1 / 14

SUFFERING

SUFFERING. A presentation of several different philosophical approaches to the problem of pain and suffering.

jaques
Download Presentation

SUFFERING

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. SUFFERING A presentation of several different philosophical approaches to the problem of pain and suffering. Philosophies to be discussed: Eudaemonism, Epicureanism, Stoicism, Reactionary Philosophies to German Idealism, Utilitarianism, Analytic, British Empiricism,

  2. Eudaemonism • Not a whole philosophical system, only an ethical system • Eudaemonistic: Directed toward happiness; Spiritual directedness toward the good -Eu means good, Daemon means prophetic spirit • One cannot do evil for evil’s sake, act for a supposed good • Plato is first to posit a eudaemonistic ethical system -Knowledge is a virtue that always prevails over pleasure and everything else for the good -Decisions should be made with good/evil in mind because pleasure/pain is bodily ~Decisions based on pleasure arise from ignorance

  3. Eudaemonism • Aristotle expands upon eudaemonistic ethics -Final cause of every action is aimed at some good -Happiness is final end of man -Happiness is desired in itself and never for the sake of something else -Happiness: an activity of the soul in accordance with perfect/complete virtue in a whole life complemented by external goods -By including external goods in definition, Aristotle allows pain to be the destroyer of happiness -Virtue for Aristotle is either Moral (the perfection of our appetites, including the will) or Intellectual (perfection of the mind and how we think)

  4. Stoicism • Zeno is founder of the Stoics • For Stoics, virtue is freedom from both pain and pleasure -Thus able to retain happiness and virtue even during pain • Stoicism preaches a resignation (apathea) to fate -Fate: the rational principle within all things that determines what is going to happen

  5. Epicureans • Epicureus is the founder • Final cause of man is the seeking of pleasure -Peace of soul/mind: absence of pain through a lifetime • Two types of pleasure -Kinetic: actions taken to remove pain ~Natural and Necessary, Natural and Unnecessary, Unnatural and Unnecessary -Static: pleasure in and of itself (the greater of the two) • Highest pleasure is health of the body and peace of soul • Pain is allowable if it will lead to greater pleasure later -Thus prudence is the greatest of man’s virtues

  6. British Empiricism • Influences -Nominalism of William of Ockham -Empirical method of Francis Bacon -Hobbesian epistemology and language • Three main philosophers: Locke, Berkeley, Hume • Concern ourselves with David Hume -Lived 1711 – 1776 -Considered culmination of British Empiricism -Ethics is one of empirical skepticism

  7. British Empiricism • Empirical skepticism: the discounting of a thing if there is no empirical knowledge -Thus all causality and logical knowledge is denied • Ethics based on pleasure/pain and feeling -Question: how to go from “man is…” to “man ought…” -Answer: individual experience and passions ~The moral quality of all actions is based in emotions from prior experiences • Primary motion is sympathy -Definition: the feeling within us that we must do something for a fellow human -Customs and laws result from sympathy, not universal

  8. Reactions to German Idealism • Feuerbach, Schopenhauer, Kierkegaard, and Nietzsche • Philosophies were reactions to Hegelian Idealism • We will focus on Arthur Schopenhauer -Lived 1788 – 1860 -Fascinated with the Idealism of Plato -Studied under Fichte -Opponent to Hegel

  9. Reactions to German Idealism • Schopenhauer provides the basis for Nietzsche’s philosophy • Ultimate goal of man is to escape from individual existence and limitations on universal will -Through the exercise of the will, we create reality • Assertion of the will over all things -Thus suicide is okay because it shows a stronger will than individual existence • Pain/pleasure are inconsequential unless they affect the will -Will should never be limited -Should not act for pain/pleasure but for assertion of the will

  10. Utilitarianism • Three main figures: Bentham, James Mill, and James Stuart Mill • Bentham is considered the father of Utilitarianism -Lived 1748 – 1832 -Pleasure/pain are the only principles by which we should analyze our actions • Hedonistic Calculus -Bentham’s system to determine how one should act -Calculation of how to bring the greatest amount of pleasure with the least amount of pain -No qualitative difference between pleasure/pain -Reduce everything to quantity and mathematics

  11. Utilitarianism • The main factors in Bentham’s hedonistic calculus -Intensity: How intense is the pleasure -Duration: How long does the pleasure last -Certainty: Probability pleasure will occur -Propinquity: How far in the future is the pleasure -Fecundity: Probablity this pleasure will lead to other pleasures -Purity: How unmixed with pain is the pleasure -Extent: How many persons are affected by the pleasure • Bentham’s equation: - {N [P(c) (I ´ D)]  +  Nf  [P(c)f  (If´ Df)]}

  12. Utilitarianism • John Stuart Mill formerly defines philosophy of Utilitarianism -Utility is the basis of morals • Pleasure for Mill, unlike Bentham, is not all equal -Pleasure/pain has different amounts, not universal -Thus rejects Bentham’s hedonistic calculus • Happiness is the highest good -Man naturally acts for happiness and is attracted to it • Must look at what will bring the greatest pleasure, least pain within society • Criterion of harm: a person is at liberty to pursue whichever of his desires causes no harm to his fellow human beings

  13. Analytic Philosophy • Reaction against British and American Idealism • Main philosophers: Bertrand Russell, G. E. Moore, and Ludwig Wittgenstein • Russell considered father of analytic philosophy -Rejects unity of reality ~Everything is separate, no universality of things • Wittgenstein is figurehead -Writes Tractus Logico-Philosophicus • Focus on the Principia Ethica of G. E. Moore (1873 – 1958)

  14. Analytic Philosophy • Principia Ethica -Ethics of analytic philosophy • Naturalistic fallacy: attempt to define the good that cannot be -Impossible because trying to apply rationality to the will, passions, and emotions -Thus nothing can be said to be good • One can act out of pleasure/pain because there is no good -Everything needs to be treated individually

More Related