1 / 16

Public Service Pension Schemes

Public Service Pension Schemes. In no particular order!. Pensions apartheid’ ‘Public service millionaires’ CPI/RPI Lord Hutton Lord Turner Final Salary v CARE Discount rate Fair Deal Cost/risk sharing Dependency / support ratio Replacement ratio Pay as you go

tokala
Download Presentation

Public Service Pension Schemes

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Public Service Pension Schemes

  2. In no particular order! • Pensions apartheid’ • ‘Public service millionaires’ • CPI/RPI • Lord Hutton • Lord Turner • Final Salary v CARE • Discount rate • Fair Deal • Cost/risk sharing • Dependency / support ratio • Replacement ratio • Pay as you go • Comprehensive Spending Review • Fixed cost ceiling • Public service ‘framework’ • Pay Review Bodies • Tiered contributions/progressive contributions • Longevity • NEST • Protection of accrued benefits • Defined benefit • Ponzi schemes • Defined contribution

  3. The Growing Disparity and Longevity • ONS 2008 data shows there to be 3.6 million private sector employees in DB schemes – there were 6.5 million in 1991 and 8.1 million in 1967 • In contrast there are just over 5 million active members within the public sector in DB schemes and just over 12 million members • Public sector schemes have near 85% take-up whereas in the private sector 2/3rds of employees don’t even receive a pension contribution • Retiring at 60 you could live 40-45% of adult life in retirement. (1950s = 30%)

  4. Public Service Schemes - Timeline • 22 June 2010 - Emergency Budget outlined move to CPI indexation • CSR statement of 20 October outlined “progressive contribution increases” • 10 March 2011 – Lord Hutton produced final recommendations for reform • Fair Deal consultation “live” with deadline date of 15 June 2011

  5. 1 - Contribution Increases • The Government announced in the CSR a cut in funding to PAYG schemes of £2.8 billion a year by 2014/15 • This equates to just over a 3% average contribution increase for members • Contributions to be phased in “progressively” from 2012, with a 40% saving in 12-13, another 40% in 13-14 and the remaining 20% in 14-15

  6. 1 - Contribution Increases (2) • All these savings will be made by higher member contributions • The lower paid will be “protected” • The increases should be ‘progressive’ • Following a meeting with the PSLG the Government has decided to postpone further discussion and consultation to the Summer • This is effectively a Government tax on public service pension scheme members • The Government thinks only 1% will opt-out.

  7. What are the current NHSPS contributions?

  8. 2 – The Move to CPI • The Government appears committed to increasing public service pensions by CPI instead of RPI from April 2011 • The consequences are significant. CPI is typically, on average, 0.7% per year lower than RPI • The OBR predict that pensions will be 8.5% less by 2017 • Lord Hutton says this move alone represents a 15% cut in benefits

  9. What exactly is CPI? • Both CPI and RPI calculate how prices change for a typical basket of goods that people buy to work out the inflation rate • Significantly however the CPI excludes changes to housing costs, council tax, TV licence fees and vehicle excise duty • The Royal Statistical Society, Institute for Fiscal Studies and UK Statistics Authority don’t believe the CPI to properly reflect pensioner spending patterns

  10. The Implications of CPI • Pensions are likely to increase from April by 3.1% this year when otherwise would have increased by 4.6% • A woman on the median NHSPS women’s pension of approx £3500pa will be around £53 worse off • A member receiving the overall average public service pension of around £7800pa will be around £117 a year worse off

  11. 3 – The move away from a final salary scheme • Lord Hutton stated in his Interim Report of 7 October that final salary schemes “disproportionately” favour ‘high flyers’ • He has recommended switching to a career average scheme for future service by the end of the next parliament – i.e. 2015 • He has stated that each year’s pension earned in a new CARE scheme should increase in line with increases in average earnings

  12. What is a CARE scheme? • Career Average Re-evaluation of Earnings • This is a scheme that bases benefits on average pensionable earnings • Such a scheme could potentially benefit members whose annual salary increases are generally less than inflation and who are unlikely to benefit from regular promotions • The devil is in the detail however and the RCN is not necessarily against a CARE scheme as long as it’s not a clear cost-cutting exercise • The new scheme for civil servants is a CARE scheme and GPs have a CARE scheme

  13. 4 - Increasing Retirement Ages? • The Government has already brought forward the State Pension Age (SPA) equalisation date meaning that from November 2018 the SPA will be 65 for both men and women • From April 2020 the SPA will be 66 for both men and women. Under current legislation the SPA is due to rise to 67 between 2034-2036 and 68 between 2044-2046 • Lord Hutton has stated that with exception of “uniformed services” NRA’s should increase in line with SPA

  14. 5 – The Abolition of Fair Deal? • The Government stated in the CSR that it will launch a consultation on Fair Deal • Fair Deal is the agreements that enable TUPE transferred staff from public services to either remain in such a scheme or be provided with a “certified” broadly comparable scheme • There is a big danger than the Government will look to scrap because of the relative cost to companies bidding for public service contracts • This would leave TUPE transferred staff at the pensions mercy of private contractors

  15. A summary of what’s possibly in store • Contribution increases • A move from RPI to CPI for increasing pensions • A move away from a final salary scheme • Increasing retirement ages • A worsening position for TUPE transferred members

  16. And don’t forget…. • The contribution increase talks have already been put back to the Summer • Don’t panic, there is nothing to be gained in opting-out of schemes fearing the worst • Both Lord Hutton and the Government have stated that accrued rights will not be affected PUBLIC SERVICE PENSIONS ARE BENCHMARK PENSIONS AND ARE WORTH SAVING!

More Related