560 likes | 718 Views
Telerehabilitation; Towards Remote Monitoring & Remotely Supervised Training. Hermie J. Hermens, PhD Roessingh Research & University of Twente. Trends in health care. Rising demand for care Increase of number of elderly people Increase number of people with chronic disorders
E N D
Telerehabilitation; Towards Remote Monitoring & Remotely Supervised Training Hermie J. Hermens, PhD Roessingh Research & University of Twente
Trends in health care • Rising demand for care • Increase of number of elderly people • Increase number of people with chronic disorders • Rand Coop predicts in US • 2010: 141 million people with chronic illness • 2030: 171 million people with chronic illness • Chronic Care now over 50% of total costs and increasing
Costs of Health Care (% BNP) • Source: OECD (2002) • Tsjechie 5.7 % BNP • England: 7.7 % BNP • Netherlands: 9.1% BNP • Germany 10.5 % BNP • Suisse 11.2 % BNP • United States 14.6 % BNP Quote Martin van Rijn (NL): with unchanged policies, health care will cost us 12% BNP and 20% of working people will have to work in healthcare
Results of these trends in health care • Rising demand for chronic care • With limited budget and people • Will force a higher productivity without losing our high quality • Changes in the customer will require • Independent living as long as possible • Individually tailored solutions All these changes will require a change in our approach to health care
Need to change our approach Present focus From Philips
Need to change our approach Required extensions From Philips
Trends in Technology • Sensing technology • High quality ambulatory acquisition possible • Smaller, low power, wireless connection • User friendly (integrated in textiles) • PDA’s get smarter and more powerful • Information & Communication Technology • Broadband connection available and cheap • Special data transport platforms available • Centralised Electronic Health record available
Creating new opportunities Combining Biomedical Engineering with Information and Communication Technology creates a new area of research and relevant clinical services: • Remote monitoring • Remotely supervised training Enabling monitoring and treatment of subjects anywhere, anytime and intervene when needed
Remote monitoring Guarding the health condition of a subject by measuring and interpretation of vital biosignals, without interference of his daily activities but able to react when required
Remotely supervised training & Treatment Enabling the subject to train at his time and place, providing him the same quality of feedback/assurance as in the intramural situation = Monitoring + dedicated feedback X
The potential benefits Monitoring • Less intramural care (costs) • More freedom for the patient • Peace of mind Remotely supervised treatment • High intensity of training possible (more = better) • Training in natural environment translates better to ADL situations (more effective training) • Patient himself responsible for results • Clinician can ‘treat’ several patients at the same time
The challenges • Are we able to make this technologically feasible ? • Will this result this in a same quality of treatment ? • Will this be accepted by health care providers ? • Will this be accepted by the patients ? Summarising experiences of the past ten years by: • Roessingh Research & Rehabilitation Centre & • University of Twente • Many partners (Lucent, Philips, Atos Origin, ..) Ongoing research focused, on ambulatory monitoring and treatment
Architecture Remote monitoring & remotely supervised training
General architecture RMT systems Decision support Personal Coach Feedback Care & Coaching Sensing Hospital & “Central” Database Informal coach (Hermens, 2008)
wireless (GPRS,UMTS, WiFi) An example: The Mobihealth system • Developed in European projects (Mobihealth and HS24, Awareness) • Supports mobile data transport • Supports various networks • Data encryption of biosignals • Access • User Identification by password • Device authentication by pin • Tested in many clinical pilot studies • See www.mobihealth.com secure wireless transmission patient data MyoTel Service Centre Internet hybrid data communication infrastructure
Sensing; general demands • Sensors • Sensors should be wearable, comfortable, forgettable • Autonomic placement feasible • Processing • Continuous sensing required, independent of place, time • “Real-time” processing and feature extraction required
Sensor development in Twente • Capacitive EXG • EMG garment • Activity monitoring • 3-D Force shoe • Full body movements
Automatic feature extraction in EMG E.g. spasticity (Detect when and how often muscle active) AGLR to detect changes in variance Post-processing based on physiol. properties
Looking for new features: physical condition Important variable in chronic diseases But requires max effort Can this be estimated in non max conditions Have people do various activity , while measuring ECG and activity ECG and activity
Estimation of physical condition from ambulatory measurements First results :Modeling predicts good correlations with Astrand cycle ergometer test and modified Bruce treadmill test
The Body Area Network (BAN) • Often more then on body sensor is required (sensor fusion): • To enable more robust features (e.g. Movements) • To enable different features (e.g. Physical condition) • And actuators for feedback purposes So, we need to connect multiple sensors and actuators to a central point to enable synchronised data collection
Several approaches to create a BAN • One amplifier/AD converter (classic) • Bussystem (e.g. Xsens) • Multiple bluetooth connections • Upcoming: Wireless sensor networks
What kind of services should we develop? Considering that chronic diseases develop slowly but sudden events might happen Monitoring services should aim at: Monitoring sudden adverse events Detecting slow changes over time Detecting changes in patterns Treatment services should aim at: Providing feedback to the person, so he can change his “negative” behaviour and To the health care professionals for consultation purposes support and to enable interventions
Case 1 Chronic low back pain
A Tele-treatment of chronic pain patients • 80% all people ever have low back complaints • About 90% recovers, 10% becomes chronic • Over 80% no clear damage • Lot of medical shopping • High costs (5 BE, 1995) • Present treatments not very effective (35% for multidisc. Programs) • All models do predict a change in activities as part of the chronification process
Do low back pain patients show an abnormal activity pattern over the day? • Chronic pain patients (n=29) and asymptomatic controls (n=20) • Wore MT9 inertial 3-D motion sensor to measure the activity level during 7 consecutive days. • Fill in questionnaires to assess the activity level subjectively. Van Weering et al 2007
Do low back pain patients show an abnormal activity pattern? 1,4 controls patients • Overall activity level not different between patients and controls • Activity pattern Patients unbalanced: significant higher in the morning and lower in the evening 1,2 1 0,8 mean acceleration 0,6 0,4 0,2 0 7pm 9pm 7am 9am 1pm 5pm 3pm 11am 11pm time
An idea for a new treatment concept • Starting from: LBP patients have a dysbalanced activity pattern during the day • Assuming that such dysbalance in activity is an important component in the chronification process in low back pain • Conceptual idea: Normalising this activity pattern might reverse the chronification! • Realise this by providing continuous personalised feedback on the activity pattern
Personalised context aware feedback Scenario: After making breakfast for the kids and while doing the dishes, the system detects that Cinderella has been too active for a period of time. She receives feedback: • General feedback: • That she needs to rest for some minutes. • Personalized feedback (preferences): • That she should have some tea. • Context-aware feedback (time, weather, presence) • Drink a cup of tea in the backyard and enjoy the sun.
