1 / 31

Constitution, Society, and Leadership Week 6 Unit 1 History of Rights: Topic Introduction

Constitution, Society, and Leadership Week 6 Unit 1 History of Rights: Topic Introduction. Christopher Dreisbach, Ph.D. Johns Hopkins University. History of Rights: Topic Introduction- i Unit Overview- i. This unit has three main sections Review: Types of Rights

Download Presentation

Constitution, Society, and Leadership Week 6 Unit 1 History of Rights: Topic Introduction

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Constitution, Society, and Leadership Week 6 Unit 1 History of Rights: Topic Introduction Christopher Dreisbach, Ph.D. Johns Hopkins University

  2. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-iUnit Overview-i • This unit has three main sections • Review: Types of Rights • Review: History of Ideas • Looking ahead to the 3 remaining units

  3. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-iiTypes: A Review-i • Four basic types of rights • Inalienable and positive • Inalienable and negative • Conferred and positive • Conferred and negative

  4. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-iiiTypes: A Review-ii • An inalienable right • Cannot be taken away • Cannot be given away • The Declaration of Independence claims at least three inalienable rights • Life • Liberty • Pursuit of Happiness

  5. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-ivTypes: A Review-iii • Conferred rights can be • Taken away • Given away • All rights the Constitution recognizes are conferred rights.

  6. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-vTypes: A Review-iv • A positive right entails someone else’s duty to help the rights holder exercise that right. • E.g., in a valid contract to buy a car, the buyer has a right to the car to the extent that the seller has a duty to give up the car.

  7. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-viTypes: A Review-v • A negative right is simply the right to be left alone in the enjoyment of that right. • E.g., while I might have a right to brush my teeth, no one else has a duty to brush them in order for me to exercise my right. • Roe v. Wade confers a negative right on a woman to have an abortion. • No one has a duty to give her one.

  8. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-viiTypes: A Review-vi • In addition to the four basic types of rights • Rights can be legal, but not moral • E.g., the legal right prior to 1865 to own slaves in the United States • Rights can be moral, but not legal • E.g., Rosa Park’s right to take an empty seat on a public bus in Montgomery, Al in 1955. • And a right can be both moral and legal.

  9. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-viiiTypes: A Review-vii • Thus there are at least 8 logically possible sorts of rights: • Legal, inalienable, positive • Legal, inalienable, negative • Legal, conferred, positive • Legal, conferred, negative

  10. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-ixTypes: A Review-viii • Moral, inalienable, positive • Moral, inalienable, negative • Moral, conferred, positive • Moral, conferred, negative

  11. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xHistory of Ideas: A Review-i • Our topic this week is the history of rights • More to the point: the history of the idea of rights • Recall: One way to think about the general history of ideas in western thought is to divide that history into five basic periods • While recognizing that a sixth period appears to be emerging

  12. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xiHistory of Ideas: A Review-ii • These periods include • Ancient • Medieval • Early Modern • 19th Century • 20th Century • And perhaps: • Early 21st Century

  13. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xiiHistory of Ideas: A Review-iii • Each period can be distinguished from the others by at least 4 characteristics • Dates • Intellectual focus • Key thinkers • Each period ends in skepticism

  14. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xiiiAncient Thought: A Review-i • 650 BCE-45 CE • Intellectual Focus: Logic • Key Thinkers • Pre-Socratics • Socratics • Socrates (d. 399 BCE) • Plato (d. 347 BCE) • Aristotle (d. 322 BCE)

  15. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xivAncient Thought: A Review-ii • Post-Socratics/ Hellenists • Epicureans • Stoics • Cicero (d. 43 BCE) • Skeptics • Skepticism as the final dominant view in the Ancient period

  16. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xvRights in Ancient Thought • Rights are implied in Ancient discussion of duty • E.g., if I have a duty to treat you with respect, then you have a right to be treated with respect • But there is no explicit mention of rights during this period

  17. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xvMedieval Thought: A Review-i • 450-1500 • Intellectual Focus: Religion • Key Thinkers • Jewish Scholars • Christian Scholars • Augustine (d. 430) • Thomas Aquinas (d. 1274) • Erasmus’s In Praise of Folly as a skeptical capstone of the medieval period

  18. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xviiRights in Medieval Thought • Explicit focus on rights emerges in the latter third of the Medieval period E.g., The Magna Carta—1215 • But a consistent and coherent discussion of rights does not begin until the early Modern period

  19. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xviiiEarly Modern Thought: A Review-i • 1500-1800 • Key Intellectual Focus • New Science • Rationalism v. Skepticism

  20. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xixEarly Modern Thought: A Review-ii • Key Thinkers • Empiricists • Thomas Hobbes (d. 1679) • John Locke (d. 1704) • George Berkeley (d. 1753) • David Hume (d. 1776): A Skeptic • Rationalists • Rene Descartes (d. 1650) • Benedict Spinoza (d. 1677) • Gottfried Leibniz (d. 1716)

  21. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xx19th Century Thought: A Review-i • 1800-1900 • Key Intellectual Focus • Immanuel Kant’s Philosophy • Evolution • American Philosophy • Transcendentalism • Pragmatism

  22. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xxi19th Century Thought: A Review-ii • Key Thinkers • Immanuel Kant (d. 1804) • Georg Friedrich Hegel (d. 1831) • Charles Darwin (d. 1882) • Karl Marx (d. 1883) • Ralph Waldo Emerson (d. 1882) • Henry David Thoreau (d. 1862) • William James (d. 1910) • Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. (d. 1935)

  23. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xxii19th Century Thought: A Review-iii • Ends with nihilism as a dominant intellectual movement

  24. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xxiii20th Century Thought: A Review-i • 1900-present • Possible early 21st Century movement: globalism • Key Intellectual Focus • Science v. Philosophy • Analytic Philosophy • Postmodernism

  25. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xxiv20th Century Thought: A Review-ii • Key Thinkers • Bertrand Russell (d. 1970) • G. E. Moore (d. 1958) • Ludwig Wittgenstein (d. 1951) • Jacques Derrida (d. 2004) • Jean Baudrillard (d. 2007) • Jean-François Lyotard (d. 1998) • Michel Foucault (d. 1984)

  26. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xxv20th Century Thought: A Review-iii • Postmodernism • The dominant intellectual movement at the end of the 20th Century • A form of skepticism

  27. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xxviLooking Ahead-i • This week we will look at some influential theories of rights in an historical context • Keeping in mind the various types of rights • Next week we will look at contemporary theories

  28. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xxviiLooking Ahead-ii • This week relies heavily on Patrick Heyden, ed., The Philosophy of Human Rights (St. Paul, MN: Paragon, 2001).

  29. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xxviiiLooking Ahead-ii • In one sense the history of rights is as old as the history of law, since • Law implies someone’s duty to obey • This implies someone’s right to have that duty obeyed • But the explicit language of “rights” • Emerges tentatively in the Medieval Period • Becomes pronounced in the Early Modern Period

  30. History of Rights: Topic Introduction-xxixLooking Ahead-ii • This week’s discussion has the following units • Unit 2: Magna Carta to the Declaration of Independence • Unit 3: Rousseau to the End of the 18th Century • Unit 4: Kant to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights

  31. Week 6 Unit 1 History of Rights: Topic Introduction Constitution, Society, and Leadership

More Related