250 likes | 1.14k Views
2. Topics of Discussion. UNDERSTANDING ARTICLE 8 OF THE EEIUNDERSTANDING THE EEI COLLATERAL ANNEXCOMMON NEGOTIATION ISSUESQ
E N D
1. 1 THE ALL IMPORTANT CREDIT TERMS: EEI CREDIT AND COLLATERAL REQUIREMENTS AND EEI COLLATERAL ANNEX Presentation by Elizabeth Sager (JPMorgan) and Randy Osteen (Constellation)
2008 Master Agreement Training Session
November 20, 2008- Houston, Texas
2. 2 Topics of Discussion UNDERSTANDING ARTICLE 8 OF THE EEI
UNDERSTANDING THE EEI COLLATERAL ANNEX
COMMON NEGOTIATION ISSUES
Q&A
3. 3 Understanding Article 8 of the EEI 8.1 (Party A) and 8.2 (Party B)
(a) Financial Information options
(b) Credit Assurances
(c) Collateral Threshold
(d) Downgrade Event
8.3
Grant of Security Interest/Remedies
4. 4 Preparing the contract for a change in credit quality Downgrade Events
Adequate assurance
Objective Criteria For non-rated counterparties
Co-ops, often unrated with capital structure vastly different from investor-owned companies
Hedge funds, generally unrated, foreign and domestic, may reference NAV change.
Consider collateralization rather than termination
5. 5 Understanding the EEI Collateral Annex Why post margin?
Why use the Collateral Annex?
How do parties use the Collateral Annex?
6. 6 Why post margin? Posting Margin is:
Most effective way to manage credit risk to acceptable levels
Part of cost of doing business in physical energy market since credit crisis of 2001/2002
Physical power agreements have been morphing; to more closely resemble financial trading agreements
7. 7 Potential Issues with Posting Margin
Liquidity risk that may result when contracts are not matched for credit and collateral terms
Potential imbalance when selling or hedging an asset in the market
Imbalance when buying from a counterparty and selling to a customer
8. 8 Why was Collateral Annex developed? When the EEI Master was first introduced (1999), margining relationships were generally the exception, not the rule.
Post 2001, the demand for robust margining relationships became greater.
9. 9 Why use Collateral Annex? EEI Master Agreement includes its own collateral provisions
(see Secs. 8.1(c)/8.2(c)), but:
A good, thorough margining relationship cannot be addressed adequately in 23 lines!
Management of potentially millions in collateral requires more detail
10. 10 Advantages of Using EEI Collateral Annex Provides for payment of interest on and use of cash collateral
Addresses eligibility to hold collateral and custodians
Contains Letter of Credit terms (valuation principles, when draws are permitted)
Clarifies application of “Independent Amounts”
11. 11 Advantages of Using EEI Collateral Annex (cont’d) Identifies conditions precedent to delivery/return of collateral
Addresses required timing of collateral transfers (i.e., “Notification Time”, timing of deliveries and returns)
Establishes mechanism for resolving disputes over amounts of collateral calls
12. 12 How do parties use the EEI Collateral Annex? Like EEI Master: Base document with general terms drafted by group consensus
Starting point for negotiations: parties may make any elections/changes that are important to them
In “Paragraph 10”, parties make various elections, amend base annex if desired
If elections not made, then elections will be as set forth in Section VIII of Para. 10
13. 13 How do parties use the EEI Collateral Annex? (cont’d) In EEI Master Cover Sheet, elect that “Collateral Threshold” is applicable, but add:
“If applicable, the provisions of Section 8.1(c)/8.2(c) of the Agreement shall be replaced by the provisions of the Collateral Annex attached hereto.”
On Collateral Annex Cover Sheet, if elections not made, then elections will be as set forth in Section VIII
14. 14 Determination of Collateral Requirement
Net Exposure LESS:
Pledging Party’s Collateral Threshold
Cash already posted by Pledging Party
Value of Letter of Credit, other collateral posted by Pledging Party
15. 15 Sample Collateral Requirement Calculation Net Exposure
of Party A: 70
Party B's Collateral Threshold (10)
Party B Cash Held by A ( 5)
$55 Letter of Credit held by A but less that 20 days until expire - 0 -
Party B’s Collateral Requirement $ 55
16. 16 Setting Collateral Thresholds Standard choices:
Fixed amount
Matrix approach tied to Credit Ratings
Guaranty amount
Threshold goes to zero upon Event of Default /Potential Event of Default
If Potential Event of Default cured, return from zero to stated level
17. 17 Other Key Elections to Make Eligible Collateral
Valuation Percentages
Minimum Transfer Amount
Rounding Amount
Eligibility to Hold Cash Collateral
May need to amend for unrated counterparties
Interest Rate Payable on Cash
18. 18 Other Key Elections to Make -Independent Amount Fixed: Stated dollar amount must be maintained for so long as there are any obligations between the parties
Full Floating: Stated dollar amount shall always be added to exposure calculation,as if Party B had such dollar exposure
Partial Floating: Stated dollar amount is posted only if Party for whom it is selected would owe the other Party $1 or more (i.e., other Party has a Net Exposure)
Full Floating Example: No trades; $5 million Party B Full Floating Independent Amount; Party A would have $5 million dollar exposure Party B would be required to post $5 million As trades went in the money to Party B, Party B could ask for a return of collateral (e.g., trades in the money to Party B by $6 million, Party A would post $1 million (6-5)
Partial Floating Example: (1) Party A has a Partial Floating Independent Amount of $5 million; Party B has a Net Exposure of $1 million; Party A would post $6 million(2) Party A has a Net Exposure to Party B; Party B posts and Party A does not have to post any of the $5 million
Full Floating Example: No trades; $5 million Party B Full Floating Independent Amount; Party A would have $5 million dollar exposure Party B would be required to post $5 million As trades went in the money to Party B, Party B could ask for a return of collateral (e.g., trades in the money to Party B by $6 million, Party A would post $1 million (6-5)
Partial Floating Example: (1) Party A has a Partial Floating Independent Amount of $5 million; Party B has a Net Exposure of $1 million; Party A would post $6 million(2) Party A has a Net Exposure to Party B; Party B posts and Party A does not have to post any of the $5 million
19. 19 Resolution of Disputes Disputing Party must notify by Notification Time on Business Day following demand
Pending dispute, post undisputed amount
If no agreement within 1 Business Day, each party selects a Reference Market- Maker to calculate MTM for disputed trades
Mark = average of prices obtained
Same procedures for requests to return collateral
20. 20 EEI vs. ISDA Collateral Annex Performance Assurance vs. Eligible Collateral
EEI: Cash & Letters of Credit
If securities can be posted, need to add valuation, substitution, DR & security interest terms.
ISDA: Cash & Securities
If letters of credit can be posted, need to add relevant L/C terms
Payment of Interest
“Specified Conditions”
Failures to Transfer Collateral
21. 21 EEI vs. ISDA Collateral Annex (cont’d) Payment of Interest
EEI Paragraph 6(a)(iii)
Monthly invoicing by Pledging Party to Secured Party
Payment Schedule – later of:
3rd Local Business Day of following month
3rd Local Business Day after the day the invoice is received
ISDA CSA Paragraph 6(d)(ii)
No invoicing
Last Business Day of Month and any Local Business Day where Cash is transferred to the Pledgor
22. 22 Common Points of Negotiation Credit Assurances vs. Collateral Thresholds
Master netting arrangements
Implications of using EEI Gas Supplement
Collateral Lessons reinforced by Lehman
Other issues …