1 / 34

Getting Started with Research & The Literature Review Part – 2 Cont

Spring 2014. Getting Started with Research & The Literature Review Part – 2 Cont. Lecture Prepared by: Dr. Peter Bloodsworth Dr. Anjum Naveed & Dr. Usman Ilyas. This Week. The literature review – part 2 concluded Important tips Group activity Technical Writing – how to do it.

Download Presentation

Getting Started with Research & The Literature Review Part – 2 Cont

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Spring 2014 Getting Started with Research&The Literature Review Part – 2 Cont Lecture Prepared by: Dr. Peter Bloodsworth Dr. AnjumNaveed & Dr. UsmanIlyas

  2. This Week • The literature review – part 2 concluded • Important tips • Group activity • Technical Writing – how to do it

  3. Important Tips

  4. Write it Up • While doing Literature review, writing things down is important so that you: • Remember what you read • Understand what is written • Write in your own words • Can test your thinking • Any ideas that cross your mind while reading must be written. • Once written, ideas become far more clear than being in mind • Helps test the real worth of idea. • Try organizing whatever you have written, to give it form of a report. • Organizing the writing is a big problem. • We will talk of some of the difficulties and solutions at later stages

  5. Write it Up • Be systematic • Put dates on pages of notes so when you look back later you know where you were in your thesis • Learn about referencing styles early on • Keep properly formatted references • This WILL save a lot of time later  • Keep your notes safe – don’t lose them • Take them along when you meet your supervisor • Add details of such meeting into your notes • Don’t forget action points and deadlines – Regularly review how you are doing against them!!

  6. Reading Group • Read in groups even if every member reads his/her own related material • Share what you found. • Try explaining what you understood to others • At times, knowledge of other domain can be highly related to yours. • If you can’t explain it then you need to revisit what you read. • Talking about your research and writing it down helps you: • Better understand it • Clear your mind • Identify areas where you are unclear yourself • Others may see things differently which can help

  7. Reading Group • Some faculty members run paper discussions within their research groups. • Remember to share experiences with each other • Research is a collaborative process • Much of what we learn we get from others so share tips with each other • Search the web – so much excellent content out there • Remember we are all different and think in our own ways • Find methods which work for you and help you to understand what you are reading

  8. Reading Group • When the literature review is complete you can break up your group right? • WRONG! • The literature review is a continuous process • You will need people to bounce ideas off • Support each other – research can be stressful (just ask anyone with a PhD ) • Having a fairly diverse group is ideal • Gives different perspectives to problems • Sometimes a fresh look from someone new to a topic can be a big help

  9. Reading Group Activity Activity: Organise yourselves into provisional reading groups of 4-6 students – try to include people you don’t normally work with Each person in the group should: • Introduce themselves (name, e-mail address etc) • Say what topics currently interest them Identify a group coordinator to arrange regular meetings You have around 15 mins

  10. Thesis Topics with Me 2014 • Indoor positioning using sensors and agent-based techniques. • Robotics (multi-rotor or quadcopter) control and decision making • Real-time control via agents in the cloud • Applications eg: disaster management, security.. • Heterogeneous robot teamwork using agent based methods • Intelligent download using the cloud • Social cloud computing – Facebook to share vms

  11. What makes a Research Report • Claim – Problem Statement/Hypothesis/Idea • Argument for/against hypothesis • Possible solution to the problem • Supporting your claim • Analysis • Empirical (Has to be comprehensive and complete) • Theoretical

  12. What makes a Research Report • Warrant the relevance of argument • Use of rules to link the reasoning with claims • Acknowledging and responding to anticipated objections and questions • Questioning your argument as the readers will • Considering alternatives to your argument • Strengthening your argument • Looking at problem/approach from all angles

  13. What makes a Research Report • Evidence for soundness of your argument • Finally • Application, relevance to domain, significance and some history

  14. Thesis Writing • Before you start: • Two methods : write as you go or write a the end • Set a target date for submission • Set intermediary goals and check points • Read up on the rules regarding the thesis • What format does it need to be in? • Is there a word limit? • Have you got everything you need to do the writing? • Do you still need to be doing testing / result gathering? • How will you balance this? • Does you supervisor have any time restrictions? Such as going to a conference or on leave for a period

  15. A Good Thesis Looks Like… • Examples • Notice: • Good presentation • Well organised / structured • Good size not too short or too long • Follows the SEECS formatting requirements • Has been prepared carefully and has had time spent on it

  16. An Example Structure • Abstract • Introduction • Previous work • Your method introduced • Your method perhaps in more detail • Implementation • Results • Conclusion and future work • Bibliography • Appendicies

  17. Caution • Every supervisor may have their own preferred structure / way of thesis preparation • These are general guidelines which should apply in most cases • Communication with your supervisor is essential – try to have an open discussion • Don’t get upset if you don’t always like what you hear • This is for your benefit so accept advice • Query why you are asked to do something but never have heated discussions – will not help either of you

  18. Abstract Two ways of approaching this: • Some like to do it first so that they have the structure / argument of the thesis settled • Others (me included) prefer to write this at the end once the main body of the thesis is finalised • I suggest doing both – create a draft at the beginning and revise it at the end • Try to make it concise yet interesting – want to grab the attention of the reader • Need to show why you have chosen a particular problem – “because my supervisor told me to” isn’t a good answer

  19. Abstract Summarisevery briefly: • Why it is a worthy problem / potential impact • Why it hasn’t been solved so far • What you propose to do • How you are going to evaluate it • Summary of results • Try to keep within one page – approx 500 words • Write mainly in the future tense: “This thesis will show….” • Use the third person … No I, we etc.

