1 / 108

Introduction to Philosophy

Introduction to Philosophy. Part III Epistemology & Metaphysics. Epistemology. Introduction Epistemology Some Classic Problems Some Classic Questions Some Basic Concepts Rationalism A priori knowledge Innate Ideas Empiricism A posteriori knowledge No innate ideas

nyoko
Download Presentation

Introduction to Philosophy

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Introduction to Philosophy Part III Epistemology & Metaphysics

  2. Epistemology • Introduction • Epistemology • Some Classic Problems • Some Classic Questions • Some Basic Concepts • Rationalism • A priori knowledge • Innate Ideas • Empiricism • A posteriori knowledge • No innate ideas • Justified, True Belief

  3. Plato’s Epistemology & Metaphysics • Introduction • Knowledge & Opinion • Argument against relativism (Theatetus) • Relative • Self Refuting • Protagoras • First Problem of the Senses: Change • Changing world • Cannot have certainty • Appear at a specific time • Source of knowledge • Senses cannot be a source of knowledge

  4. Plato’s Epistemology & Metaphysics • Second Problem of the Senses: Definitions • Objects of knowledge must be universal & unchanging • Unchanging definitions are necessary • Language would not work • Perfect Standard Argument • Physical things fall short • Knowledge of something perfect • Knowledge cannot come from sensess • Knowledge is Not Right Opinion • Right opinion (true belief) vs. knowledge • True opinion • Account • Rational justification

  5. Plato’s Epistemology & Metaphysics • Knowledge is • Objective • Not obtained by the senses • Universal • Changeless • Based in reason • The Forms & Ideas • Particulars (tokens) & categories (types) • Universal/form • Eternal • Changeless • Perfect

  6. Plato’s Epistemology & Metaphysics • Participation • Idea • The Doctrine of Recollection (Meno) • Meno’s Paradox • Acquiring knowledge • Communing with the forms • Forgetting • Doctrine of Recollection

  7. Plato’s Epistemology & Metaphysics • Plato’s Metaphysics • The Forms • Real, objective, independent, unchanging • Not spatial or temporal • Participation problem • Change • Paradox of Change • Heraclitus • Parmenides • Platonic compromise • Particulars: changing, imperfect, object of opinion

  8. Plato’s Epistemology & Metaphysics • Particulars • Reality comes in degrees • The forms are causes of particulars • Particulars resemble the forms • Particulars participate in the forms in varying degrees • The forms group particulars into types, making them intelligible.

  9. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • Lovers of Opinion & Lovers of Wisdom • Philosophers • The One & the Many • Two • Each is One • The Many • Sights, Dreams, Opinion & Knowledge • Lovers of sounds & Sights • Life is a dream • One is awake • Absolute beauty • Forms & objects • Knowledge & Opinion

  10. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • Being & Non-Being Argument • One who knows, knows something. • Absolute beauty may be absolutely known. • The utterly non-existent is utterly unknown. • Anything that can be and not be will be between pure being and absolute negation of being. • Knowledge corresponds to being and ignorance to non being. • Spheres & Faculties Argument • Faculties are powers in us. • What has the same sphere & same result is the same faculty. • What has another sphere & another result is different. • Knowledge & opinion are both faculties, but not the same.

  11. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • Knowledge & opinion have distinct spheres. • Being is the sphere of knowledge. • Knowledge is to know the nature of being. • Opinion is to have an opinion. • If difference in faculty implies a difference in the sphere & if opinion & knowledge are distinct faculties, then the sphere of knowledge & opinion cannot be the same. • Not-being is not the subject-matter of opinion • An opinion is about something. • One cannot have an opinion about nothing. • One who has an opinion has an opinion about some one thing. • Not-being is not one thing but nothing.

  12. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • Opinion is Intermediate • Ignorance is the correlative of not being. • Knowledge is the correlative of being. • Opinion is not concerned with being or not-being. • Opinion is intermediate between ignorance & knowledge. • Its correlative is and is not and is between pure being & absolute non-being. • The corresponding faculty is opinion. • The Object of Opinion • The beautiful will be seen as ugly. • The ideas of the many are half-way. • Opinion & not knowledge.

