180 likes | 390 Views
RT 4a Network integration and modeling of large wind turbines
E N D
1. 1 RT 4aNetwork integration and modeling of large wind turbines Grids Codes and their application to distribution connected wind turbines
Voltage and power factor control - Reigh Walling
Models of variable speed wind turbines, particularly for fault calculations - Graeme Bathurst
Modelling of Wind Turbines – Stavros Papathanassiou
Loss-of-mains protection and its relevance to large wind turbines
Integration of significant distribution-connected wind generation into transmission systems, and implications for overall system balancing and operation.
2. 2 Pre-planned double circuit outage needed to allow new cruise ship ‘Norwegian Pearl’ along Ems river in north eastern Germany.
At 21:38h, both circuits of the 380-kV-line Conneforde-Diele were switched out
High loads on Wehrendorf-Landesbergen (East-Westphalia) EON to RWE
EON operators tried to couple a number of lines at a substation to resolve the problem but at
22:10h, the lines Wehrendorf-Landesbergen and Bechterdissen-Elsen lines tripped. Further tie-lines were overloaded within seconds and tripped in cascade creating 3 power islands
Area 2 (green) had ~6GW excess generation and rose to ~53Hz, Area 3 49.7 Hz
in Area 1 (orange) frequency fell to 49Hz and 13,350 MW was lost on low frequency tripping
Country TSO Load shed
Austria APG 1500 MW
Belgium Elia 800 MW
France RTE 5200 MW
Germany E.ON Netz 400 MW
Germany RWE TSO 2000 MW
Italy TERNA 1500 MW
Netherlands TenneT 400 MW
Portugal REN 500 MW
Spain REE 1050 MW
European UCTE network was reconnected after 38 minutes and the customers were progressively supplied again between 40 and 90 minutes of the incident.
Investigations by EON, German Regulator, UCTE and Council of European Energy Regulators (CEER). EON have said the event was chiefly caused by human error.
2 GW export from France to GB maintained throughout.Pre-planned double circuit outage needed to allow new cruise ship ‘Norwegian Pearl’ along Ems river in north eastern Germany.
At 21:38h, both circuits of the 380-kV-line Conneforde-Diele were switched out
High loads on Wehrendorf-Landesbergen (East-Westphalia) EON to RWE
EON operators tried to couple a number of lines at a substation to resolve the problem but at
22:10h, the lines Wehrendorf-Landesbergen and Bechterdissen-Elsen lines tripped. Further tie-lines were overloaded within seconds and tripped in cascade creating 3 power islands
Area 2 (green) had ~6GW excess generation and rose to ~53Hz, Area 3 49.7 Hz
in Area 1 (orange) frequency fell to 49Hz and 13,350 MW was lost on low frequency tripping
Country TSO Load shed
Austria APG 1500 MW
Belgium Elia 800 MW
France RTE 5200 MW
Germany E.ON Netz 400 MW
Germany RWE TSO 2000 MW
Italy TERNA 1500 MW
Netherlands TenneT 400 MW
Portugal REN 500 MW
Spain REE 1050 MW
European UCTE network was reconnected after 38 minutes and the customers were progressively supplied again between 40 and 90 minutes of the incident.
Investigations by EON, German Regulator, UCTE and Council of European Energy Regulators (CEER). EON have said the event was chiefly caused by human error.
2 GW export from France to GB maintained throughout.
3. 3 Outcome of RT What do we know?
Modelling of Wind Turbines
Steady state
Dynamic
Fault calculations
Is the relationship between the Codes for Distribution and Transmission connected wind generation clear?
Is there a role for CIRED in this area?
4. 4
5. 5
6. 6
7. 7
8. 8
9. 9 What do we need to model? Traditional Power System Analysis
Steady state operation – load flow
Dynamic operation – transient stability
Fault current – fault calculators
Additional Tools
Optimal power flow
Probabilistic power flow
Electro-magnetic tranmsients
10. 10 Features of Grid Codes (Transmission Connected) Low voltage Fault Ride Through
Wide frequency range of operation
Voltage control of entire wind farm
Ability to provide frequency response
Are these relevant for Distribution Connected Wind Turbines?
