1 / 13

Macroscopic Realism Emerging from Quantum Physics

This paper discusses the concept of macroscopic realism emerging from quantum physics, particularly focusing on the violation of local realism and macrorealism. It explores the boundaries between classical and quantum systems and the transition from quantum to classical behavior. The paper also examines the role of coarse-graining and the limitations of observability in quantum phenomena.

shawnw
Download Presentation

Macroscopic Realism Emerging from Quantum Physics

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Faculty of Physics University of Vienna, Austria Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information Austrian Academy of Sciences Macroscopic Realism Emerging from Quantum Physics Johannes Koflerand Časlav Brukner 15th UK and European Meeting on the Foundations of Physics University of Leeds, United Kingdom, March 2007

  2. Classical versus Quantum Phase space Continuity Newton’s laws Local Realism Macrorealism Determinism Hilbert space Events, ”Clicks” Schrödinger + Projection Violation of Local Realism Violation of Macrorealism Randomness - Does this mean that the classical world is substantially different from the quantum world? - When and how do physical systems stop to behave quantumly and begin to behave classically?

  3. Macrorealism [Leggett–Garg (1985)] Macrorealism per se “A macroscopic object, which has available to it two or more macroscopically distinct states, is at any given time in a definite one of those states.” Non-invasive measurability “It is possible in principle to determine which of these states the system is in without any effect on the state itself or on the subsequent system dynamics.” Q(t1) Q(t2) t t1 t2 t = 0

  4. t Dichotomic quantity: Q Temporal correlations All macrorealistic theories fulfill the Leggett–Garg inequality t = 0 t t1 t2 t3 t4 Violation  no objective properties prior to and independent of measurements

  5. for When is macrorealism violated? Spin-1/2 Evolution Observable 1/2 Violation of macrorealism Classical Spin precession around x +1 classical Macrorealism –1

  6. Violation of macrorealism for macroscopically large spins? Spin-j precession in magnetic field (totally mixed state!) j Parity of eigenvalue m of Jzmeasurement classical limit Violation of macrorealism for arbitrarily large spins j Shown for local realism [Mermin, Peres]

  7. The quantum-to-classical transition Coherent spin state (t = 0): exact measurement fuzzy measurement fuzzy measurement& limit of large spins This is (continuous and non-invasive) classical physics of a rotated classical spin vector!

  8. Transition to Classicality: General state Quantum Classical Probability to detect in a slot: General density matrix: f can be negative!  Probability for result m: g is non-negative! Hamilton operator: Hamilton function: Classical limit: Ensemble of classical spins with probability distribution g

  9. Superposition versus Mixture

  10. Coarse-graining  Coarse-graining Parity measurement (only two slots) Neighbouring slots (many slots) 1 3 5 7 ... 2 4 6 8 ... Slot 1 (odd) Slot 2 (even) Violation of Macrorealism Classical Physics

  11. No macrorealism despite of coarse-graining Unitary time evolution Ut • Ut is „non-classical“: It acts non-collectively only on two non-neighbouring sub-spaces • Violation of macrorealism because of the „cosine-law“ • - Coarse-graining does not help as j and –j are well separated

  12. Relation Quantum-Classical inaccurate measurements Discrete Classical Physics (macrorealism) Quantum Physics macroscopic objects macroscopic objects limit of large spins limit of large spins Macro Quantum Physics (no macrorealism) Classical Physics (macrorealism)

  13. Conclusions • Classical physics emerges from quantum lawsunder the restriction of coarse-grained measurements, not alone through the limit of large quantum numbers. • Conceptually different from decoherence. Not dynamical, puts the stress on observability and works also for fully isolated systems. • As the resources in the world are limited, there is a fundamental limit for observabilityof quantum phenomena (even if there is no such limit for the validity of quantum theory itself). quant-ph/0609079 New Scientist (March 17, 2007)

More Related