  13. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • Lovers of Opinion vs. Lovers of Wisdom • Those who have opinion but not knowledge • See the many • Do not see the absolute • The Objects of Knowledge • The many & the one • Many • Seen • Not known • Absolute • Form • Known • Not seen

  14. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • The Eye Analogy • Moonlight • Sunshine • The soul is like the eye • Truth & being • Twilight of becoming/perishing • The Sun Analogy • The Good • Light & sight are like the sun, but not the sun. • Science & truth are like the good, but not the good. • Good has a higher place of honor. • Pleasure is not the good. • The sun is the author of generation • The sun is not generation • The good is the author of knowledge, being & essence. • The good is not essence but far exceeds it.

  15. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • The Four Levels of Knowledge: the Line • Ruling Powers • The good-intellectual world. • The sun-visible world. • Visible vs. intelligible. • Division of the line • Visible • Intelligible • Sections A&B • A images • A is a resemblance of B. • B includes animals, growing things, and made things. • A&B have different degrees of truth. • The copy is to the original as the sphere of opinion is to the sphere of knowledge.

  16. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • Sections C & D • In C figures given by D are used as images. • Hypothetical inquiry. • In D the soul passes from hypothesis to a principle above hypothesis. • No images, but proceeding in and through the forms. • Section C-Hypothesis • Math-hypothesis • Begin with hypothesis. • Using figures thinking of forms. • Soul seeking to behold the things themselves.

  17. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • Section D-the intelligible • Knowledge attained by reason by the dialectic using hypothesis as hypothesis and not first principles. • Intelligible • As steps to a world above hypothesis and to the first principle of the whole. • Knowledge & being contemplated by the dialectic. • Clearer than notions of arts proceeding solely from hypothesis. • Contemplated by understanding & not senses. • Understanding deals with geometry & cognitive sciences & is the intermediate between opinion & knowledge. • Four Faculties of the Soul • D Reason • C Understanding • B Belief • Imaging

  18. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave

  19. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • The Allegory of the Cave • Description • Cave • Chained • Fire • Walls • Vessels • Shadows • Think they are naming what is actually before them. • To them, the truth is nothing but the shadows of the images. • Release of the Prisoners-1st Step: Free in the Cave • The light is painful. • Cannot see the realities previously seen in shadows. • Approach nearer to being & have clearer vision. • Perplexed if asked to name objects. • Will initially think the shadows are truer than the objects.

  20. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • The Release of the Prisoners-2nd Step: Outside the Cave • Pained & dazzled in the sun. • Need to grow accustomed • Shadows • Reflections in water • Objects • Light of the stars and moon • The sun • Argue the sun is the cause of all • The freed person • Praise himself & pity others. • Not care for the honors • If he returned, his eyes would be full of darkness. • Fare poorly in the contests. • Men would think it better not to ascend. • If anyone tried to free another, they would put him to death.

  21. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • The Allegory • Cave: world of sight • Light of the fire: sun • Journey Upwards: the ascent of the soul to the intellectual world.

  22. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave

  23. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • The Good • The Good • Universal author of all things beautiful & right • Parent & lord of light in the visible world. • Immediate source of reason & truth in the intellectual. • Those who have seen the Good • Unwilling to descend • Behave ridiculously • Court of law • Absolute justice • Bewilderment • One who remembers

  24. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • Source of Knowledge • Knowledge cannot be put into the soul that was not there before • Like sight into blind eyes. • The power & capacity of learning exists in the soul already. • Eye analogy • As the eye was unable to go from darkness to light without the whole body • The instrument of knowledge must be turned from becoming to being by the movement of the whole soul. • Learn to endure the sight. • The art that effects this conversion • Does not implant the faculty of sight • It exists, but is facing the wrong way.

