1 / 11

Fiduciary Risk A Part of IRM

Fiduciary Risk A Part of IRM. Jamie Collier & Jim Plaster. What’s the Risk?. Many agencies sponsor defined contribution plans (employee participants make investment decisions) Sponsor hired the plan administrator/record keeper

adair
Download Presentation

Fiduciary Risk A Part of IRM

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Fiduciary RiskA Part of IRM Jamie Collier & Jim Plaster

  2. What’s the Risk? • Many agencies sponsor defined contribution plans (employee participants make investment decisions) • Sponsor hired the plan administrator/record keeper • Plan administrator contracts with managers to offer investment options to participants • Plan administrator gets fees from participants and investment managers • Agency still has oversight responsibility of its agent

  3. Does your agency: • Periodically review investment options for appropriateness, relative performance and cost • Monitor fees charged to participants • Competitively procure record keeping services • Analyze plan sponsor’s promotional material • Provide appropriate educational resources to participants

  4. What can go wrong? • Governmental plan sponsors not subject to ERISA - yet • Courts assess a fiduciary’s performance under “prudent man rule” • Best demonstrated practice by large agencies • Size increases leverage but does let small agencies “off the hook” • Want best benefits at lowest cost for employees

  5. Levels of Exposure • Low: Department of Retirement Services Deferred Compensation Plan offered • Medium: Single 457 Plan administered by one private record keeper (like ICMA-RC, Great Western, Northwest Retirement systems) is offered for employee contributions only • High: Employer funded 401 Plan (especially as a SS substitute) administered by a private record keeper

  6. WSTIP’s Exposure & Coverage: • WSTIP’s SIR Layer • GEM Layer – reportedly not covered • Excess Layer - ??

  7. Ways to Reduce Pool’s Exposure • Exclude coverage in SIR (leave members bare) • Augment coverage in GEM & other excess layers • Improve loss avoidance • Establish a pooled resource to monitor and analyze investment performance, fees, services and competitively procure record keeper services, etc.

  8. Pooled Resource is a Win-Win • Can efficiently and effectively accommodate many individual plans in a pooled environment for reduction of risk - and fees! Requirements: • Agencies delegate to a common plan sponsor • Locally administered by each agency within broad options provided by a multi-group plan • Negotiate fees and investment options with single administrator/record keeper • Costs and benefits appropriately shared

  9. Dramatic Fee Reduction Possible • Spokane ($50mil in 7 plans) went from 0.55% to 0.135% fee without any loss of service. Annual on-going cost for consulting support: $30K Where fee reduction comes from: • Record keeper agrees to admin fee ceiling • Higher investment balances lower manager’s fees charged to record keeper • Investment managers pay marketing fees to record keeper: amounts over agreed fee rebated to participants or can cover plan costs • Need to be able to commit investment assets to achieve fee savings (unlike GSA co-op contracts)

  10. Next Steps: • Identify agencies who wish to pool their 457/401 retirement plans • Legal/regulatory issues limit but don’t determine the pooled sponsor structure • Need to decide whether to operate as separate independent pool (with its own organizational costs) or under the WSTIP umbrella (WSTIP still has coverage risk either way).

  11. Discussion: • Should WSTIP organize and sponsor the pooled plan (as a governmental employer) or • Should the interested agencies form their own pool based on a separate inter-local agreement? • What conditions and levels of support should WSTIP (as a Pool) place on this effort?

More Related