170 likes | 484 Views
Announcements. No HW this week (Q4) HW12 due on Friday, December 16 No class on Tuesday, December 13 Thursday schedule on Tuesday, December 13 (in lieu of Thanksgiving day): TA has office hours Final on Thursday, December 22, 11:00 1:30, in Harriman 137.
E N D
Announcements • No HW this week (Q4) • HW12 due on Friday, December 16 • No class on Tuesday, December 13 • Thursday schedule on Tuesday, December 13 (in lieu of Thanksgiving day): TA has office hours • Final on Thursday, December 22, 11:001:30, in Harriman 137 AST 248, Fall 2005
Search for Life in the Universe Chapters 12 (Part 2) & 13 Alien Civilizations AST 248, Fall 2005
Outline • UFOs • Crashed Aliens in Roswell, NM • Crop Circles, Abductions, etc. • Ancient Visitations • Cover-Up & Scientific Disinterest • Where Is Everybody? • Age of Civilization • Cosmic Calendar • Civilization Timescales • Youngest Civilization • Galactic Colonization • Colonization Models • Motives for/against Colonization • Possible Solutions to the Paradox AST 248, Fall 2005
UFOs • Appearance • Jet planes first introduced at the end of World War II public aware of fast-moving aircrafts • First UFO claim in June 1947 • “Flew erratic, like a saucer” flying saucer • ~50% of the public believe in the existence of UFOs • Air Force Investigation • 20-year investigation • 90% of claims discarded • Remaining 10% indeterminate • Lack of proof is no proof AST 248, Fall 2005
Crashed Aliens in Roswell, NM • Known facts • Rancher found crash remnants July 1947 • Military personnel picked up the debris • Remains shown next day in Fort Worth, TX • Claimed to be remains of a weather balloon • Claims by Stanton Friedman (1978) • Crash an alien spacecraft • Alien bodies also recovered • Story hushed up by military • Analysis • Project Mogul: balloon used for secret monitoring of Soviet tests • Witness accounts in seventies contradicted or discounted • Motive for secrecy not clear • Ability to keep secret highly doubtful AST 248, Fall 2005
Crop Circles, Abductions, etc. • Crop circles: • Claim: too accurate and too quick to be done by humans • Shown to be possible • Some admitted to be pranks • Abductions: • Sleep paralysis: common dream during rapid eye movement (REM) • Also known during day dreaming AST 248, Fall 2005
Ancient Visitations • Ancient drawings • Claim: pictures of aliens • Counterclaim: other possibilities abound • Nazca markings • Claim: needed unavailable knowledge • Counterclaim: did not need unavailable knowledge • Claim: could only be seen from space • Counterclaim: could be form of worship • Egyptian pyramids • Claim: Egyptians could not build the pyramids by themselves • Counterclaim: it was shown that the pyramids could be constructed with tools available then AST 248, Fall 2005
Cover-Up & Scientific Disinterest • Cover-up • Motive to avoid alarm: 50% already think that aliens have landed • U.S. Government notoriously unable to keep secrets known by many for a long time • All other governments need to participate in the conspiracy • Scientific disinterest • Stems from lack of evidence, not disinterest • If there was serious evidence, or the chance to obtain serious evidence, scientists would jump at it AST 248, Fall 2005
Where Is Everybody? • Statement of the Paradox • If our civilization is not unique, others would have formed long before us, would now be far more advanced, and would long have colonized the Galaxy • Where are they? • Von Neumann machines • Self replicating robots • Overcome distance by much longer longevity • Frank Tipler: Von Neumann machines would by now have colonized the entire Galaxy • We have seen no evidence our civilization is unique AST 248, Fall 2005
Cosmic Calendar AST 248, Fall 2005
Civilization Timescales • Time to form a civilization :done by us in 4.6 byr • Age of Galaxy: ~10 byr • Time to form civilizations before us: 6 byr • Rate • 1011 stars x 106 probability = 105 civilizations = 1 per 6 x 104 yr • 1011 stars x 106 probability / 20 (heavy element abundance) = 5,000 civilizations = 1 per 105 yr • 1011 stars x 109 probability = 100 civilizations = 1 per 6 x 107 yr AST 248, Fall 2005
Youngest Civilization • Assume youngest civilization 105 years older than us • At a distance of 8 x 104 ly, we would still see it at an age of 2 x 104 yr AST 248, Fall 2005
Colonization Models • Light travel time through the Galaxy • 105 yr • Nuclear-powered travel at 0.1c • 106 yr • Coral Model (0.1c) • Colonize a star and then move on • Add ~ 150 yr per step of 50 yr • Multiplies expansion time by 4 AST 248, Fall 2005
Motives for/against Colonization • For: • “Human” nature • Humankind spread quickly • And then spread more by displacing other people • Against: • Population growth: too expensive • Conquering a backward civilization: not worth defeating “cavemen”, although natural resources may be valuable • Conquering a more advanced civilization: “cavemen” unlikely to defeat us AST 248, Fall 2005
Possible Solutions to the Paradox • We are alone • The numbers in the Drake equation are poorly known, so we are possibly alone • Civilizations but no colonization • Technical difficulties: our estimates may be too optimistic • Sociological reasons: population and energy problems solved another way • Self destruction: we have already come close to nuclear confrontation • There is a Galactic civilization • They are keeping us in a “nature reserve” • We are not interesting • We may be interesting sometime in the future, when our action manifests our cosmic “maturity” AST 248, Fall 2005
Thank you for your attention Good luck on the final: Thursday, December 22, 11:001:30 in Harriman 137 (here) AST 248, Fall 2005