1 / 16

Emmaia Gelman, Laborers International Union of North America egelman@liuna // (917) 517-3627

On-Bill Financing. in Green Jobs-Green NY. for mass-scale retrofits, efficiency & economic recovery . Emmaia Gelman, Laborers International Union of North America egelman@liuna.org // (917) 517-3627 KEEA ACI conference, Sept. 20, 2011. LiUNA!. Green Jobs/Green NY:.

opal
Download Presentation

Emmaia Gelman, Laborers International Union of North America egelman@liuna // (917) 517-3627

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. On-Bill Financing in Green Jobs-Green NY for mass-scale retrofits, efficiency& economic recovery Emmaia Gelman, Laborers International Union of North America egelman@liuna.org // (917) 517-3627 KEEA ACI conference, Sept. 20, 2011 LiUNA!

  2. Green Jobs/Green NY: Signed in October ‘09, now under RFP for work to begin 2011 Mass-scale retrofits + good local jobs • 1,000,000 homes in 5 years • 14,250 permanent jobs • ~$1000/year home energy savings • $5b in new capital invested in New York …to build a sustainable retrofit economy in 5 years. LiUNA!

  3. Why On-Bill Recovery? • Overcome barriers: up-front cost, lack of trusted messenger, lack of clarity about return on investment, etc. - GET TO MASS SCALE • Open up closed customer sectors – about half of NYS homes? • Give lenders enough security to raise $billions in market-rate funds (without high interest rate, huge loan loss reserve or defaults) • Create consumer-safe loans to avoid creating debt spirals... (Utility bill is the safest available debt vehicle for vulnerable pops.) • Tie savings directly to repayments (use energy savings as revenue) • Create a vehicle that community groups willingly market to customers • Create sustainable, scalable, replicable retrofit fund. • Leverage state's role to ensure good jobs, good impacts LiUNA!

  4. Critical building blocks • Universal standards for worker/contractor certification already in place • State agency with programming standards, including some M&V • Bulk data from prior years’ energy efficiency retrofits • Utility rates high enough to provide good returns on retrofits (although lower-cost states are also making it work!) • Utility bill protections for consumers (NYS HEFPA) • Loan Loss Reserve funding (RRGI in NY) • Legislation setting terms of retrofits, standards & customer recruitment • On-Bill Recovery legislation LiUNA!

  5. Play-by-Play • Convened 150+ stakeholder groups to devise program to be funded w/ OBR • Consulted with lenders from the very start – maybe even fatigued them! • Held utilities separate, so they didn't overrun process, but consulted from start • Convened political actors/political will: primarily around jobs message • Provided competent technical drafts of legislation to bill champions • Continued intensive education, problem-solving & drafting for legislature • (Negotiated job standards between business, communities & labor after trust had been well-established.) • Introduced legislation in 2010, passed in 2011. LiUNA!

  6. On-Bill Recovery • State action • State creates Retrofit Fund & Loan Loss Reserve legislates utility role, basic loan terms & economic impact standards • Utility bill provides security for lenders • Low rate of default and write-offs among OBR-eligible customers • Possibility of power shut-off backs payment • Revenue from retrofit is sent directly back to Retrofit Fund • Utility bill provides safer borrowing for vulnerable households • No one puts their home up as collateral • Missed/late payments aren't catastrophic • Penalty for default (shut-off of service) is reversible • Homeowners don't have to budget in order to repay LiUNA!

  7. On-Bill Recovery (cont.) • Obligation to repay stays with the meter (and the retrofit) • “Enforcement Mortgage” (or maybe UCC1 filing) is assumable by a new owner, so even homeowners who may move can do retrofits • Projects can be scoped for cost-effectiveness within longer time period (15 years in NY legislation) • Utility focus supports community organizing around retrofits • On-Bill Recovery allows massive engagement by community groups • On-line tools like “EarthAid” can support post-retrofit engagement • Etc... LiUNA!

