1 / 17

ISSUES FOR POLITICAL PARTIES ENGAGEMENT WITH THE CONSTITUTIONAL REVIEW PROCESS

ISSUES FOR POLITICAL PARTIES ENGAGEMENT WITH THE CONSTITUTIONAL REVIEW PROCESS. BY YASMIN JUSU-SHERIFF INDEPENDENT LEGAL CONSULTANT. EMERGING ISSUES IN S.L CONSTITUTIONAL REVIEW 2013-15. TORS FOR THE PRESENTATION

wyatt
Download Presentation

ISSUES FOR POLITICAL PARTIES ENGAGEMENT WITH THE CONSTITUTIONAL REVIEW PROCESS

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. ISSUES FOR POLITICAL PARTIES ENGAGEMENT WITH THE CONSTITUTIONAL REVIEW PROCESS BY YASMIN JUSU-SHERIFF INDEPENDENT LEGAL CONSULTANT

  2. EMERGING ISSUES IN S.L CONSTITUTIONAL REVIEW 2013-15 TORS FOR THE PRESENTATION • Analysis of the 1991 S.L. Constitution related to Areas of Interest to political parties • Identify Gaps and potential intervention areasfor political parties • Recommendations to support political parties’ engagements with the entire constitutional review process

  3. Background S.L. has had 4 Constitutions since 1961: 1961- Independence Constitution 1971- Republican Constitution 1978-One Party Constitution 1991- Return to Multi Party Constitution -Resulted from civil society initiatives(Sierra Leone Bar Assn Conference & FBC Student Union advocacy); 1ST Time drafted thru broad participatory processes involving more than just politicians.

  4. Background Contd • In April 1992 NPRC suspended 7 month old 1991 Constitution and political parties; Advisory Council’s 1993 draft constitution was still born • Both Lome Peace Accord 1999 & TRC Report 2004 call for constitutional review as peace building and peace consolidation strategy. • Limited effort to comply until Peter Tucker Review Commission(PTRC) appointed by Pres Tejan Kabbah in Jan 2007 & Report presented to Pres Koroma in Jan 2008

  5. Background Contd • Over 5 years elapsed between presentation of PTRC Rept & Govt’s response: July 2013- new Cowan CRC charged to “Review the Constitution of Sierra Leone, Act No. 6 of 1991” including: • With 84 members, the new committee has a much larger membership than any previous CRC constitutional roughly 25% drawn from government or state institutions, 40% from political parties and the remainder from civil society and non- government organisations. • Even after clamour 19 women only on CRC; well short of TRC Recommendation & President Koromas’s 2010 promise in Moyambaas the minimum quota/proportion of women to sit on any decision-making body. .

  6. Issues for Political Parties • The Language and style of the Constitution is difficult and inaccessible to almost everyone • The obligation on the citizens to abide by the Constitution is not matched by any obligation on Government to educate citizens on the Constitution or to make it accessible • Building, consolidating and sustaining PEACE are not mentioned among the political objectives I

  7. ISSUES FOR POLITICAL PARTIES • Chapter II- ‘Principles of State Policy’ – described as ‘codes of conduct for the Executive, the Legislature, the Judiciary and the Public’; ‘the terms of the social contract between all Sierra Leoneans that is the basis for our voluntary union in the state’;- this chapter is limited in scope, insufficient protection of land & natural resources and NOT justiciable

  8. ISSUES FOR POLITICAL PARTIES • PRINCIPLES OF STATE POLICY Directive Required that Principles to be used effectively by 3 arms of government even if not Justiciable. See Ghana Const Emphasize Accountability , Consultation & Information sharing obligations of MPs & Councilors; Strengthen language on Corruption and tackling Inequality; Emphasize Peace Building; building a culture of community & care; Include tolerance of divergent views, respect for difference, Citizen Participation, proactive citizenship,

