60 likes | 399 Views
Request for Additional CTD Guidance. Structured approach to integrated clinical summaries/analyses and individual study reports
E N D
Request for Additional CTD Guidance • Structured approach to integrated clinical summaries/analyses and individual study reports • Avoid building in unnecessary redundancy in data and analyses in the Clinical Overview, Clinical Summary, Integrated Summary of Effectiveness, and Integrated Summary of Safety • Provide reviewers a framework for their region-specific safety and efficacy reviews.
The Summary Pyramid • Clinical Overview: “intended to provide a critical analysis of the clinical data in the Common Technical Document,” CTD, 2002 • Clinical Summary: “intended to provide a detailed, factual summarisation of all of the clinical information in the Common Technical Document,“ CTD, 2002 • Integrated Summary of Effectiveness: “should provide an integrated summary of the data demonstrating substantial evidence of effectiveness for each claimed indication.” ClinStat Format, 1988 • Integrated Summary of Safety: “is, in part, simply a summation of data from individual studies and, in part, a new analysis that goes beyond what can be done with individual studies.” ClinStat Format, 1988
Clinical Summary and/or ISS • Have compared and mapped content from ISE and ISS to content of Clinical Summary • Large overlap between ISE/ISS and Clinical Summary:According to agencies:According to contentmapping analysis: ISE CS ISS CS ISE CS ISS CS+ dropouts
Proposed Structure • Either ICH or FDA need to provide clarity around clinical summaries • Current FDA advice on ISS is a series of PowerPoint presentations and is not adequate for industry’s needs • Proposal: • Clinical Overview (2.5) is the detailed critical analysis and interpretation of the meaning of efficacy and safety data • Clinical Summary (2.7) is the integrated factual analysis and presentation of efficacy and safety data • Module Section 5.3.5.3 • ISE: optional integrated efficacy report (discussions of dry runs; analyses that add hundreds/thousands of pages) • ISS: presentation of specified additional integrated safety information, patient narratives, and special safety analyses requested by agencies