  20. Introduction • Start by introducing the problem domain in more detail • If you have written a draft abstract use it to guide you – expand each sentence from the beginning part of the abstract into one or more paragraphs • Significance / application of your solution • Plan Sections / Sub-sections before writing • Describe any assumptions / simplifications that you have made • Have a clear problem statement or research hypothesis or both • Have some research questions which encompass the problem statement or allow you to answer the hypothesis

  21. Introduction • Aim for a logical flow between research questions • Check that they are not: • Too ambitious • Too vague • Badly worded so as to be unclear or misleading • Irrelevant to your work • Questions which have a yes / no answer

  22. Introduction • Next you need to describe at a high level how you are going to do the research • This is often called your research method • Try to be clear in what you write • Have a well structured approach to doing your work • Be logical and rigorous • Briefly describe how you plan to evaluate your work • Could be quantitatively or qualitatively or both

  23. Introduction • Finally list any constraints / boundaries that you are setting for your work clearly • Explain why throughout – for each decision you make • You may want to introduce a criteria by which you can judge the success of your system / concept • Last thing: describe the structure of the remaining thesis

  24. Previous Work • Otherwise known as your literature review, have said a lot about that already in previous weeksso won’t repeat Some structural points that may help: • Start off with overview – what broad areas do you need to consider and how do they relate? • In each main area which systems / approaches / results are of interest and pick out specific ones that are particularly relevant to your work and why? • What did they do, what didn’t they do and what conclusions can you draw for your work? Explain conclusions as you go. • Have a final discussion or concluding section which focuses on your area and leads into the following chapter

  25. Lead In and Lead Outs • This is very important in making a thesis readable • The end of each chapter should lead into the next one. • The start of the new chapter should pick up the theme of the previous lead out • Each section should lead into the next • Each paragraph should also lead into the next in a logical way

  26. Chapters About Your Work • Plan the chapter carefully, list the content that you want to present down on paper before writing • Organise your points in a logical flowing way • Start off with a GENTLE introduction to your approach • Remember that you will be an expert in the area of your thesis but the reader might need time to get your message or meaning • Use simple examples to show how complex processes work • Pick a case study and use it throughout your thesis to explain points • Describe technical details very carefully and don’t assume that the reader knows it already

  27. Chapters About Your Work • Explain architectural points clearly • Give clear reasons for the important decisions that you have made in designing your work • If there are potential drawbacks to the approach then acknowledge them and suggest how they may be overcome • Gradually go into more detail don’t just jump in • Use technical language appropriately and in the right context • Link the technical details of your proposed system / architecture to the problems with existing work that you identified in your Previous Work chapter

  28. Implementation • Be very careful when you describe your implemented system • Ask a friend to read your description to see if they think that using it they could build the system • Be sure that you explain implementation choices • Need to convince the reader that you have been rigorous in the way you have set up your prototype • Ensure that implementation decisions don’t influence your final results by biasing your experiments • Try to predict potential nasty questions and answer them in advance – will make your final defense easier

  29. Results • Describe carefully what you are trying to show and how this relates to your hypothesis / problem statement • Explain how you are going to do this using a set of experiments / tests • Thoroughly describe each experimental set up • As you do think about what a reader could question and try to give an answer in advance • How have you ensured that all tests are fair? • What assumptions have you made and why?

  30. Results • Look back to your literature review – how do other researchers in your domain test their systems / approaches? • What metrics are commonly used? • Are there any standard datasets that researchers use to evaluate their work? • Be careful with your technical language especially if mathematical or statistical where there is very little room for error • Look up a term if you don’t completely understand it – don’t guess

  31. Results • Relate your final results to the research method that you described in your first chapter • Apply any criteria for success that you set at the beginning of your thesis • Use appropriate methods of illustrating results such as graphs and tables • Be careful with the presentation of any figures you use make sure they: • Have a clear title • Have a legend where appropriate • Are readable • Make the point you want them to • Are linked into the text and explained • Don’t have too many figures as they break the text up

  32. Conclusion and Future Work Very important chapter don’t rush it! • Start by reviewing what you said you would do in your abstract and Introduction • Summarise the main points that you have covered in the thesis – give special focus to your experimental set up and results • Show areas where you have made a contribution and answer any research questions you have set yourself

  33. Conclusion and Future Work • Make a judgementregarding your hypothesis / problem statement and explain how your results confirm this • Say what directions your work may take in the future • Your chance to say what you would have done if you weren’t constrained by time • You can speculate regarding how your work could be used by others in the future • Be sensible though don’t claim too much

  34. Job Done Then? • Sadly not  • Now go through and make sure it is consistent • Get the logical flow right • Remove loose ends that examiners could latch on to • Will likely require significant tweaks to each chapter • Finally do a last proof read format check and get ready to submit

More Related