  9. ISSUES FOR POLITICAL PARTIES • Entrenched equal rights to Citizenship lacking(see PTRC) • Local Government to be guaranteed recognition, status as Chieftaincy is • Death Penalty NOT abolished (see TRC rec cfd to PTRC) • Proposed PTRC Anti Discrimination provision(section 27) is improvement but could be clearer in particular subjecting the institution of Chieftaincy, customary law & usage to principle of Non Discrimination

  10. ISSUES FOR POLITICAL PARTIES Chapter III- ‘Recognition & Protection of Fundamental HRs- Social & Economic Rights not included- adopt and expand PTRC recs Non –Discrimination principle to be strengthened & made overarching; Equality of Opportunity to be emphasized -Individual Rights should be interpreted expansively the Courts -Rights to Health including Reproductive Health Rights, Education, Work opportunities, Food, Shelter & Clothing to be JUSTICIABLE • Excellent new Right to a Clean Environment

  11. ISSUES FOR POLITICAL PARTIES Current weak Governance due to ineffective Separation of Powers between the 3 arms of Government & ‘Over mighty’ Executive. PTRC recommends remedy by -No MP is to be nominated as Minister or Deputy s56 -Separation of AG from Minister of Justice(TRC & PTRC Rec) *** -ALL presidential appointments to be subject to parliamentary approval- currently many appointments including temporary judges and plethora of ‘advisors’ and ‘special assistants’ are not -Section 77- Party/MP relations

  12. TRC Recommendations for Inclusion in Constitution -Enshrine ‘human dignity’ as Part III right & Guarantee non-derogable HRs during Emergency(accepted by PTRC) -Outlawing of Corporal Punishment thru out S.L. society -Binding Code of Conduct for Judges & Magistrates as well as civil servants. What about for politicians? -Limit Political Campaign contributions *Related Rec- Limits on costs of governance and salaries of public officials, MPs etc as percentage of GDP

  13. ISSUES FOR POLITICAL PARTIES • LAND RIGHTS - Land should not be just like any other commodity & Citizens’ access to Land to be guaranteed; foreigners shouldn’t have same rights as citizens over land; Land should always revert back to citizens;Principles on Land Investment to protect against Land Grabs • PROTECTION OF NATURAL RESOURCES - Entrench the Sovereign Wealth & Transformation Fund; Affirmative Action measures to have priority call on such a fund;Guarantee that Extractives to benefit all Sierra Leoneans see South Sudan Constitution • YOUTH Special recognition and protection for childhood and youth in Chapter II and Chapter III

  14. Issues for Political Parties CON’T WOMEN’S RIGHTS • Unequivocal provisions confirming Equal Rights of Women. • Put all CEDAW Rights into Part III • Ensure Stronger Property Rights especially access to Land , Affirmative Action, Anti Discrimination and 30% Quota in decision making • Equal Opportunity/uniform access to leadership positions. • Repeal of section 27(4)(d) and (e) and gender discriminatory provisions in all laws • Make Constitutional Recognition of Customary Law and chieftaincy subject to principle of Non Discrimination • Remove barriers of custom and tradition to women’s access to chieftaincy and traditional governance; Confirm section 8(1)(a) of the Chieftaincy Act • Prioritize Equal Access to justice; place obligation on Judiciary to ensure it

  15. POLITICAL PARTIES IN THE CRC PROCESS • Take Leadership or Die; Civil Society is on the move • Champion Public Awareness and participation; Demonstrate political parties comparative advantage in mass mobilisation • Push the boundaries of the debate; take risks with important but controversial issues • Engage MPs from the outset; don’t allow them to see themselves as marginalised /excluded and therefore justified to be spoilers at the end

  16. POLITICAL PARTIES IN THE CRC PROCESS • Urge CRC to simplify the Constitution, clear language etc; use of national languages and multi media formats not just print • Call for CRC to look at existing obnoxious laws e.g- Public Order Act and recommend their repeal not just limit selves to Constitution

  17. CONCLUSIONSTHE END • THANK YOU FOR LISTENING • Questions comments

More Related