1 / 9

Professor Suzanne Fitzpatrick Heriot-Watt University

Professor Suzanne Fitzpatrick Heriot-Watt University. The Broader Policy Context for Homelessness in Scotland. Presentation to Beyond Homelessness: Putting Research into Practice , by Suzanne Fitzpatrick, 24 th January 2011. The UK homelessness legislation is unique.

lise
Download Presentation

Professor Suzanne Fitzpatrick Heriot-Watt University

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Professor Suzanne FitzpatrickHeriot-Watt University

  2. The Broader Policy Context for Homelessness in Scotland Presentation to Beyond Homelessness: Putting Research into Practice, by Suzanne Fitzpatrick, 24th January 2011

  3. The UK homelessness legislation is unique • Often there is a constitutional ‘right to housing’, but unenforceable –a ‘political marker of concern’ • There are enforceable rights to emergency shelter in some European countries; always confined to roofless households • French ‘DALO’ (2007) attempted to establish a legally-enforceable right to housing for social housing applicants (including homeless people) who experience ‘an abnormally long delay’ – but vague and complex = No other country outside UK provides homeless people with clear, legally-enforceable rights to permanent or settled housing

  4. Legislative and policy divergence within UK • Intense period of policy activity on homelessness since devolution - particularly in Scotland (Homelessness Task Force) and England (Homelessness Directorate) • Legislative framework has now diverged across the UK: Scotland has a far stronger statutory safety net than elsewhere (the 2001 and 2003 Acts and 2012 target; Human Rights awards) • Homelessness prevention has had a major (and controversial) impact in England and Wales - much less so in Scotland and N.I. thus far

  5. Homelessness prevention • England - 2002 Act - homelessness strategies - 2005 target to halve households in TA by end 2010 • ‘housing options’ - PRS, family mediation, sanctuary schemes, tenancy support, etc • massive drop in homelessness acceptances - ‘gatekeeping’? • Wales – similar approach and results to England • Scotland- cautious, limited and experimental in comparison, but now changing… • N.I. – just coming onto the agenda

  6. Impact of homelessness prevention in England by 2009/10 • Homelessness prevention activity outside statutory framework (‘cases where positive action was successful in preventing or relieving homelessness’) • 165,200 cases • 61% involved the household being assisted to obtain alternative accommodation (usually PRS) • 39% were assisted to remain in their existing home • Statutory homelessness ‘acceptances’ – 40,030 cases (70% down on 2003 peak) = almost as many homelessness acceptances in Scotland (36,643) as in the whole of England (40,030)

  7. What is happening in England now? • Homelessness acceptance starting to rise again – last 2 quarters • Localism Bill – local control over access to waiting lists; end of security of tenure for social tenants?; ‘compulsory’ discharge of duty into PRS fixed-term tenancies • Welfare reform – LHA, HB and Shared Room Rate (25-35 year olds); will restrict use of PRS to prevent homelessness/discharge duty

  8. Policy changing rapidly in Scotland • 2012 target and shortage of social housing lets; can’t ‘build way out’ • Discharge of duty into PRS ‘short assured tenancies’ – ‘settled housing’ • ‘Housing options’ – seems muted in Fresh Thinking, New Ideas, but shift towards robust prevention; national seminar and funding for regional hubs; concerns over gatekeeping, but Scottish Housing Regulator has given ‘green light’ • Housing (Scotland) Act 2010 - new duty to assess housing support needs • Broader context – public funding cuts; Supporting People; constraints in new housing supply; HB/LHA/SRR

  9. Conclusions • Funding cuts = very challenging time for housing and homelessness • But new emphasis on prevention and housing options = opportunity for more creative ‘problem solving’ than in the past • Social networks a key dimension of prevention and re-integration, e.g. Glasgow hostel closure study (under/over 50s) • Social networks relevant to new housing support duty?

More Related