1 / 17

Family

Family. Family law central to status and rights of women 1848 Seneca Falls convention focused particularly on family law issues: Marriage Divorce Property Custody of children. Women’s Rights in the Family: Two Problems. Difficulties in determining the rules of family law

tam
Download Presentation

Family

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Family • Family law central to status and rights of women • 1848 Seneca Falls convention focused particularly on family law issues: • Marriage • Divorce • Property • Custody of children

  2. Women’s Rights in the Family: Two Problems • Difficulties in determining the rules of family law • Difficulties in determining which rules will promote women’s rights. • States have jurisdiction over family matters • 50 different systems • Complexity added by combination of legislation and judicial precedent

  3. States and Family Law • States have jurisdiction but in practice families and family behavior are not of government concern. • Family = Private • Laws may require certain behaviors but in practice there is not uniform conformity with law. • Eg; Defense Of Marriage Act – legally defines marriage – has not prevented people outside this definition from setting up “marriage-like” relationships.

  4. Two Perspectives on Family Law • Gender role focus • Comparing rights and responsibilities for women and men • Underlying theories of gender roles give meaning to the content of rules/regulations • The effects of gender-roles on the status of women • There is little agreement on this (cultural diversity) • Affected by changing family arrangements and relationships • Judges, lawyers, family members private views

  5. Role of Feminists • Minor role in the family law debate • Feminists disagree on what is in the best interest of women • Lawyers are interested and tend to dominate debates • Contemporary women’s movement deeply affected • Feminist theory attacks patriarchal arrangements • Unequal burden of house/paid work responsibilities • Economically dependent women – special protection?

  6. Examples of Legal variation • 50 sets of: • Adoption procedures • Who is eligible to adopt • When is adoption finalized • Costs of adoption • Who can offer children/broker adoptions • Information and privacy rights of birth/adoptive parents and adopted • Marriage rules and procedures • Non-marital children • Divorce Laws • Property arrangements • Waiting periods • Conditions for divorce

  7. Marriage Regulations Acceptable partners Minimum age Surname after marriage Domicile laws Interspousal immunity Marital support Marital services Marital Property Divorce Legal Fault based No-fault based Alimony Property Parental Rights and Responsibilities Custody after divorce Child support and non-support Families without Marriage “soul mates” (Bruce and Wendy) Gay marriage Property rights Cohabitation laws – illegal! Children born out of wedlock? Legal status depends on the father. Examples of Legal variation

  8. Marriage • Unity of Husband and Wife – Coverture • A “covered” woman; a married woman joins her identity with her husband losing her status as “femme sole” • Woman disappears as an independent entity • First challenges to this were from wealthy fathers seeking to protect property from husband’s creditors • Political theory critique: no equality, not democratic • Gradual evolution: property protected, right to control earnings, women were granted contract and liability status (legal status of women has driven legal entity of “marriage”)

  9. Marriage • Traditional view: Judeo-Christian idea of lifelong commitment between a man and a woman for the purpose of producing and nurturing children • Governmental presence: has established responsibilities/rights applicable to “legally sanctioned” unions. • When problems arise – govt involved in dispute resolution (child custody, spousal support) • Shared-partnership reforms have varied from state to state

  10. Marriage • Separate-but-equal legal status • 1900-1968 marriage was technically viewed as a relationship between two different individuals making equally important contributions • Common-law civil liabilities still in place • Shared equal partnership • Focus on shared overlapping responsibilities • Movement away from duty assignment based on sex • Piecemeal evolution could accommodate this change

  11. Marriage Law • Fundamentally concerned with: • Creation of union (marriage) • Dissolution of union (divorce) • Constitutional presence? • None specifically – historically left to states • Full faith and credit clause • Supremacy clause • Any constitutional amendment will conflict with 14th amendment -> equal protection under the law • Supreme court would have to “balance”

  12. Marriage Law • Acceptable partners – racial and sex regulations, fees and licenses – racial prohibitions dropped (Loving v. Virginia 1967) sex restrictions still in force • Minimum Age – age requirements still in effect unless the bride is pregnant; then no age restriction exists – all states 18 w/o consent variation (14-18) with consent. • Surname after marriage – few specific statutes; most women take husbands name mostly because of custom. Costs of keeping birth name: some states require wives to use husband’s name on particular documents; courts have upheld states ability to require this of married women only; variation in state laws necessitates explanations to bankers, realtors, insurance companies. Costs of changing your name: divorce, multiple name changes, credit record problems; men unaffected.

  13. Marriage Law • Interspousal immunity – spouses cannot enter into contracts with one another nor can they sue each other in court • Problem when women tried to press charges against abusive husbands • Married Women Property Acts – some courts interpret them as allowing contracts and lawsuits others do not

  14. Marital-Support Laws • Under common law husbands obligated to support wives • Reform simply extended responsibility for family debt to wives as well as husbands • Husbands not required to pay wives debt; free to refuse eg; McGuire v. McGuire (see page 188) • Today? Each spouse has an obligation to support the other – criminal penalties for abandonment, desertion, nonsupport (reduce state welfare responsibilities)

  15. Marital Property • Women no ownership of property as late as 1968 in some states • “Separate Property” – 42 states • Husband and wife treated as separate individuals • May join resources or act independently • Exceptions are the home/homestead and inheritance; eg: some states give a spouse automatic interest in the other’s estate

  16. Marital Property • Community Property • 8 states: Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas and Washington • Marriage creates community property • Everything jointly owned if acquired after the marriage • Husbands had the power to manage the property but wives had rights to 50% in the event of death or divorce

  17. Evolution of Wife Status • The idea of equal partnership gains ground but has not eliminated either coverture or separate but equal roles • Eg: income earned by wives under Separate but Equal is secondary income (because her role is different yet important to the marriage … in a different way … which some would say is inherently unequal).

More Related