130 likes | 342 Views
Maternal smoking and offspring behaviour. Consistent association with risk of problem behaviour:Disruptive behaviour(CD, ODD, co-morbid ADHD)SmokingSubstance useMultiple, independent, cross-national samples, robust to measured confounders. Correlation or causation?. Does smoking play an aetiologic roleIs smoking a marker for intergenerational transmission processes associated with both:tendency to smokerisk of offspring with problem behaviour.
E N D
1. Meaningful differences in maternal smoking behaviour during pregnancy: Implications for infant behavioural vulnerability Kate E. Pickett, Callie Wood, Joy Adamson, Lalitha DeSouza, Lauren Wakschlag
3. Correlation or causation? Does smoking play an aetiologic role
Is smoking a marker for intergenerational transmission processes associated with both:
tendency to smoke
risk of offspring with problem behaviour Seven studies in TEN paper, all find same answer but there are still questions
5 prospective, population-based studies
3 CD, 4 criminal offending
US, Scandinavia, New Zealand
No question about robustness, no question that finding a prenatal, potentially modifiable etiological factor would be important
Is it a teratologic effect?
Is it due to confounding?
Is this effect modified by other risk factors for CD (eg: genetics, parenting)Seven studies in TEN paper, all find same answer but there are still questions
5 prospective, population-based studies
3 CD, 4 criminal offending
US, Scandinavia, New Zealand
No question about robustness, no question that finding a prenatal, potentially modifiable etiological factor would be important
Is it a teratologic effect?
Is it due to confounding?
Is this effect modified by other risk factors for CD (eg: genetics, parenting)
4. Background work A critical review of epidemiological studies
Empirical work:
Estimate of the population attributable risk
Patterns and measurement of maternal smoking
Timing of onset of delinquency
Early onset of externalizing behaviour problems in toddlers
Individual and contextual characteristics of women who smoke, women who quit, women who never smoke
5. “Competing” Hypotheses Is exposure to cigarette smoke associated with an early risk pathway?
Does it increase the risk of difficult temperament in infants? Is quitting smoking associated with an early protective pathway?
Does it increase the likelihood of temperamental robustness in infants?
6. Study setting Millennium Cohort Study
18,263 mother-infant pairs
9 months old, born 2000-2001
Sample selected from a random sample of electoral wards, stratified to ensure representation of all four UK countries, deprived areas and areas with high concentrations of Black and Asian families.
7. Measurement of temperament 14 questions from Carey Infant Temperament Scale
3 dimensions (high score=more robust)
Positive mood
Receptivity to novelty
Regularity
“Difficult” temperament (scores below sample means)
Lack of positive emotionality
Wariness
Irregularity
8. Measurement of smoking etc Smoking
Never smoked in pregnancy
Gave up during pregnancy
Continuous light smoking (< 10/day)
Continuous heavy smoking (10+/day) Other factors
Birth weight, length of gestation
Age
Alcohol consumption
History of depression
History of domestic violence
Marital status
Poverty
Educational attainment
Social class
Ethnicity
9. Smoking in the MCS
10. Temperament by smoking
11. Adjusted effects of smoking on difficult temperament
12. Discussion Martin et al (2006) found “better” temperament among infants of smokers in Finland, but included quitters with smokers
More attention needs to be paid to characterizing differences between pregnancy quitters and pregnancy smokers
Need to examine development over time and the unfolding of early vulnerabilities into problem behaviours
13. Adaptive problems related to smoking in the Family Health and Development Project