1 / 28

Evaluating & Improving Algorithms

Evaluating & Improving Algorithms. Analyzing US Change. While M>0 c <- value of largest coin with value <= M give c coin to customer M <- M-c Three statements per loop Loop executes k times, where k is… Therefore, running time is 3*k. Generalized US Change. for i <- 0 to d-1

keefe
Download Presentation

Evaluating & Improving Algorithms

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Evaluating & Improving Algorithms

  2. Analyzing US Change While M>0 c <- value of largest coin with value <= M give c coin to customer M <- M-c • Three statements per loop • Loop executes k times, where k is… • Therefore, running time is 3*k

  3. Generalized US Change for i <- 0 to d-1 Calculate and give the max number of this coin (c[i]) • How many times does this loop run? (k) • How many operations are in calculate & give max? (x) • Resulting time is k*x

  4. General Rules for Calculating Time • Steps in sequence are added • A function is replaced by its # steps (or count each call as 1 step) • Total # of steps in a loop gets multiplied by the # of times the loop executes

  5. Summary so far… • Original US change • O(N) where N is # coins given • Generalized change algorithm • O(N) where N is # different coins in system • But this doesn’t work for all cases!

  6. Brute Force* Change N <- 1 While (not done) construct a combination of N coins if it adds up to M return it (done=true) else N <- N+1 *Brute Force = try all combinations

  7. How many loops? • One loop for every combination with too few coins 1! + 2! + … • One loop for every combination with the right number of coins before the correct one • Best case for this part is 0 • Worst case for this part is k! where k is the number of coins in the solution

  8. Summary and Analysis • Original US change • O(N) where N is # coins given (linear) • Generalized change algorithm • O(N) where N is # different coins • O(1) for a fixed coin system (constant) • Brute force change algorithm • O (N * N!) where N is # coins given • (Worse than 2N)!

  9. What We’ve Learned • Brute force algorithms (try all possibilities) are guaranteed to work, but… • Brute force algorithms (usually) take too long • We need ways to speed up the work

  10. Detour: Recursion • Specify a solution to a problem in terms of solutions to one or more smaller problems • Mathematically elegant

  11. Recursive Fibonacci • Mathematical definition • F(0) = 0 • F(1) = 1 • F(N) = F(N-1) + F(N-2) • Implemented directly: • F(4) = F(3)+F(2) = F(2)+F(1)+F(2) = F(1)+F(0)+F(1)+F(2) = 1+1+1+F(2) = 3+F(1)+F(0) = 3+1+1 = 5

  12. A Tree of Recursive Calls F(4) F(3) F(2) F(2) F(0) F(1) F(1) 1 1 1 F(1) F(0) 1 1

  13. Dynamic Programming • Save intermediate results from which the final result can be computed • Order the computations so you have all saved results before you need them • Example: our Fibonacci Algorithm

  14. Dynamic Programming For Fibonacci • Generate answers from smallest to largest • Use previous answers in calculations fibonacci (n) O(n) where n is input f[0] <- 1 f[1] <- 1 for i <- 2 to n-1 n times f[i] <- f[i-1]+f[i-2] 1 step return f[n-1]

  15. Recursion Isn’t Always Slower • Recursive US Change (M) if (M>0) c <- value of largest coin with value <= M give c coin to customer Recursive US Change(M-c) • Only one recursive call, at end • This is “tail recursion”, just as fast as the original loop

  16. Greedy Algorithms • Order your algorithm to solve the “biggest chunk” first • Example: always give the biggest coin possible in the change problem • Not every greedy algorithm is correct (e.g. generalized change)

  17. Branch and Bound • Consider a brute force problem solution as a series of choices • When a single choice is avoided (pruned), all future choices that depend on it are also avoided • AI calls this “heuristic search”

  18. Randomized • Make each choice randomly until the problem is solved • Not guaranteed to solve the problem • Technically not even algorithms, if not guaranteed to halt (e.g. by time limit) • Sometimes we can prove that a “good enough” solution is “likely enough” and these are simple to implement

  19. Find the Phone (Brute Force) Find the phone: if the phone is at your location return true (phone is found) else for each direction (left, right, forw, back) take a step if (find the phone) return true return false (phone not found here)

  20. Find the Phone (Branch & Bound) Find the phone: if the phone is at your location return true (phone is found) else listen to the phone & rule out opposite direction for each remaining direction take a step if (find the phone) return true return false (phone not found here)

  21. Find the Phone (Greedy) Find the phone: if the phone is at your location return true (phone is found) else listen & pick best direction (left, right, forw, back) take a step if (find the phone) return true return false (phone not found here) • What if there’s an irreplaceable Ming vase between you and the phone?

  22. Find the Phone (Randomized) Find the phone: if the phone is at your location return true (phone is found) else repeat forever pick a random direction (left, right, forw, back) take a step if (find the phone) return true

  23. Divide and Conquer • If the problem is small enough, solve it directly • Else • Break the problem down into 2 or more subproblems • Solve each one separately (recursive step) • Combine the solutions • Works best when subproblems are equal size

  24. Divide & Conquer Example • Quick Sort • Pick a value from the list (k) • Divide the input into “<k” list and “>k” list • Sort each list separately • Build the result: • Sorted “<k” list followed by k followed by sorted “>=k” list

  25. Machine Learning • Given: many instances of input and output • Discover: a function that relates them • Generalize: to previously unseen inputs • Generally need large amounts of representative data • ML algorithms are fairly time consuming

  26. Summary of Techniques • Brute Force • Try every possibility • Rarely practical for reasonable size problems • Dynamic programming • Solve subproblems in the right order and save solutions to build the final answer

  27. Summary (cont’d) • Greedy Algorithms • Take the “biggest step” first each time. Not always correct. • Branch and Bound • Rule out impossible choices and their successors, but try everything else • Divide and Conquer • Combine results from smaller subproblems

  28. Summary (cont’d) • Machine learning • Use large amounts of data to “automatically” generate an appropriate solution algorithm • Randomized algorithms • Try solutions at random until one is found (or “good enough”) • Not always completely random (e.g. genetic algorithms)

More Related