240 likes | 245 Views
Chapter 12 Undertaking Research for Specific Purposes. Multimethod (or Mixed Method) Research. A design that blends qualitative and quantitative data and strategies in a single project. Advantages of Multimethod Research. Complementarity Enhanced theoretical insights Incrementality
E N D
Multimethod (or Mixed Method) Research A design that blends qualitative and quantitative data and strategies in a single project
Advantages of Multimethod Research • Complementarity • Enhanced theoretical insights • Incrementality • Enhanced validity • Creating new frontiers
Applications of Multimethod Research • Instrument development • Explicating and validating constructs • Hypothesis generation • Illustration, clarification, and amplification • Understanding relationships and causal processes • Theory building, testing, and refinement
Multimethod Research Designs • Component designs • Integrated designs
Component Multimethod Designs • Qualitative and quantitative aspects are implemented as discrete components of the inquiry, and remain distinct during data collection and analysis • Types of component designs: • Triangulated design • Complementarity design • Expansion design
Integrated Multimethod Designs • Integration of methods at all phases of the project, from the development of research questions, to data collection and analysis, to interpretation of results • Types of integrated designs: • Iterative design • Embedded (nested) design • Holistic design • Transformative design
Strategies for Multimethod Research • Clinical trials • Evaluation research • Surveys • Ethnographies
Obstacles to Multimethod Research • Epistemologic biases • Costs • Researcher training • Analytic challenges • Publication biases
Types of Quantitative Research with Different Purposes • Studies that are usually experimental/quasi-experimental: • Clinical trials • Evaluation research • Intervention research
Types of Quantitative Research with Different Purposes (cont’d) • Studies that can be experimental or nonexperimental: • Outcomes research • Replication studies • Methodologic research
Types of Quantitative Research with Different Purposes (cont’d) • Studies that are usually nonexperimental: • Survey research • Needs assessments • Secondary analysis • Meta-analysis • Delphi surveys
Clinical Trials Studies that develop and test the effectiveness of clinical interventions
Phases of a Full Clinical Trial • Phase I: finalizes the treatment (e.g., to determine things like drug dose and safety) • Phase II: seeks preliminary evidence of effectiveness • Phase III: fully tests the treatment (randomized clinical trial or RCT) • Phase IV: focuses on long-term consequences of the treatment
Key Issues, Activities, and Products of Phase I Developmental Work for Nursing Interventions
Evaluation Research Examines how well a specific program, practice, procedure, or policy is working Types of evaluation: • Process (implementation) analysis • Outcome analysis • Impact analysis • Cost analysis
Intervention Research Research with a distinctive process of planning and testing interventions. Steps include: • Project planning; development of an intervention theory • An intervention design, flowing from the theory • Implementation of a data collection system • Testing the intervention, in progressive stages • Dissemination of the results and intervention
Outcomes Research Documents the quality and effectiveness of health care and nursing services Framework for outcomes research: • Structure of care (organizational features) • Nursing processes (aspects of clinical decision making and interventions) • Patient characteristics • Clinical outcomes
Survey Research • Obtains information about the prevalence, distribution, and interrelations of variables within a population • Modes of administration: • Personal (face-to-face) interviews • Telephone interviews • Self-administered questionnaires • Internet surveys
Secondary Analysis • Studies using previously gathered data to test new hypotheses • Alternative strategies: • Examine relationships not previously analyzed • Focus on a subgroup within the data set (e.g., males only) • Change the unit of analysis
Needs Assessments • Studies to estimate the needs of a group, community, or organization • Needs assessment approaches: • Key informant approach • Survey approach • Indicators approach
Delphi Surveys A tool for planning and short-term forecasting. Procedures include: • Distributing questionnaires to an expert panel • Tabulating responses and distributing results back to the panel • Completing follow-up rounds of surveys (typically 3 or more rounds to achieve consensus)
Replication Studies • Studies to determine if findings from an original study can be duplicated in another independent study • Types of replication: • Identical replication • Virtual replication • Systematic extension replication
Methodologic Research Investigations of the ways of obtaining, organizing, and analyzing data Examples: • Developing and evaluating a new data collection instrument • Testing the effectiveness of stipends in facilitating recruitment