1 / 20

Debates in Psychology

Debates in Psychology. Reductionism Versus Holism Freewill Versus Determinism Adapted from www.completepsychology.co.uk. Topics to Consider. Reductionist and holistic levels of analysis forms of reductionism a hierarchy of explanation Free will and determinism

Download Presentation

Debates in Psychology

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Debates in Psychology Reductionism Versus Holism Freewill Versus Determinism Adapted from www.completepsychology.co.uk

  2. Topics to Consider • Reductionist and holistic levels of analysis • forms of reductionism • a hierarchy of explanation • Free will and determinism • either/or, or somewhere in-between?

  3. Overview • Disagreement about a range of issues • Different positions lead to different approaches to psychology • Important to understand these issues to be able to evaluate theories in psychology

  4. Debate 1 Reductionism versus Holism • Reductionism is the view that complex phenomena can be best understood by reducing them to separate simpler parts Descartes held that non-human animals could be reductively explained as automata — De homines 1622.

  5. Reductionism • Reductionism is the view that complex phenomena can be best understood by reducing them to separate simpler parts

  6. Types of Reductionism • physiological reductionism • biological reductionism

  7. Physiological Reductionism • Psychological explanations are replaced by physiological explanations in terms of brain operation, genetics, or both • Provides simple explanations than can often be tested scientifically

  8. Biological Reductionism • Explain human behaviour in terms of simpler animals • Assumes continuity of behavior between animals and humans

  9. Reductionism & Levels of Explanation • Some argue that the “best science” focuses on the deepest levels • Watson: ‘There is only one science, physics: the rest is just social work.’

  10. Evaluation • Advantages of reductionism: • Scientific, easily tested and concise explanations • successful interventions e.g. treatment of bipolar disorder

  11. Evaluation • Disadvantages of reductionism: • may lose features of the phenomenon of interest (‘can’t see the wood for the trees’) • most behaviours - e.g., violence - have a social meaning that may not correspond to biological processes

  12. Holism • Human behaviour is highly complex and higher levels of analysis give a more complete and realistic view of behaviour • “the whole is greater than the sum of its parts”

  13. Holism • Answering the question as to why we are aggressive has more practical value than understanding the physiological underpinning of the behaviour.

  14. Evaluation • Adopting many levels of analysis a challenge • Danger that biological aspects of behaviour are neglected

  15. Debate 2 Free Will and Determinism

  16. Free Will and Determinism • Do we have free will, or is all our behaviour determined by identifiable causes? • Much of psychology assumes determinism, since to be scientific (finding cause and effect) means identifying determining causes • However, determinism conflicts with our subjective experience of choice

  17. Definitions of Free Will • Choice: • people have free will if they have a genuine choice of behaviour • Assumes that influences on behaviour can be rejected at will

  18. Defining Determinism • Comes in a range of forms, depending on what’s seen as determining behaviour • e.g. behaviourism, psychodynamics, evolutionary psychology • Determinism means all behaviour has theoretically identifiable causes and can be predicted

  19. Soft Determinism • A compromise position first proposed by William James 1890 • Behaviour is seen as determined to an extent, but in the absence of compulsion, people have a degree of choice and freedom • The question then becomes ‘How much is determined?’

  20. Evaluation • Belief in free will matches subjective experience and our sense of moral responsibility • However, difficult to find an scientific explanation of behaviour if we don’t accept determinism • Perhaps different phenomena differ in the extent to which they’re determined • e.g. language use vs. instinctive responses

More Related