record • Causes of women’s universal subordination • Cultural explanations for gender asymmetry • Cultural universals • Material and ideational origins • Symbolic systems of meaning & differential values • Biological differences  unequal cultural evaluations • Claude Lévi-Strauss – Structuralism • Binary opposition • Cultural interpretations of biological attributes • Values and meanings assigned via binary contrasts

  5. Ortner - Nature/Culture • Sherry Ortner (1974) • “Is Female to Male as Nature is to Culture?” • Simone de Beauvoir – The Second Sex (1953) • “Woman is not born, but made” • Gender as cultural construct • Western categories • e.g. male & female, Self & Other • Women’s bodies interpreted as ‘natural’ by male-dominated culture

  6. Ortner - Nature/Culture • Sherry Ortner (1974) • “Is Female to Male as Nature is to Culture?” • Women’s universal devaluation due to association with nature • Women’s body and procreation = nature • Men exhibit creativity externally = culture • Men transcend nature, make culture • Human society result of conquest of nature by culture

  7. Self/Other • Self/Other = Men/Women • Women defined by their bodies • Men free of body; selfhood = “not woman” • Women trapped in body, men transcend it • Women defined by lack • Western dichotomies • Deprive women of autonomous selfhood • Define men as central actors in culture • Women as inferior • Men: subject, active • Women: object, passive • Bodies central to self perception

  8. Critique of Ortner • Assumption of universal devaluation • Men’s view • Universality of binary thinking • Universal meanings of nature/culture • Diversity and complexity of gender and conceptual systems

  9. Kimmel & Cross-cultural Research • Male domination as ‘near universal’ • Correlations without resort to biology • Biological model • Cultural variations • Andro- and ethnocentric biases • Effects of colonialism • Cause and effect • Gender inequality  gender difference • Similar biology has different outcomes • Gender differences culturally constructed

  10. Social and Cultural Determinants • Division of labor • Functionalist view • Evolutionary imperative • Change and variability • Ideologically sustained • Male power • Marx/Engels – historical materialism • Social evolution • Primitive communism  feudalism capitalism • Private property and inheritance • Nuclear family and control of women • Rise of nation-state

  11. Friedrich Engels • Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State (1884) • Women’s status declines with: • Private property • Production for exchange (surplus) • Early communal society • No private property, no nuclear family • Sexual division of labor, but for group • No domestic/public divide • Men and women equal producers • Sedentarization emergence of private ownership • Nuclear, patriarchal family • Productive, economic, decision-making unit • Competition • Economic differences (inequality) emerge

  12. Engels’s Historical Narrative • Primitive clan-based society (primitive communism) • Production for use-value • No class differentiation • Domestic labor also public labor • Gender equality • Advent of private property • Men’s control of animals and land • Family carved out from clan unit • Domestic/public, division of labor • Women’s work devalued, become dependent • Production for exchange • Become more important than production for subsistence • Increased class and gender differentiation • The State • Bourgeoisie and proletariats

More Related