1 / 14

Towards a more dynamic view of inter-organizational networks: Antecedents and future directions

Athens University of Economics and Business. Department of Management Science and Technology. Towards a more dynamic view of inter-organizational networks: Antecedents and future directions. Elpida Prasopoulou PhD Supervisor: Dr Nancy Pouloudi. Introduction.

verdad
Download Presentation

Towards a more dynamic view of inter-organizational networks: Antecedents and future directions

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Athens University of Economics and Business Department of Management Science and Technology Towards a more dynamic view of inter-organizational networks: Antecedents and future directions Elpida Prasopoulou PhD Supervisor: Dr Nancy Pouloudi

  2. Introduction • In recent years, there has been a remarkable growth in various forms of co-operation among organizations in various industries (Ebers, 1999) • This tendency towards collaboration in the business world was been supplemented by the upsurge of interest in the role of networks in the academia (Powell & Smith-Doerr, 1995) • The concept of network is in vogue, but its popularity is accompanied by a general vagueness about exactly what the idea entails Elpida Prasopoulou

  3. The concept of “network” • Thus far the concept of network has been used to, explicitly or implicitly, describe: • social networks (Burt, 1992) • governance mechanisms (Powell, 1990) • new organizational forms (Miles & Snow, 1986) • Moreover, the concept of network has been examined through the lenses of various theoretical perspectives: • economic sociology (Granovetter, 1985) • strategic management (Gulati, 1998) • organization theory (Ebers, 1999) • information systems (DeSanctis & Fulk, 1999) Elpida Prasopoulou

  4. What is a network? • The most general use of the term “network” is the structure of ties among the actors in a social system (Nohria & Eccles, 1996) • These actors may be: roles, individual persons, organizations, industries, nation states • Their ties may be based on: conversation, affection, friendship, kinship, authority, economic exchange, information exchange or anything else that forms the basis of a relation • In this broad sense the structure of any social organization can be thought of as a network Elpida Prasopoulou

  5. Inter-organizational networks • In my research, I focus on the governance mechanisms that regulate interaction among organizations • Thus, the unit of analysis is the inter-organizational network • An inter-organizational network is a particular form of organizing or governing recurring exchange relationships among a limited number of organizations that retain residual control of their individual resources yet periodically jointly decide over their use (Ebers, 1999) Elpida Prasopoulou

  6. Research work on inter-organizational networks • The main body of research in inter-organizational networks has examined: • when, where, why and how organizations engage in inter-organizational networking (Embers, 1999; Alter & Hage, 1993) • with whom firms built networks (Gulati & Garguilo, 1999) • However, all these studies are static and focus primarily on the initial stages of inter-organizational network formation • Studies that adopt a more dynamic perspective on inter-organizational networks are scarce: • Mainly Ring & Van de Ven (1992), Larson (1992) and Hamel (1991) provided models investigating the dynamic processes that underlie the evolution of this form of organizing • However, the majority of these articles are conceptual and do not provide empirical grounding Elpida Prasopoulou

  7. Inter-organizational network formation • If we focus in the selection of partners, we can see that current literature has identified two major trends: • The deployment of social networks as a reservoir for potential partners in order to decrease uncertainty associated with the choice of partners (Gulati & Garguilo, 1999) • The role of status similarity as a incentive to collaborate (Podolny, 1994) • Real life examples show that these two parameters do not guarantee the successful operation of an inter-organizational network • Instead, the initiators of an inter-organizational network must create a web of allies that will support the initiative inside each participating organization Elpida Prasopoulou

  8. Research question • How do inter-organizational networks evolve? • We need a theoretical approach that: • provides the basis for a more dynamic perspective of the networking phenomenon • accounts for the difficulties of the initiating actors Elpida Prasopoulou

  9. Actor-network theory and inter-organizational networks • Actor-network theory and more specifically the four moments of translation (problematization, interessement, enrollment, mobilization; Callon, 1986) provide a conceptual vehicle to describe the stages of inter-organizational network formation • Through the four moments of translation the various alliances that the network initiators need to go through in order to enroll all the necessary actors are highlighted • All the relevant actors are acknowledged whether they participate in the final network or not • ANT as a perspective is more dynamic and takes into account the dimension of time in the analysis Elpida Prasopoulou

  10. Research design • Interpretivist research approach • Longitudinal case study supported by a synthesis of relevant literature Tools & methods • Qualitative data collection methods (semi-structured interviews, documentation) • participant observation Elpida Prasopoulou

  11. Empirical context: Global eManagement MBA • GeM is an inter-organizational network among 10 renowned business schools, namely AUEB, CBS, RSM, NHH, Reykjavik, GSU, ESADE, EGADE, Denver, Cologne • The purpose of this arrangement is to offer an executive program in eManagement • Additionally, the program offers: • International seminars • Global team exercises • Internet-based courses • Why GeM? It provides a fertile ground for study • inter-organizational • multi-national • polycentric character Elpida Prasopoulou

  12. Preliminary findings • ANT indicates that GeM was not a simple inter-organizational initiative • GeM should be interpreted as an organizational change project which demanded changes in the operation of the participating universities and the teaching and learning practices of the participating actors • The reason why GeM was a loosely coupled network where the universities operated semi-autonomously can be traced to the limited support that some universities provided • During the fall of demand in e-business courses there was not a coherent network of actors to support and promote GeM • The perceptions and actions of actors that were not directly involved (deans, rectors) in the alliance influenced the course of GeM Elpida Prasopoulou

  13. Contribution • A deeper understanding of the dynamic processes underlying inter-organizational networks • Gain theoretical insights from ANT that can benefit strategic management literature • Understanding of academic networks (including EU projects) Elpida Prasopoulou

  14. Research work • First classification of literature, identification of open issues • Empirical work: first round of interviews, participant observation during 3rd International Seminar of Ring III • Interpretation of inter-organizational network formation using actor-network theory • Presentation of my work in IFIP Joint 8.2 + 9.4 Conference, IS Perspectives and Challenges in the Context of Globalization, 15-17 June 2003, Athens, Greece • There is a need for: • a second round of interviews • further interpretation of the data collected so far Elpida Prasopoulou

More Related