1 / 21

Immune Cell Ontology for Networks (ICON)

Immune Cell Ontology for Networks (ICON). Immunology Ontologies and Their Applications in Processing Clinical Data June 11-13, Buffalo, NY. Confessions. I am an ontological newbie Idea for a new ontology of immune networks Immunologists I’ve talked to like the idea

simone
Download Presentation

Immune Cell Ontology for Networks (ICON)

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Immune Cell Ontology for Networks (ICON) Immunology Ontologies and Their Applications in Processing Clinical Data June 11-13, Buffalo, NY

  2. Confessions • I am an ontological newbie • Idea for a new ontology of immune networks • Immunologists I’ve talked to like the idea • Biostatisticians I’ve talked to like the idea • So, possibly not entirely stupid • Looking for feedback and advice • Looking for friendly collaborators

  3. Immunological case-control studies Lupus Patient Normal Donor

  4. Typical case-control study • Data collection • Hundreds of cell subsets from flow cytometry • Dozens of cytokines from Luminex • Other assays (IHC, single cell PCR etc) • Data analysis • Pairwise comparisons • Apply Bonferroni correctiongives p >> 0.05 • Statistical aggregation e.g. PCA • Often difficult to give biological interpretation

  5. How does an immune response actually work?

  6. Cancer microenvironment network

  7. Missing biological knowledge • Immune response does not consist of isolated cells and cytokines acting independently • Networks coordinated by cell-cell communication • Gap – immune network ontology • Applied ontology that draws strength from pre-existing ontologies

  8. Is a network ontology feasible? • Analysis of regulatory networks suggest that networks map to dynamical attractors • Typically surprisingly few attractors given potential combinatorial explosion • Examples • Boolean regulatory networks (e.g. Kauffman) • Recurring gene network motifs (e.g. Alon)

  9. What’s needed? • Networks consist of cells that communicate via contact- and cytokine-mediated signaling • Components • Cells, cell surface molecules, cytokines • Cell-cell interactions may be specific to particular species, local environments and disease states • Contexts • Species, tissue, disease

  10. Components Contexts

  11. Tentative construction strategy • Iterate • Build cheap “weak links” graph database by text mining • Edges for cell:cell surface molecule, cell surface molecule:cell surface molecule, cell:cytokine, cytokine:cell surface molecule • Question: Does text mining work for anyone here? • Human review to identify spurious links and add species, disease and tissue contexts • Use “confirmed” and “spurious” links as training, validation and test data sets to improve text mining • Split into networks • Split into discrete subgraphs by cutting “weakest” links based on some method of assigning weights to edges

  12. Usage • Queries • Find networks associated with a disease • Find cell subsets, receptors and cytokines associated with a network • Find reagents associated with cell subsets, receptors and cytokines • Find networks most relevant for given cell subsets, receptors and cytokines • Applications • Reference, targeted assay development, better informed fishing expeditions • Basic science – validate novel links or networks

  13. App: Web accessible reference • No existing database • Literature review is laborious • Useful public resource

  14. App: Targeted assay development • What networks are potentially active in disease X? • Which are the most informative cell subsets and/or cytokines for these networks? • What reagents are available to identify the cell subsets and/or cytokines of interest? (Needs additional reagent database)

  15. App: Better fishing expeditions • Sets of cells +/- cytokines in networks • Test for enrichment of networks in treatment groups rather than pairwise-comparisons • Adapt statistical methods developed for enrichment analysis in expression array data (e.g. TANGO or GSEA) • Allows integration of immune biomarkers over multiple panels (e.g. T, B, innate flow panels, Luminex, immunohistochemistry)

  16. Starting point

  17. T cell social network analysis

  18. Initial networks in Protégé (courtesy of Anna Maria)

  19. Acknowledgements • Duke Center for Computational Immunology • Tom Kepler • Lindsay Cowell • Anna Maria Masci • Duke Immune Profiling Cores • Kent Weinhold • David Murdoch • Janet Staats • Sarah Sparks

More Related