E N D
1. Audit of the Monitoring of Obstetric Patients in Theatre Recovery Dr Gareth Roberts, Ysbyty Gwynedd
Dr Haitem Maghur, Ysbyty Gwynedd
3. Audit objectives To find out what:
Recovery training has been provided for midwives to enable them to undertake this role
Observations are documented on obstetric patients recovering from anaesthesia
Facilities are present in the obstetric theatre recovery bay
4. Audit standards The obstetric theatre recovery bay must meet the AAGBI minimum national standards for recovery facilities
All women should have at least the AAGBI recommended set of minimum observations recorded on a dedicated recovery chart at least every 15 minutes
All recovering women should not be left alone at any time
5.
There should be a protocol for discharge from recovery and all women should meet these criteria before leaving the area
All recovering women should be recovered by a member of staff (nurse or midwife) who has undergone recovery training and recovers patients on a regular basis
All recovering women should have the presence of trained recovery staff giving them 1:1 care
6. Method 3 part audit :
1st part was a questionnaire sent to all midwives on labour ward
2nd part was a retrospective analysis of cases notes of patients being recovered following Caesarean Section
3rd part was an audit of the facilities present in obstetric theatre recovery compared against AAGBI minimum standards
7. PART 1
Prospective
Questionnaire sent to all 70 midwives working at Ysbyty Gwynedd
8. Questions asked about :
1. Recent training in recovery skills
2. Basic life support training
3. Frequency of recovering patients
4. Confidence level when recovering patients
5. Criteria for discharge from recovery
6. Training in use of invasive monitoring
7. Ability to give intravenous drugs
9. Results
25 questionnaires completed (35% response rate)
10. I have received the following formal training in recovery skills within the last 3 years
None 5 (20%)
Day release to main recovery 20 (80%)
Other 0
11. I have passed a BLS course within the pastyear
Yes 22 (88%)
No 3 (12%)
12. How often do you recover patients following surgery?
13. I feel confident in recovering patients after: GA 21(84%)
Spinal 25 (100%)
Epidural topup 25 (100%)
14. Criteria for discharge
15. How often do you care for a patient in Obstetric HDU?
16. Have you received formal training in the use of an arterial line?
Yes 4 (16%)
No 21(84%)
17. Have you received formal training in the use of a central line?
Yes 4 (16%)
No 21 (84%)
18. Are you able to give drugs intravenously?
Yes 23 (92%)
No 2 (8%)
19. PART 2 Retrospective
45 case notes of patients recovered from elective and emergency Caesarean Section in obstetric theatres audited
Sampling period between 1st January and 31st August 2008
3 groups of 15 cases audited based on the type of anaesthetics, GA, Spinal, Epidural topup
‘AAGBI minimum monitoring requirements in recovery’ parameters audited in these 45 recovered patients
20. AAGBI minimum obstetric recovery observations should include:
1. Haemoglobin oxygen saturation
2. Respiratory rate
3. Heart rate and rhythm
4. Blood pressure
5. Temperature
6. Level of consciousness
7. Pain score
8. Sensory level of regional block
9. Blood loss from wound, vagina and drain
21. Results
22. Spinal
23. GA
24. Epidural topups
25. Part 3 Prospective
Assessment of recovery facilities including staffing carried out.
Compared against The AAGBI checklist of minimum nationally recommended recovery facilities which include:
Oxygen outlet
Ambu Bag
Electrical Sockets
4. Pulse oximeter
26. 5. ECG monitor
6. Suction Unit
7. NIBP monitoring
8. Telephone / emergency buzzer
9. 1:1 staff to patient ratio
10. Breast feeding facilities
11. IV cannulas
12. Tape
13. Blood test bottles and forms
14. IV fluid and giving sets
15. Defibrillator
16. Emergency drug box
17. Intubation equipment
27. Results 100% of recovery facilities found to be present
Midwives however provide 1:2 care due to having to care for the newborn baby and recover the mother simultaneously
Midwife occasionally needing to leave recovering patient due to newborn duties
No obstetric recovery discharge protocol in existence for the midwifes to use
28. Conclusions Although most midwives have received a day of recovery training in the past 3 years this is probably insufficient training to meet current national standards for obstetric recovery care
Although midwives feel confident in recovering patient following regional and general anaesthesia they do not recover patients often enough to maintain experience
Very poor documentation of patient’s vital signs, pain score and sensory block level in recovery.
29. Midwifes are not always able to be with patient for whole of recovery period due to additional newborn duties
Obstetric theatre recovery facilities fully meet minimal national requirements
30. Recommendations We recognise the valuable contribution that midwives have played in the recovery of obstetric patients over the years
However, as shown by this audit, to meet current national standards for the recovery of obstetric patients, their recovery at Ysbyty Gwynedd should in the future only be undertaken by trained recovery nurses
Midwives require formal training in the use of invasive monitoring (arterial & CVP line management) to make them more effective in caring for the sick parturient
To establish an Obstetric recovery discharge protocol with well defined criteria to aid in the decision of discharging patients back to the ward.
31. Future audits Audit length of stay of patients in obstetric recovery against national standard
Audit obstetric HDU monitoring, staffing and facilities
Re audit in 12 months.
32. References Association of anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland. Immediate postanaesthetic recovery. AAGBI London 2002
Association of anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland. The Anaesthesia Team. AAGBI London 2005
Association of anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland. Recommendations for standards of monitoring during anaesthesia and recovery. AAGBI London 2007
Confidential Enquiry into Maternal and Child Health. Saving Mother’s Lives 2003-2005. CEMACH, London 2007
33. Thank you…
Questions?