Personal context data Non-Personal context data Body area network Back End system Sensors &Actuators Bluetooth Wires UMTS/GPRS Transport system Front-end www Database interpretation, reasoning and storage Mobile Base Unit PC Continuous context aware feedback Healthcare professional Medical display Professional feedback The M-health service platform
Present status • Activity sensing implemented on PDA • Personalised messaging implemented • Context aware feedback not yet • Clinical trial recently started • First responses positive Input pain level Personalised feedback Feedback of performance
Case 3. Fully ambulatory training of neck/shoulder pain
Chronic neck/shoulder pain • Chronic pain in neck/shoulder with no clear cause of physical overloading • Often associated with computer work • Cinderella theory: • Lack of relaxation results in overloading specific muscle parts • Overloading results in pain • Pain results in changes in posture and more overloading Solution: warn the subject in case of insufficient relaxation, so subject is able to learn and adapt posture and muscle activation
Starting points for the system design • Assess muscle relaxation by surface EMG measurement and processing • Provide private feedback when there is insufficient relaxation • Enable an intense treatment outside the hospital! • during normal activities: fully ambulant • Non-obtrusive • Support independent
Summarizing our experiences • In about 50 patients: • Unstable signals during first five minutes, then good signal for over 24 hours • Requires initial individual fitting, then reproducible signals • Independent donning and doffing possible • Not interfering with activities of daily living
EMG Processing for Feedback Calculate relative relaxation time (RRT; (resampling 125 ms; moving window 1 m.) Filtering Rectification Smoothing If RRT<20%, warn subject with vibration
Myofeedback in practice • Able to improve muscle relaxation (international RCT) • Able to decrease pain complaints But often intensive supervision required: • Discuss experiences and results • Troubleshooting in first week(s) So, could this treatment be improved using ICT ? Voerman et al 2006; Huis intVeld 2007)
Database with signals And subject data PC Healthcare professional The service system to enable remote consultation Sensors &Actuators Wires Bluetooth Web based Viewer UMTS/GPRS Front-end Autonomous Feedback Mobile Base Unit Consultation & Feedback From health care professional Exozorg
Remotely supervised Myofeedback for treatment of neck/shoulder pain • Initial Questions: • Is it technically feasible to monitor muscle activity during 8 hours per day? • Is it accepted by patients and care givers? • Are care givers able to provide advice not seeing the patient? • Is it effective? Huis intVeld et al. 2007
Results Remotely supervised Myofeedback for treatment of neck/shoulder pain • Inital study in 10 patients • Often failure of wireless connections • Enough data was received at backend • Remote consultation feasible • Confidence in treatment both by patients and clinicians • Clinically at least as effective as non-remote myofeedback treatment • Now entered market validation study in 3 countries (eTEN project Myotel) Huis intVeld et al. 2007
The next step: show large scale feasibility • Show effectiveness and efficiency (Market validation ) in 3 countries (eTEN Myotel) • Development business plan • Development of Decision support system
Development of a CDSS • To assist the clinician and patient in optimising advices during consultation session • Characteristics: • Streaming data: 2 signals (RMS, RRT) of two muscles • Filtered, re-sampled at 4 Hz and stored in database • Together with activity diary and pain scores • Direction of solution • Using Bayesian network to • Detect technical failures • Relating specific activities to pain • Relate specific moments to related pain • Implement this in an agent platform
Case 2b Monitoring of low back muscle activation
A similar feedback treatment for low back pain ? • Literature shows inconsistent data on the muscle activation of the low back • Indications of both inactivity and hyperactivity patterns were found • So, what EMG patterns can be found and do they differ from normal subjects?
Ambulatory measurement of low back muscles Development: Special garment to measure the EMG Utilising dry electrodes in a flexible system to enable stable contact during activities of daily living Studies Able to don/doff independently without affecting the EMG signals ? Differences in muscle activity pattern between patients and controls How, what, when to feedback ? (de Nooy et al, 2008; patent pending)
Example EMG patterns low back muscles Accumulated EMG activity in the evening: Left healthy subject showing phasic patterns and Right a patient showing rather continuous low level activation
Present status Garment can be worn during at least 8 hours without pain/serious discomfort Sensitivity misplacement: low in longitudinal direction, high in lateral direction So far: data of 10 patients and 9 healthy subjects during 7 days Differences in patterns apparent Feedback strategy : avoid constant activity ? First implementation carried out
Present and future of Remote Monitoring and Treatment (RMT)