1 / 13

Dementia, Sexual Autonomy, and Gatekeeper Responsibility

Dementia, Sexual Autonomy, and Gatekeeper Responsibility. Elizabeth Victor, Ph.D. Visiting Assistant professor , philosophy Grand Valley State University Laura Guidry-Grimes, M.A., A.B.D. Doctoral Candidate, philosophy Georgetown University.

kaylee
Download Presentation

Dementia, Sexual Autonomy, and Gatekeeper Responsibility

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Dementia, Sexual Autonomy, and Gatekeeper Responsibility Elizabeth Victor, Ph.D. Visiting Assistant professor, philosophy Grand Valley State University Laura Guidry-Grimes, M.A., A.B.D. Doctoral Candidate, philosophy Georgetown University International Conference for Clinical Ethics Consultation

  2. Introduction & Outline International Conference for Clinical Ethics Consultation

  3. Outline • Presentation of cases to frame discussion • Capacity modeling for sexual decision-making • Sexuality and well-being in the twilight of identity • Recap of case findings • Recommendations: Institutional measures • Establishing a policy to guide caregiver practice • Determining a baseline • Geriatric ethics consultation International Conference for Clinical Ethics Consultation

  4. Introduction: The Challenges • Stylized Case 1: Janie • Stylized Case 2: Earl • Questions arising from cases: • Which residents have sufficient capacity for sexual activity? • Do these relationships support or threaten well-being? • What are the responsibilities of caregivers, who act as gatekeepers? International Conference for Clinical Ethics Consultation

  5. Capacity modeling for sexual decision-making International Conference for Clinical Ethics Consultation

  6. More risk to individual: Higher standard for capacity More certainty req’d Risk and Autonomy in Context • Concern: Over-idealized interpretations of capacity • Exclusionary, neglect relational features of agency • Should seek to identify reasonable standards • Sliding-Scale models • Risks/benefits – as judged by patient’s minimally consistent aims, values – set threshold • Decision-specific, choice-specific Less risk to individual: Lower standard for capacity Less certainty req’d International Conference for Clinical Ethics Consultation

  7. Risk and Autonomy in Context • How to evaluate risk in sexual activity • Similar to choosing ice cream? • The ice cream analogy misses the ways in which consenting to sex involves intimacy, identity, and vulnerability • All of these are bound up with who the sexual partner is and how gatekeepers control available options • Application to cases International Conference for Clinical Ethics Consultation

  8. Sexuality & Well-Being International Conference for Clinical Ethics Consultation

  9. In the Twilight of Identity • Supporting sexuality for people whose sense of self is fading • How do we resolve tensions when sexual behavior does not cohere with long-standing values? • Narrative arc and empathic access as a way to know when and how to support resident’s actions • Recognize the power of caregivers and family • Involving family members carries heavy moral costs • Application to cases International Conference for Clinical Ethics Consultation

  10. Recommendations International Conference for Clinical Ethics Consultation

  11. Institutional & Interactive Policies • Establishing a policy to guide caregiver practice • Many caregivers report seeking guidance from policies, but few institutions have explicit policies about how to handle residents’ sexual activities. • Determining a baseline • At intake, establish and periodically track sexual decision-making capacity • May include observational measures over time • Help caregivers tailor differences in need for individuals • Geriatric ethics consultation • Help alleviate moral distress • Track exclusionary systems and practices International Conference for Clinical Ethics Consultation

  12. Thank You! Elizabeth Victor evictor@mail.usf.edu Laura Guidry-Grimes lkg8@georgetown.edu

  13. Questions? International Conference for Clinical Ethics Consultation

More Related