1 / 26

Integrating Basic Government into Graduate Programs for Non-Traditional Learners

Integrating Basic Government into Graduate Programs for Non-Traditional Learners. Emergency Management Higher Education Conference Emmitsburg, MD, June 6-9, 2011 Thomas E. Poulin, Ph.D. Capella University. Graduate Focus. Undergraduates Program focus is on working within discipline

johntallen
Download Presentation

Integrating Basic Government into Graduate Programs for Non-Traditional Learners

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Integrating Basic Government into Graduate Programs for Non-Traditional Learners Emergency Management Higher Education Conference Emmitsburg, MD, June 6-9, 2011 Thomas E. Poulin, Ph.D. Capella University

  2. Graduate Focus • Undergraduates • Program focus is on working within discipline • Presumption learners must be provided all information relevant to the program • Graduate programs • Focus is on executive leadership, research or consulting • Learners are often non-traditional EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  3. Emergency Management Non-traditional Learners • Graduate EM programs attract many non-traditional learners • Non-traditional students • Technically oriented specialists • Entered government service in a specialty, but entering, or has entered, management position • Seeks degree to prepare for promotion, or to refine skills for current position • Career Transition • First responders • Military EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  4. Converging Degree Path in EM Linear Degree Path Converging Degree Path MS (Accounting) Graduate EM Programs Criminal Justice Social Work BS (Accounting) Engineering Education Health Other EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  5. Challenges for Faculty • Emergency Management, regardless of sector, works within US disaster policies • Policies are founded on principles of public administration, including, in the US, federalism and free enterprise systems • A substantive lack of knowledge concerning government and governance can hinder understanding and practice of EM EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  6. Challenge Compounded by a Lack of Civil Literacy • In recent surveys of US citizens • 71% had mean score of 49% (F) • Elected officials scored 6 points lower • Only 49% could identify three branches of government • 54% did not know Congress could declare war (40% thought it presidential power) EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  7. Lack of Civil Literacy (Continued) • In recent surveys of US citizens (Continued) • Only 16.25% could describe a free enterprise system • 20% believed Electoral College was a government training institution for potential presidential candidates EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  8. Lack of Civil Literacy (Continued) • In recent surveys of US citizens • By a 2 to 1 margin, more people knew Paula Abdul was a judge on American Idol than knew Abraham Lincoln wrote of “government of the people….” EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  9. Potential Influence of Leadership • Within their professions, many have undergone leadership training • Potential “flaws” in leadership training programs • Trait-based, not competency-based • Single leader (heroic model) vs. Collaborative leadership • Lack of environmental contexts EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  10. Challenges in Course Room • Learners unaware of • Public versus private goods • Separation of powers • Concurrent powers • Legal mandates • Wilsonian dichotomy or Madisonian inclusivity, favoring Hamiltonian or Jeffersonian models EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  11. Challenges to Faculty • Develop means of introducing basic government theory and practices into courses • Develop appreciation of intergovernmental management, as opposed to intergovernmental relations EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  12. Specific EM-related Constitutional Elements • US Constitution • Preamble: General Welfare • Article 1, Section 8: Delegated Powers, Elastic Clause • 9th Amendment: State Authorities • 10th Amendment: Reserved Powers • 5th Amendment: Due Process • 14th Amendment: Due Process • State Constitutions EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  13. Examples of US Disaster Laws and Policies • Disaster Acts or Policies • Stafford Act • National Response Framework • National Incident Management System • Miscellaneous Acts • Environmental, Historical, Cultural Preservation Acts • Employment and related acts EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  14. Structural Remedies • Some academic degree programs address this through course structure • Formal cohort • Formalized introductory courses • Academic pre-requisites • Structural remedies may limit programmatic flexibility EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  15. Adaptive Remedies • Instructors must develop easily achievable basic introduction, then use it as context for course work • Adapt to the level of understanding in class • Focus on parameters and authorities associated with laws and policies, not complex legal theories or interpretations, which