E N D
1. Oral Health Disparities in Publicly Insured Children Dental Advisory Committee
April 11th, 2008
Tegwyn H. Brickhouse DDS PhD
Department of Pediatric Dentistry
VCU School of Dentistry
2. Grant NIH Career Transition Award (K22)
From the National Institutes of Dental and Craniofacial Research
Supports young investigators in their early career
Experience guides them to become a independent scientist
Future grants
3. Oral Health Disparities Dental caries is the most common chronic disease of childhood, affecting 58% of all children.
Untreated dental caries has been identified as the most prevalent unmet health need in US children.
4. Health Coverage for Children Employer/Private Insurance 60%
47 million children
Medicaid/SCHIP 28%
22 million children
Uninsured 12%
Over 9.4 million
5. Background Publicly Financed Health Plans Providing Dental Services
Medicaid
A joint federal-state-county program established in 1965 to provide health insurance to low-income populations
State Children’s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP)
A joint federal-state program established in 1997 to provide coverage to low-income uninsured children who are not eligible for Medicaid.
6. Grant Objectives Examine the structure of public dental insurance programs and patterns of Enrollment in publicly insured children.
Examine the Process of dental care (utilization, mix of services) and dental health status Outcomes (tooth loss, caries-related treatments).
Compare dental treatment with of general anesthesia versus the conventional dental delivery system for preschool-aged children
Implement a project that examines outcomes for case management of infant oral health in a medical setting.
7. Effects of Public Insurance on Access to Dental Services Cohort of Publicly Insured Children
Enrollment and Claims data from 2002-2005
Children 0-18 years of age
Two State Programs (Virginia and North Carolina)
Similar size
Similar population distribution
Similar geography
8. Analytical File Construction Claim summaries of utilization
Provider-Level summaries
Individual Child-level files
linked enrollment and claims across time periods.
9. Analytical File Creation Child-Level File
10. Enrollment Patterns of Publicly Insured Children Measures that characterize enrollment in public programs
Length of Enrollment (duration)
Heterogeneous populations
Patterns of Enrollment (continuity)
yearly and age determinations
gaps
11. Impacts of Enrollment Impact on eligibility for dental services
Age and aid categories of eligibility determination
Enrollees are approximately 10% SCHIP, 90% Medicaid
75% of children were enrolled with one MCO provider
20% enrolled with 2 MCO’s
5% enrolled with 3+
Impact on provider acceptance
Real-time eligibility determination (on-line, swipe methods)
12. Enrollment Over the 3 year period, children were enrolled a mean number of 436 days, median of 365 days.
The mean age of enrolled children is 5 years.
12.5% had no gaps in enrollment
50% has one gap in enrollment
37.5% had 2+ gaps in enrollment
Few studies have examined the relationship of enrollment patterns and utilization.
13. Outcomes Dental Visits
Utilization of dental services measured by at least one paid claim.
Annual Dental Visit (NCQA standards)
Performance Measures of Dental Services
Which children utilize services/benefit most
Age
Geography
Income
14. Outcomes Performance Measures of Dental Services
Preventive services
Restorative services
Tooth Loss (receipt of one or more extraction services)
Dental Home
2 visits to same practice/same year
15. North Carolina Claims Data
16. Medicaid versus Separate SCHIP Program
17. Mix of Services for all Children
18. Mix of Services for Children Accessing Dental Care
20. Virginia Claims Data 62% of dental claims were MCO
38% of dental claims were FFS
Mean age for children with claims was 9 years of age.
21. Mix of Services 32% Diagnostic Services
40% Preventive Services
18% Restorative Services
5% Extraction Services
1.5 % Orthodontic Services
22. Infant Oral Health Project Preventive oral health services consist of
knee to knee oral screening and risk assessment
Fluoride varnish
oral health education for caregivers
referral to a pediatric dental clinic.
23. Infant Assessment 19% of children had signs of dental caries
12.5% having white-spot lesions
75% were categorized as ‘high’ risk and referred for a dental visit
80% of children received a fluoride varnish treatment
26. High-Risk Children 6-months post-enrollment, 9% of children had made a dental visit to VCU.
Children with visible plaque were more likely to have decay at baseline.
400+ Children enrolled in the VCU Bright Smiles Program
Examine the prevalence of dental claims for enrolled children versus a random sample of Medicaid children 0-3 years of age.
27. Future Studies Provider Measures
Participation in programs
Level of activity
Types of Services
Response to program changes
Program structure
Fee increases
28. State Program Reform Single Vendor Carve Out
Pre-Post Design
29. Questions? Many Thanks to DMAS
Sandra Brown
James Starkey
Lisa Bilik
Pat Finnerty