Are the Grid Codes appropriate for Distribution Connected Wind Turbines?
11. 11 Voltage and Power Factor ControlReigh Walling
Should vernier pf or voltage control be required?
Should tariffs allow payments to wind generator for ancillary voltage regulation service?
12. 12 Fault Calculations for Variable Speed TurbinesGraeme Bathurst What data should manufacturers provide?
Are existing calculation methods sufficient?
Should we consider equipment failure?
13. 13 Loss of Mains Protection Designed to trip Distributed Generation during network disturbances
Main objective is Distribution Network Safety (Earthing, Operator Safety, single in-feed)
Is this compatible with very large penetrations of DG?
Is this compatible with Grid Codes?
14. 14 Voltage Depressions throughout the network Example of propagation of voltage depression throughout the network caused by a Supergrid fault.
This leads to the requirement for robust Fault Ride Through capability of distributed wind farms
Slide from Colin Bayfield Scottish Power In almost all items of electrical generating plant, normal operating conditions are only a small part of the story. In particular, for generation disbursed over a wide area, the power companies are worried about the effects of network faults causing voltage depressions that, in turn lead to much of the generation being disconnected. As well as normal operation, it is extremely important to consider abnormal or fault conditions. This slide shows the effect on network voltage of a fault on a busbar in central Scotland and it can be seen that low voltage propagates throughout Scotland and down as far as England.
Red shows 0-15% retained voltage
Blue shows 30-50% retained voltage
White shows 50-85% retained voltage
Only converter connected plant can continue to operate with significant voltage depressions. This is another reason for the popularity of DFIG and wide range wind turbines. In almost all items of electrical generating plant, normal operating conditions are only a small part of the story. In particular, for generation disbursed over a wide area, the power companies are worried about the effects of network faults causing voltage depressions that, in turn lead to much of the generation being disconnected. As well as normal operation, it is extremely important to consider abnormal or fault conditions. This slide shows the effect on network voltage of a fault on a busbar in central Scotland and it can be seen that low voltage propagates throughout Scotland and down as far as England.
Red shows 0-15% retained voltage
Blue shows 30-50% retained voltage
White shows 50-85% retained voltage
Only converter connected plant can continue to operate with significant voltage depressions. This is another reason for the popularity of DFIG and wide range wind turbines.
15. 15 In the past if there is any fault in the system, it was a common practice to disconnect the wind farm from the system.
However as the capacity of the wind farm is increased, disconnecting large amount of wind power could cause instability in the system.
Therefore, presently wind farms are required to be remain connected to the system for a certain period of time defined by the grid codes. In the past if there is any fault in the system, it was a common practice to disconnect the wind farm from the system.
However as the capacity of the wind farm is increased, disconnecting large amount of wind power could cause instability in the system.
Therefore, presently wind farms are required to be remain connected to the system for a certain period of time defined by the grid codes.
16. 16 In the past if there is any fault in the system, it was a common practice to disconnect the wind farm from the system.
However as the capacity of the wind farm is increased, disconnecting large amount of wind power could cause instability in the system.
Therefore, presently wind farms are required to be remain connected to the system for a certain period of time defined by the grid codes. In the past if there is any fault in the system, it was a common practice to disconnect the wind farm from the system.
However as the capacity of the wind farm is increased, disconnecting large amount of wind power could cause instability in the system.
Therefore, presently wind farms are required to be remain connected to the system for a certain period of time defined by the grid codes.
17. 17 In the past if there is any fault in the system, it was a common practice to disconnect the wind farm from the system.
However as the capacity of the wind farm is increased, disconnecting large amount of wind power could cause instability in the system.
Therefore, presently wind farms are required to be remain connected to the system for a certain period of time defined by the grid codes. In the past if there is any fault in the system, it was a common practice to disconnect the wind farm from the system.
However as the capacity of the wind farm is increased, disconnecting large amount of wind power could cause instability in the system.
Therefore, presently wind farms are required to be remain connected to the system for a certain period of time defined by the grid codes.
18. 18