  25. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • Source of Knowledge • Knowledge cannot be put into the soul that was not there before • Like sight into blind eyes. • The power & capacity of learning exists in the soul already. • Eye analogy • As the eye was unable to go from darkness to light without the whole body • The instrument of knowledge must be turned from becoming to being by the movement of the whole soul. • Learn to endure the sight. • The art that effects this conversion • Does not implant the faculty of sight • It exists, but is facing the wrong way.

  26. Plato’s Line & Allegory of the Cave • Other virtues of the soul are akin to bodily qualities • If not innate, they can be implanted later by habit & exercise • The virtue of wisdom contains a divine element which always remains. • By this its conversion becomes useful & profitable or hurtful & useless. • The narrow intelligence of the clever rogue • His paltry soul clearly sees the way to his end. • He is the reverse of the blind. • His keen sight serves evil and he is mischievous in proportion to his cleverness.

  27. Introduction to Skepticism • Varieties of Skepticism • General Skepticism • The theory that we do not have any knowledge. • We cannot be completely certain that any of our beliefs are true. • Local/Moderate Skepticism • Can have mathematical and empirical knowledge. • Cannot have metaphysical knowledge. • Global Skepticism • Maintain universal doubt • Deny knowledge of an external world & other minds. • Deny knowledge of metaphysical truths. • Do not deny knowledge of mathematics & logic.

  28. Introduction to Skepticism • Super-global/Extreme Skepticism • Universal doubt • Deny knowledge of mathematics & logic. • Methodological Skepticism • Skepticism is adopted as a means to another end. • Typically the refutation of skepticism. • Example: Descartes.

  29. History of Skepticism • Introduction • Skeptikos • Error • Skeptikos • Lack of Foundations • Pyrrho of Elis (320-270 B.C.) • Revitalization of skepticism • 1st Century B.C. • No writings

  30. History of Skepticism • Pyrrho’s Sense Experience Argument • Sense experience cannot provide knowledge. • To provide knowledge the sense experiences must match their objects. • If we can never get outside of our sensations, we can never know the experiences match the alleged objects. • Pyrrho’s Reason Argument • Argumentation cannot provide knowledge. • For each argument there is an equally good counter-argument. • Thus, there is no rational ground for accepting one argument over another.

  31. History of Skepticism • Skeptic’s Position • Given that both senses and reason fail, we cannot have knowledge. • One can only speak in terms of experience. • Prudent approach: suspend judgment and not make any assumptions. • This skepticism also applies to morality. • A wise person adopts apathy and indifference. • People should follow existing laws & traditions.

  32. History of Skepticism • Academic Skepticism • Arcesilaus • 316-242 B.C. • Head of Plato’s Academy • Turned Academy towards skepticism • Carneades • 214-129 B.C. • Took over Academy after Arcesilaus. • Brilliant philosopher • Athenian Ambassador to Rome (156-155 B.C.) • Public speeches • Two-Faced Method

  33. History of Skepticism • The Academy • Skeptics thought the Academy lost the Socratic spirit. • Ironic charge • Skeptics focused on • Socrates’ claim he knew nothing. • Socratic dialogues ended without a definite conclusion. • Appearance • Skeptics attacked the dogmatism of the Stoics and Epicureans. • Some sense impressions seem indubitable. • Dreams & hallucinations seem convincing but are false.

  34. History of Skepticism • Main Argument: No Criterion for Truth • Any standard of truth will also need justification • Thus requiring another standard to establish the truth of the standard. • And so on in an infinite regress. • Claims • Did not claim that nothing can be known. • Claim: we appear to lack knowledge. • Suspended judgment regarding skepticism. • Probability • Stoics argued that skepticism would lead to the suspension of activity. • Carneades argued that certainty is not possible but probability is and is sufficient. • Compromise lead to scorn from Stoics and later Pyrrhonic skeptics.

  35. History of Skepticism • Revival of Pyrrhonian Skepticism • Purists • The Academics were not skeptical enough. • Rejected Carneade’s view of probability. • Named after Pyrrho. • Formalized skepticism. • Agrippa: Five Pillars of Skepticism • Disagreement: Not everyone will agree on an issue. • Infinite regress • Resolution requires reasons • Reasons require justifications • Justifications require justifications and so on to infinty.

