1 / 18

Constitutional Aspects of Croatian Accession to the EU

Constitutional Aspects of Croatian Accession to the EU. By Tamara Ćapeta (October 2007). Place of domestic constitutions in EU system. Formally – EU indefferent to national constitutions Substantively – domestic constitutions supply legitimacy to EU legal order

wynn
Download Presentation

Constitutional Aspects of Croatian Accession to the EU

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Constitutional Aspects of Croatian Accession to the EU By Tamara Ćapeta (October 2007)

  2. Place of domestic constitutions in EU system • Formally – EU indefferent to national constitutions • Substantively – domestic constitutions supply legitimacy to EU legal order • “composite constitution”- balancing domestic and EU constitution

  3. When does domestic constitution become relevant in accession process? • No negotiating chapter on ‘constitutional impact of EU membership’ • Constitutions should, however, be considered before membership

  4. Types of constitutional provisions influenced by EU membership • Constitutional basis for membership • Organisation of domestic institutions of governement for participation in EU decision-making • application of EU decisions in domestic order and the relationship between EU and domestic rules • Other specific provisions

  5. Constitutional basis for membership • Provision enabling accession • General transfer of powers • Transfer of powers to the EU • Separate EU chapter (comparative overview) • Provision regulating the adoption of the EU Treaties amendments

  6. Constitutional basis for membership • Voting requirements • Usually the act by which accession treaty is accepted requires higher majorities then usually for the adoption of international treaties • Parliamentary procedure often coupled by referendum

  7. Institutional arrangements • Relationship between parliament and government • Parliamentary control over government representatives in Council • Implementation of EU law • Participation of parliament in EU affairs as provided by EU Treaties

  8. Relationship between EU and domestic law • Supremacy and direct effect of EU law • Ordinary supremacy: often solved in practice on the basis of either transfer of powers provisions, or provisions governing position of international treaties in constitutional order • Supremacy over constitution: constitutional tolerance • Powers of the courts to review Laws for conformity with EU law (Simmenthal requirement)

  9. Other specific provisions • Voting rights at local and European Parliament elections • Central bank independence • Ownership of land • Extradition • Discussed during negotiations in different chapters

  10. Croatian Constitution – basis for membership • Undecided – 2 possible provisions • Article 141: association into alliance with other states • Article 139/2 : transfer of powers on international organisations

  11. How to decide? • Voting requirements • Article 141 : 2/3 majority in parliament + obligatory referendum – majority of total number of electors (electorate includes also diaspora) • Article 139 : 2/3 majority in parliament + referendum possible – Art. 86 majority of voters who voted; required turnout: majority; referendum outcome is binding

  12. Citizens support for EU membership • 2000 (July): FOR – 77,6% AGAINST – 7,9% • 2001 (Dec): FOR – 76,9% AGAINST – 13,2% • 2002 (Dec): FOR – 75,7% AGAINST – 12,9% • 2003 (Jun): FOR – 73,6% AGAINST – 13,5% • 2004 (Aug): FOR – 51,0% AGAINST – 39,0% • 2005 (Aug): FOR – 41,9% AGAINST – 47,9% • 2005 (Dec): FOR – 48,6% AGAINST – 44,0% • 2007 (Spring) – different survey: • 29% - EU membership good • 28% - EU membership bad • 40% - neither good nor bad • 3% - do not know

  13. How to decide? • Political pragmatism • Government that wants Croatia in the EU would try to avoid Article 141 as constitutional basis for membership

  14. How to decide? • Purpose of constitutional provision • Art. 141 : to disassociate from Yugoslavia; not to become EC/EU member (?) • Art. 139/2 – not for UN, not for SAA, not for WTO, was probably not introduced for EC either – no purpose?

  15. How to decide? • Relevance of EU Constitutional Treaty failure/Reform Treaty • perception of EU as ‘alliance of states’ – application of Art. 141 • Perception of EU as ‘international organisation of states’ – application of Art. 139/2

  16. The third solution • To introduce specific EU legal basis in the Constitution • Reasons in favor: • Importance of EU in the life of a Member State • Importance of constitution for the determination of a state – “taking constitution seriously”

  17. Other provisions in present Croatian Constitution important for EU membership • Institutional provisions not adjusted for EU membership • Voting for local and EU elections not possible • Extradition of Croatians not possible • Constitutional law on Constitutional Courts – review of constitutonality centralised (interpretation conform to EU requirements possible)

  18. EU Chapter • Provision allowing for membership in the EU, providing for adequate procedure – higher majority in parliament + opitonal referendum • Provison providing solution for ratification of future EU Treaties amendments • Substantive conditions for membership, and acceptance of future changes (?) • Provision on leaving the EU (?) • Provision deciding on appropriate procedure for implementation of EU law (relationship parliament – government) • Provision deciding on parliamentary control of government in EU affairs • Provision deciding on participation of parliament directly in EU affairs • Provision deciding on the relationship between EU and domestic law, and the role of courts (?)

More Related