1 / 83

Employment Law: An Update

Employment Law: An Update. January 2006 Alison Bell. Hot Topics: . Discipline and grievance Long term sickness Changing terms and conditions Compromise agreements. New Legislation:. TUPE 2006 Work & Families Act 2006 Recent Cases What's in the pipeline. Hot Topics .

Samuel
Download Presentation

Employment Law: An Update

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Employment Law: An Update January 2006 Alison Bell

  2. Hot Topics: • Discipline and grievance • Long term sickness • Changing terms and conditions • Compromise agreements

  3. New Legislation: • TUPE 2006 • Work & Families Act 2006 Recent Cases What's in the pipeline

  4. Hot Topics Discipline and grievance

  5. Disciplinary/dismissal and grievance procedures • Statutory Dispute Resolution Regulations • In 2 parts: Disciplinary/Dismissal Procedure and Grievance Procedure • Standard 3 step procedure • Put it in writing • Meet and discuss • Appeal

  6. The disciplinary/dismissal procedure • Mandatory Disciplinary/Dismissal Procedure • An additional obligation • If the employer fails to comply: • Automatic finding of unfair dismissal; and • An increase in compensation

  7. Points to note in the standard procedure • Step 1 – Put it in writing, send it to the employee and invite the employee to a meeting • Step 2 – Arrange the meeting before action is taken • Step 3 – If the employee appeals, invite the employee to a further meeting and inform the employee of the final decision

  8. Practical implications • Post employment disputes • Overlapping procedures

  9. Practical Implications • Retirement • Redundancy

  10. Practical implications • Probationary periods • Fixed term contracts

  11. Grievance and disciplinary procedures • A wide definition of “grievance letter” • Solicitor’s letter (open or without grievance) • Flexible working request letter • Complaint about handling of earlier grievance • Solicitor’s letter asking for settlement not an appeal • Information required as part of a DDP • Employers must not rely on expired disciplinary warnings

  12. Long term sickness

  13. ACAS Code of Practice • Investigation • Establish underlying cause • No reason for absence – discipline • Genuine illness – capability • Sympathetic and considerate approach Consultation, consultation, consultation !

  14. Long term sickness - capability • Regular contact • Consult employee • Employee’s medical evidence • Own medical evidence • Need to replace

  15. Long term sickness (2) • Warn employee of dismissal • Meeting with employee to consider • Alternative employment • Reasonable adjustments

  16. Decision • Nature of the illness(es) • Likelihood of recurrences • Other sickness absence? • Length of absence

  17. Decision (2) • Spaces between absences • Need for particular employee • Impact on others • Length of employment • Consistency

  18. Varying terms and conditions

  19. Varying terms and conditions • Employment law implications • Possible routes forward • Contractual change • Consultation • Redundancy situation

  20. Contractual change ? • Terms and conditions • Employee handbook • Individual agreements • Longstanding practice

  21. If no contractual change • Discuss at consultative forum • Individual consultation process • Reason for objection • Discrimination issues • Disciplinary procedure for refusals

  22. If contractual change • How important • Business reasons

  23. Introducing contractual change • Four options • Through a contractual right • By agreement • By imposing the change • By dismissal and re-engagement

  24. Imposing the change • Resign and claim constructive dismissal • Continue to work under protest • Claim unlawful deduction from wages (if there is an effect on pay) • Claim breach of contract • Claim discrimination (eg if there is a negative effect on a particular group of employees)

  25. Dismiss and re-engage • Wrongful dismissal • Unfair dismissal whether or not re-engaged • Business need, ‘some other substantial reason’

  26. Redundancy • Very significant changes • Consultation with employees’ representatives • Individual consultation

  27. Varying Terms and Conditions – Summary • Employment Law implications • Possible routes forward • Contractual change • Consultation • Redundancy situation

  28. Compromise Agreements

  29. The technical requirements • When to use • Without prejudice conversations • Tactical considerations

  30. New Legislation

  31. Summary of main TUPE changes • More transactions likely to be TUPE transfers • Old employer can be liable for failing to consult • Old employer must disclose information to new employer • New employer has (limited) ability to change contracts of employment • Insolvency

  32. Work and Families Act • Maternity and adoption pay • Keeping in touch • Early return to work notice • Flexible working for carers • Paternity pay • Minimum annual leave entitlements

  33. Practical implications • Pay administration • Increased warning of return to work • Reasonable contact – KIT days • Sharing maternity/adoption leave • Impact of increase flexible working for carers

  34. Recent Cases

  35. Case law developments • Disability absence and sick pay schemes • Sickness vs disability • Vicarious liability for harassment • Whistleblowing – detriment after termination • Discrimination by association • ‘On racial grounds’

  36. Case law developments • Length of service and pay • Employers vicarious liability for discrimination • Public holidays for part time workers • Using the right procedures

  37. In the pipeline

  38. Future legislation • Commission for Equality and Human Rights – Oct 07 • Data protection fully implemented – Oct 07 • Smoking bans – 2007/08

  39. Smoking • Smoke free premises • Signage requirements • Vehicles • Penalties

  40. Age Discrimination January 2006

  41. Age discrimination • Outline of the Regulations • Specific issues • Recruitment • Service related benefits • Retirement • Other areas of impact

  42. General observations • Applies to all applicants/workers • Irish experience: 22% of claims about age • Many existing policies/practices are ageist • Uncapped compensation

  43. Some statistics… • 40% increase in age claims in the US • High numbers already facing age discrimination • Big cultural change required

  44. Main principles • Direct – different treatment actual/perceived age • Indirect – policy/practice/criterion disadvantages • Harassment • Victimisation • Positive discrimination • Selection must be age neutral

  45. Main Principles - Justification • Direct and indirect • Proportionate and legitimate • Evidence not assertion

  46. Other exemptions to AD • Genuine occupational requirements (very limited) • Pay based on national minimum wage • Complying with a statutory authority e.g. health & safety, under 18s doing bar work • Occupational pension schemes • Life Assurance • Some pay and other service-related benefits • Contractual redundancy payments

  47. What else… • Employers liable for acts of employees • No age limits for unfair dismissal and redundancy • Default retirement at 65 • Right to request to work longer

  48. Enforcement & Remedy • In the Employment Tribunal • Brought within 3 months of the discriminatory act • Provided compliance with the Statutory Grievance Procedure • Compensation = Uncapped

More Related