  8. Utilities appeared... Issues mostly based on misinterpretation of the bill/program. • We don't want to be a bank. • Utilities are only collecters – no other obligation. Retrofit charge is just a line item on the overall bill; no separate collection. • We don't want to collect the debts of some state agency. • Utilities are part of the energy infrastructure. Providing access to energy efficiency is an appropriate role. • We don't want to shut off customers' power for a debt that's not ours. • Customers would be paying the same or more for without the retrofit, so shut-offs will not increase. • You can't accurately predict savings from retrofits. • Inaccuracies are minimized by using home-specific data on utility bills and usage, and periodically recalibrating projections using real program data. The program can also build in a cushion (don't use all of your monthly savings to pay the bill) LiUNA!

  9. Utilities appeared... • This will increase our uncollectible bills (and therefore raise rates.) • OBR rules require that project savings match the repayment amount. Bills will not go up because of a retrofit loan. OBR will not increase shut-offs nor uncollectibles. • When there's a new buyer of a retrofitted home, we'll have to sue/deny service/do expensive collections to get them to start paying. • OBR builds in strong provisions of notice and transfer of obligation, at the demand of mortgage lenders and utilities. • This will cost a lot in collections. • Administrative costs are coverable by NYSERDA. • This will require millions of dollars in software upgrades. • Flipping on a new monthly charge can be manual till customer numbers grow. When upgrades are needed they can be rate-based. And yes, utilities need to upgrade outdated systems. LiUNA!

  10. … and then Realtors(who channel the mortgage lenders, too) • OBR financing may be an impediment to sale of a home • Is the benefit obvious? • Will the benefit “stick” when there's a new occupant? • Will the On-Bill Loan impinge on repair/renovation loans later? • Prospective buyers may find the OBR obligation onerous • How clear is notice? • How hard will the obligation be to assume? • Can the obligation be satisfied at sale? • At foreclosure, OBR may become a burden on the lender • Will the bank be on the hook for benefits it's not using? • Does the repayment obligation survive? • What happens when a home is “dormant?” LiUNA!

  11. Solutions for Mortgage Lenders • Notice of Lien? • Appears in Title Search • Transferable at sale • A bit unknown to lenders & realtors • Survives foreclosure (good for the Loan Loss Reserve.) • Enforcement Mortgage? • Appears in Title Search • Transferable or satisfiable at sale • Well known & used in NYC for subsidized properties • Doesn't survive foreclosure • UCC1 Filing? • Appears in Title Search • Transferable at sale • Probably survives foreclosure LiUNA!

  12. Key elements of the bill • Sets standards for contracting and cost-effectiveness • Requires that payback be achieved on the bill used to collect • Sets standards for data collection & use of data to recalibrate • Permits savings across fuels • Lays out some parameters for alternative creditworthiness tests • Provides for seamless collection as part of utility bill (including consumer protections) • Provides for complaint remediation • Allows cost recovery for utilities, while mandating “prudence” • Creates Enforcement Mortgage & Note LiUNA!

  13. The sausage-grinder effect: • On-billing only mandated for combined gas/electric utilities • Requires participants to pay a utility fee of $100 + 1% of loan value • Defers OBF roll-out for 10 months (while outreach begins now) • Doesn't establish key elements like scale, customer demographics or job standards. • Doesn't provide benchmarks for success & continuation of program LiUNA!

  14. Next hurdles • Scaling up investment capital, possibly through CDFIs/regional banks • Setting terms for “pilot” loans that work for communities, lenders • Establishing CRA eligibility for early loans • Aligning customers, contractors and financing on the messy timeline LiUNA!

  15. NY On-Bill Recovery as a model? • What's the alternative? • NYSERDA “Tier 2 loans” use OBR's alternative credit tests, but may not be safe for vulnerable borrowers... • Small credit unions issuing subordinate mortgages on a local scale,but use homes as collateral • PACE! But not for a while, and not for folks with lower incomes or lower home values • On-Bill solution documents at www.cwfny.org • Critical elements of On-Bill Recovery policy and legislation • Green Jobs-Green NY “Enforcement Mortgage” language • Talking points & solutions on utility objections • Model legislation (near future!) LiUNA!

  16. Emmaia Gelman, Senior Researcher Laborers International Union of North America egelman@liuna.org (917) 517-3627 LiUNA!

More Related