1 / 17

Plan for Today: Structural Preconditions for Democracy

Plan for Today: Structural Preconditions for Democracy. Finish debating universality of democracy. Introduce distinction between structural and strategic factors. Become familiar with evidence on relationship between democracy and economic factors. .

shanae
Download Presentation

Plan for Today: Structural Preconditions for Democracy

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Plan for Today:Structural Preconditions for Democracy • Finish debating universality of democracy. • Introduce distinction between structural and strategic factors. • Become familiar with evidence on relationship between democracy and economic factors.

  2. Argument that liberal democracy demands “social homogeneity” of rights • PRO: Need different rights that apply to different citizen groups depending on religion or ethnicity of citizens involved. • CON: • Liberal democracy typically includes minority rights to protect various communities. (e.g. Canada) • India exactly this kind of society, but sustains democracy.

  3. “Bread over democracy” argument • PRO: Authoritarian governments can provide economic goods (including food) more efficiently than democratic governments. • CON: • Poor people benefit from ability to voice complaints and protest (Sen). • Very little evidence that poor people reject democracy once instituted (Sen). • Scant evidence that authoritarian regimes provide economic goods better than democracies.

  4. Structural Factors/ Preconditions Favouring Democracy

  5. Three possible roles of structural factors in transitions • Necessary preconditions or prerequisites. • Sufficient preconditions. • Facilitating or discouraging factors (weaker role).

  6. Structural factors = broad underlying conditions in an environment

  7. Strategic interactions =choices of people, interacting with one another, to produce outcomes

  8. Types of Structural Preconditions Economic factors • Wealth or income per capita

  9. Probability of democratic regime by per capita income (Przeworski & Limongi)

  10. Wealth and Democracy(1989 World Bank Data)

  11. Question about Causal Direction seems more likely Wealth  Democracy? OR Democracy  Wealth?

  12. Economic Development • Broad-based industrial development may  democratization because: • Leads to complex economy that becomes harder for authoritarian regimes to control. • Brings about shifts in class dynamics & changes in social values.

  13. Role of Economic Development More highly educated public Civic culture attitudes – trust, satisfaction, competence Higher economic development Support for democratization Larger middle class (From Huntington, p. 69)

  14. Role of Economic Development – my modification More highly educated public More political efficacy, sense of worth, unwilling to be servile Higher economic development Support for democratization Larger middle class

  15. Economic Development • Broad-based industrial development may  democratization because: • Leads to complex economy that becomes harder for authoritarian regimes to control. • Brings about shifts in class dynamics & changes in social values. • Opens societies to external influences.

  16. Types of Structural Preconditions Economic factors • Class structure

  17. Class Structure • A certain balance of relations among classes is necessary. • Esp. middle class/ bourgeoisie (Aristotle, Moore). • Argued middle class “moderate” for various reasons – sheer numbers or position “in middle”. • Bourgeoisie crucial due to autonomous income. • Powerful landowning class can hinder.

More Related