1 / 12

PHASED RETIREMENT LEGAL ISSUES

PHASED RETIREMENT LEGAL ISSUES. Ethan Lipsig & Patrick W. Shea Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker LLP. INTRODUCTION. This presentation outlines the core legal issues phased retirement efforts normally raise “Phased retirement” means different things to different people

Download Presentation

PHASED RETIREMENT LEGAL ISSUES

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. PHASED RETIREMENT LEGAL ISSUES Ethan Lipsig & Patrick W. Shea Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker LLP

  2. INTRODUCTION • This presentation outlines the core legal issues phased retirement efforts normally raise • “Phased retirement” means different things to different people • Incentives for delaying retirement • Incentives for early retirement • Initiatives targeted at particular individuals • Initiatives targeted at classes of employees • Incentives sometimes include part-time status or commencement of pensions during continued employment

  3. USUAL LEGAL ISSUES • Age discrimination • Against older workers • Reverse age discrimination • Other discrimination risks • Release issues • Plan design issues

  4. DISCRIMINATION AGAINST OLDER WORKERS

  5. WHY TARGETED RETIREMENT INCENTIVES ARE RISKY • Individualized effort to encourage an older worker to retire could suggest age-based bias • Individual might claim that he or she was coerced to retire on account of age • If individual does not retire, could claim that adverse employment treatment was on account of age, citing the employer’s retirement encouragement effort

  6. HOW TO MINIMIZE THIS RISK • Encourage poorly performing or surplus workers of all ages to resign • Make approaches in writing or by using a written script, in either case, in a manner that minimizes appearance of age bias, e.g., that stresses that decision is purely voluntary and that nothing adverse will be done if employee turns it down • If employee accepts offer, get a valid age discrimination release

  7. REVERSE AGE DISCRIMINATION • Reverse age discrimination is legal under federal law, but not under some states’ laws, e.g., Connecticut • If phased retirement benefits are all ERISA-governed, federal law would preempt state reverse discrimination laws • When providing non-ERISA-governed phased retirement benefits, make sure that state reverse discrimination laws will not be a problem

  8. DISCRIMINATION OTHER THAN AGE • Phased retirement could violate other laws • Intentionally offering incentives on the basis of e.g., sex or race, would be illegal • Offering them disproportionately to e.g., white men, could be illegal • Likely only an issue for phased retirement targeted at individuals • Not as frequently encountered as age discrimination

  9. RELEASE ISSUES • If possible, condition phased retirement incentives intended to encourage retirement on securing a release • Generally allowable, even under qualified retirement plans as to new benefits • Make sure the release waives all federal and state discrimination claims • Make sure it is a valid ADEA release

  10. PLAN DESIGN ISSUES • Immediate lump sum cash payments from employer almost always would be fine • Deferred cash payments might implicate 409A • Qualified retirement plans • Plan must be amended to provide incentives • Only certain kinds of incentives allowable • Incentives usually cannot be discretionary • In-service benefit commencement subject to limits

  11. PLAN DESIGN ISSUES (continued) • Other plans • Myriad issues • E.g., discrimination in favor of highly paid

  12. CONCLUSION • Most phased retirement initiatives pose little risk if implemented correctly • The one exception are individualized efforts to encourage retirement • If we can provide more guidance, contact • Ethan Lipsig at 213-683-6304 or ethanlipsig@paulhastings.com • Patrick W. Shea at 212-318-6405 or patrickshea@paulhastings.com

More Related