1 / 11

Capacity Development in the context of Decentralisation

Capacity Development in the context of Decentralisation. Some Observations Anthony Land. Presentation Outline. SNS – Towards CD good practice CD Challenges in Decentralisation Context Core Capabilities for local governance. Context: SNS – Towards CD good practice.

salaam
Download Presentation

Capacity Development in the context of Decentralisation

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Capacity Development in the context of Decentralisation Some Observations Anthony Land

  2. Presentation Outline • SNS – Towards CD good practice • CD Challenges in Decentralisation Context • Core Capabilities for local governance

  3. Context: SNS – Towards CD good practice • Long-term iterative perspective – SNS guided by PNG decentralisation policy/strategy, and designed to adapt to emerging priorities over 10-15 yr time horizon. CD prog is PNGs, not AusAIDs ! • Demand-driven – responding to needs and requests identified by national and provincial stakeholders, and negotiated with AusAID counterparts (Co-location) • Multi-level interventions - system-wide eg NEFC work; organisational eg PPII; individual eg TA-counterparts

  4. (Toward good CD practice Continued) • Incentive-based CD support (PPII) – provincial CD support staged, benchmarked/criteria and performance-based • Flexible use of TA – residential + fly-in teams; international + national; TA + co-located; coaching + substitution • M&E for CD: combining learning and accountability – qualitative & quantitative, multiple perspectives

  5. CD Challenges in a Decentralising Context (four themes) • Decentralisation as a whole-of-government/ governance reform • Sector Reforms/ SWAPs: opportunities and threats • Harmonising and aligning CD support • Keeping sight of civil society

  6. 1. Decentralisation as a whole-of-government/ governance reform • Fundamentally a political change process that demands multi-actor engagement (incl. Civil soc) – redefining institutional landscape • A long-term and complex transformation process, difficult to plan and predict • much more than a local govt “sector” reform - it requires engagement across government depts. (eg PLLSMA) • Treat as an integral part of public service reform • goes beyond technical/ organisational fixes – taking account of context is critical eg. state-society relations/ local political economy

  7. 2. SWAPs & Decentralisation: pulling in the same or opposite directions ? Opportunities/potentials: • Offers coherent policy framework – guidelines / standards-supervision/ objectives/ task-role division • Predictable and increased flow of funds – esp important for provinces with low local revenue potential • Conditional grants as instrument CD/ accountability – planning, budgeting, expenditure tracking, reporting • Harmonisation and alignment of external support around national systems – discourages fragmentation of aid flows and forces national systems to work

  8. 2. SWAPs & Decentralisation: pulling in the same or opposite directions ? Threats/risks: • Vertical perspective rather than horizontal perspective – piecemeal rather than holistic • Narrow CD focus on sector technical aspects – overlooking governance and process dimensions • Centralisation of d-m/ planning processes – SWAPs the business of donors, central agency technocrats, uncomfortable with “letting go”. Strengthening central authority, “managerial” approach • undermine local political process incl. multi-actor engagement & local accountability – local level viewed as recipient/ beneficiary, rather than “owner” of sector resources. Deconcentration rather than decentralisation perspective. • Can reduce scope for discretion and choice (priority setting) based on locally determined needs, and incentives for integrated planning

  9. 3. Harmonising and aligning CD support • Risk of multiple CD interventions – every sector/ central agency has its own CD programme/ project for local govt staff/ tech depts, with a narrow focus on sector needs rather than thinking in terms of integrated approach • Lack of coordination between central HR agencies and local government – who is in charge, who is coordinating, resourcing, supply or demand driven ? • Importance of emphasizing provincial CD plan/ strategy and provincial CD/ change capacity – too much attention to supplying CD, too little time to develop capacity to manage CD locally • Sector ministries also need CD - to adapt to new dispensation ! to effectively interface with local authorities and in particular strengthen capabilities for policy coordination and dialogue, programme monitoring, financial control and technical mentoring.

  10. 4. Keeping sight of civil society • What role for CS in a decentralising context? – as legitimate actor in local governance ? • Dialogue and monitoring role in local policy process – creating space and opportunity for local dialogue on local matters eg localising MDGs and strengthening local accountability • Service provider complementing provincial / LLG providers – identifying opportunity for joint action on service delivery • How to ensure access to funding ? – once donor funding is channeled through national budget to local govt budget: implications for their independence and accountability • What kinds of CD support required ? – CD for effective engagement; dialogue, accountability, service delivery

  11. Core Capabilities for Decentralised Governance • Need to look beyond capability to deliver core functions and technical services – necessary but not sufficient: So what else ? • Capability to manage change and adapt – fundamental to long-term organisational/ system sustainability • Capability to dialogue and maintain/ manage multiple relationships – Prov. Govt part of complex network of relationships upward, downwards, horizontal • Capability to motivate, inspire and earn legitimacy – balancing political and administrative dimensions, creating local level legitimacy and internal pride

More Related