  36. History of Skepticism • Relativity: Perceptions of things differ in different circumstances. • Hypothesis: All starting points are arbitrary. • Circular Reasoning: Any argument that avoids the other 4 pillars will be circular. • Latter Skeptics: Two Theses • Nothing is self-evident • Nothing can be proven • Skeptic’s Goal • Personal peace • If one cannot know, there is no reason to worry. • Accept what appears to be and follow existing customs and laws. • Sextus Empiricus (3rd Century AD)

  37. History of Skepticism • Importance of Skepticism • Problem • Starting points are needed for arguments. • This implies there are reasons for believing the starting points. • Contributions • Made philosophers more critical. • Philosophers had to accept or respond to the skeptics. • St. Augustine Against the Academics • Methodological skepticism in the Modern era. • Skepticism used to attack reason and support faith & revelation. • Development of science.

  38. History of Skepticism • The Decline of Skepticism • Did not succeed in creating peace. • Created Confusion. • Unsatisfactory. • Religious philosophies & Christianity.

  39. Renee Descartes • Rene Descartes • Life & Works • Born March 31, 1596 in La Haye France (now Descartes). • La Fleche • Degree in law • Joined armies • November 10, 1619 Three vivid dreams. • 1649 became tutor to Queen Christina of Sweden • Died February 11, 1650

  40. Renee Descartes • Published Works • 1620 Rules for the Direction of the Mind • 1633 Le Monde (The World) • 1637 Discourse on the Method of Rightly Conducting One’s Reason and Seeking the Truth in Sciences. • 1641 Meditations on First Philosophy • 1644 Principles of Philosophy • 1649 Passions of the Soul

  41. Renee Descartes • Agenda • Motivation • Dissatisfied • Disputed and doubtful • Shaky foundation of science • Travel • Old ideas • Intellectual Journey • Diversity of opinion

  42. Renee Descartes • Inward Focus • Studies • Solid foundation for the sciences • Father of modern philosophy • Quotes & argument from authority • Solitary Thinker • Personal pronouns • Discover truth • Individual journeys lead to same truths.

  43. Renee Descartes • Goals • Find certainty • Create universal science • Reconcile the scientific, mechanistic conception of the universe with human freedom and religion.

  44. Renee Descartes • Methodology • Mathematics • Model • Certainty & Self Evidence • Discourse • Mathematics consists in two mental operations • Intuition • Deduction

  45. Renee Descartes • Intuition • The recognition of self-evident truths. • Seeing the truth. • Not derived from other truths. • Innate ideas-implanted by God. • Not always aware of ideas. • Not from sense experience. • Intellectual vision.

  46. Renee Descartes • Deduction • Inference • Deduction from self-evident truth • All truths can be reached by deduction. • Analytical geometry (1637) • Physical world • All knowledge • The Meditations on First Philosophy • Six meditations • Decade • Six Days of Holy Week

  47. Descartes’ First Meditation • First Part • Start and Goal • Beliefs • Doubtful • Goals • Rid himself of opinions • Establish a foundation for the sciences. • Method • Not necessary to show all beliefs are false. • Assent with held from • Matters not entirely certain and indubitable. • Manifestly false beliefs.

  48. Descartes’ First Meditation • Rejecting the whole • No need to examine each belief • Doubting the Senses • Senses • Learned from the senses • At times the senses deceive • Not trust • Dream Problem • Skeptical pause #1 • Dreams • Asleep • Skeptical pause #2

  49. Descartes’ First Meditation • Sleep • No certain indications • Assumes he is asleep • Painter Analogy • The analogy • General things • Combined • Simpler & more universal things • Corporeal nature • Extension • Figure • Quantity • Location • Time

  50. Descartes First Meditation • Sciences considering composite things are dubious. • Math-Skeptical Pause • Arithmetic, Geometry, etc. • Awake or Asleep • Seems Impossible • God & the Demon • God • God as all powerful creator. • How does he know? • Deception. • God’s Goodness • Not Contrary to His Goodness

More Related