might require a lawyer to teach • Focus is on creating an understanding of real-world EM EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  16. Integration Processes • During first session(s) • Brief overview of why EM should understand laws and policies • Brief discussion of legal environment, related to EM • Injects during remaining sessions • Often simple, but critical changes to • Class discussions • Examinations • Projects EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  17. Inject Example #1 • If asking about federal government response to Hurricane Katrina: • Instead of: • How could the federal government have accelerated the response to Katrina? • Change to • How could officials have streamlined application of the Stafford Act and the National Response Plan to accelerate the response to Katrina? EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  18. Inject Example #2 • Instead of asking • When should evacuations be ordered? • Ask • What are decision-making factors in ordering an evacuation, and who has the legal authority to order and enforce them? EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  19. Inject Example #3 • Instead of asking • Should a quarantine be imposed? • Ask • Who has the authority to order a quarantine, and what is the process for doing so in your state? EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  20. Strengths and Weaknesses • Strengths • Provides learners specific contexts for EM engagement in their communities • Provides learners with perspective of external influences on their discipline • Weaknesses • Consumes time • May generate unrelated debate, which must be controlled • Does not address issues of EM within private organizational structures, though some information translates easily EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  21. Conclusions • The Problem: Learners who lack an understanding of disaster-related laws and policies may experience difficulties in the practice or research of EM. • Idealized Goal: New emergency managers who have sufficient appreciation of the overarching political framework to be able to manage technical programs within the real world. EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  22. References • Anderson, T.D., Gisborne, K., & Holliday, P. (2006). Every officer is a leader, 2nd edition. Victoria, BC, Canada: Trafford Publishing. • Burns, J.M. (2003). Transforming leadership. New York, NY: Grove Press. • Gormley, W.T., Jr., and Balla, S.J. (2008). Bureaucracy and democracy: Accountability and performance. Washington, DC: CQ Press. • Heifitz, R.A., Linsky, M. (2002). Leadership on the line. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Business School Press. • Intercollegiate Studies Institute American Civil Literacy Program. (n.d.). Additional findings. Enlighted citizenship. Retrieved from http://www.americancivicliteracy.org/2011/summary_summary.html EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  23. References (Continued) • Intercollegiate Studies Institute American Civil Literacy Program. (n.d.). Summary. Enlighted citizenship. Retrieved from http://www.americancivicliteracy.Org/2011/summary_summary.html • Intercollegiate Studies Institute American Civil Literacy Program. (n.d.). Additional findings. Our facing heritage. Retrieved from Http://www. americancivicliteracy.org/2008/additional_finding.html • Kettle, D.F. (2002.) The transformation of governance. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Press. • McEntire, D.A., & Dawson, G. (2007). The intergovernmental context. In W.L. Waugh, Jr. and K. Tierney (Eds). Emergency management: Principles and practice for local government, 2nd edition (pages 57-70). Washington, DC: ICMA Press. . EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  24. References (Continued) • Nicholson, W.C. (2003). Emergency response and emergency management law: Cases and materials. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas Publishers. • Riley, D.D., & Brophy-Baermann, B.E. (2006). Bureaucracy and the policy process. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield Rosenbloom, D., & Naff, K. (2010). The status of law in contemporary public administration, literature, education and practice. In R. O’Leary, D. Van Slyke, & S. Kim (Eds.). The future of public administration: The Minnowbrook perspective (pages 211-232). Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press. • Rubin, C.B. Local emergency management: Origins and evolution. In W.L. Waugh, Jr. and K. Tierney (Eds). Emergency Management: Principles and Practices for Local Government, 2nd edition (pages 57-70). Washington, DC: ICMA Press. EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  25. References (Continued) • Stillman, R.J. II. (1999). Preface to public administration: A search for themes and direction, 2nd edition. Burke, VA: Chatelaine Press. • Sylves, R. (2008). Disaster policy and politics: Emergency management and homeland security. Washington, DC: CQ Press. EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

  26. Contact Information Thomas E. Poulin, PhD Capella University Core Faculty – Emergency Management Thomas.Poulin@Capella.edu EMHEC - Basic Government & EM Courses

More Related