270 likes | 478 Views
2. OUTLINE. Motivation
E N D
1. BEYOND LINEAR OPTICS:ZENO GATES AND PHOTON HOLES Jim Franson
Johns Hopkins University
2. 2
3. MOTIVATION
4. 4 MOTIVATION FOR ZENO GATES There has been considerable progress in LOQC by many groups
Quantum logic including CNOT gates
Single-photon sources and detectors
Small scale circuits
Quantum error correction
Cluster states
There are several ways to deal with the failure events:
The failure rate can be made arbitrarily small by using a large number of ancilla
Cluster states
The failure events can be eliminated using the quantum Zeno effect
A random event can be suppressed by frequent observations to see if it has occurred
“A watched pot never boils”
5. 5 QUANTUM ZENO EFFECT Frequent measurements can inhibit an error
6. 6 ZENO GATES Our CNOT gate works correctly if one photon exits in each mode
All failure events are due to two photons leaving in the same path
These failure events can be suppressed by frequent observations to determine if two photons are present in the same output path
7. 7 IMPLEMENTATION OF ZENO GATES The Zeno effect requires a continuous process
The beam splitters are replaced with coupled fiber devices
The emission of two photons into the same fiber can be inhibited by frequent measurements to see if two photons are there
This is equivalent to adding atoms to the fibers that can absorb two photons but not one
The atoms “watch” for the presence of two photons
8. 8 SUPPRESSION OF ERRORS USING THE ZENO EFFECT We assumed that N equally-spaced measurements were made to determine whether or not two photons were in the same fiber
As expected from the quantum Zeno effect, the emission of two photons into the same fiber was suppressed for large N
The same results were obtained using two-photon absorption
9. 9 TWO-PHOTON ABSORPTION AND CAVITIES The required two-photon absorption can be enhanced using a resonant cavity
The energy of a single photon is concentrated in a small region
Several different cavity designs are being investigated
Single-photon absorption can be reduced using electromagnetically induced transparency (EIT)
Without any laser beams (quant-ph/0603044)
10. ENTANGLED PHOTON HOLES
11. 11 OUTLINE Concept of entangled photon holes
Somewhat analogous to holes of semiconductor theory
Can be generated using two-photon absorption
Violations of Bell’s inequality
Requires single-photon detectors
Macroscopic effects
Can be observed using classical detectors
Nonclassical reduction in the two-photon absorption rate
Could be a concern in Zeno gates
12. GENERATION OFENTANGLED PHOTONHOLES
13. 13 REVIEW OF TWO-PHOTON ABSORPTION A three-level atom is assumed to be off resonance from photon 1
A virtual transition can occur in which photon 1 is absorbed first
Followed by photon 2
For large detunings, the two photons are absorbed at very nearly the same time
14. 14 COMPARISON WITH DOWN-CONVERSION In parametric down-conversion, two photons are generated at the same time but that time is uncertain (energy-time entanglement)
With a coherent superposition of those times
In two-photon absorption, two photons are annihilated at the same time
With a coherent superposition of those times
The dips in the probability amplitude can be viewed as holes in an otherwise constant background
Somewhat analogous to the holes of semiconductor theory
15. VIOLATIONS OF BELL’S INEQUALITY
16. 16 FIRST CONSIDER PAIRS OF PHOTONS FROM DOWN-CONVERSION Suppose the two photons travel in opposite directions to two interferometers
If we only accept events in which the photons arrive at the same time, there are two possibilities
They both took the long path ( ) or the short paths ( )
There is no contribution from or
Interference between and gives a coincidence rate proportional to
Violates Bell’s inequality
17. 17 VIOLATION OF BELL’S INEQUALITY USING ENTANGLED PHOTON HOLES Once again, consider two distant interferometers and assume the dips go to zero
Now there is no contribution from or
The photons are never emitted at the same time
Interference between and now give a coincidence rate proportional to
Also violates Bell’s inequality
18. MACROSCOPIC EFFECTS OF ENTANGLED PHOTON HOLES
19. 19 EFFECTS OF ENTANGLED PHOTON HOLES A classical state of light is assumed to be incident on a two-photon absorbing medium
As the photons propagate through the medium, the magnitude of the dips in the probability amplitude will increase
At some point, there should be no probability amplitude for two photons to be in the same location
So the rate of two-photon absorption should go to zero
But the probability amplitude for two photons to be found in different locations will be nearly unaffected
Thus the two-photon absorption should stop when the total probability of absorption is still small
20. 20 TWO-PHOTON ABSORPTION CALCULATIONS Earlier calculations used
Semiclassical theory or
One or two second-quantized modes or
A continuum of second-quantized modes to lowest order in perturbation theory
The effects of interest here require a multi-mode calculation to all orders
In the absence of an analytic solution, Schrodinger’s equation was integrated numerically
For two gaussian wave packets as input
21. 21 HAMILTONIAN Each photon was limited to k vectors (periodic B.C.)
There are a total of states in the state vector
states corresponding to two photons with and
states corresponding to a single photon and the atom in the first excited state
One additional state with the atom in the upper level
The Hamiltonian in this basis is
22. 22 NUMERICAL INTEGRATION With this Hamiltonian, Schrodinger’s equation corresponds to a set of coupled differential equations
The Hamiltonian contains more than terms
This set of differential equations was integrated numerically using Mathematica
The execution time did scale as
The equations could be integrated in four hours for
This was used as the baseline
A subset of the calculations were repeated using
Gave the same results
23. 23 INITIAL STATE The single-photon intensity was calculated by tracing over the photon 2 components
The probability of detecting two photons separated by a distance s was calculated as usual using
24. 24 AFTER PROPAGATION THROUGH 5 mm The photon wave packets were propagated through a distance of 5 mm
The single-photon intensity was nearly the same
The two-photon detection probability shows a small dip as expected
25. 25 PROBABILITY OF REMAINING INTHE INITIAL STATE The wave packets were propagated through atoms
The probability of remaining in the initial state was calculated
It can be seen that the two-photon absorption rate decreases
The probability reaches a plateau after ~ 20 atoms
26. 26 COMPARISON OF THREE CASES
Photons in same direction
Semiclassical results
Photons in opposite direction
27. 27 SUMMARY OF ENTANGLED PHOTON HOLES Entangled photon holes are somewhat analogous to the holes of semiconductor theory
The analogy is obviously limited since photons are bosons
The “background” corresponds to small probability amplitudes vs unity for fermions below the Fermi level
Entangled photon holes can violate Bell’s inequality using single-photon detectors
Entangled photon holes can have macroscopic effects on two-photon absorption
Can be measured using a classical source and detector
Entangled photon holes can also be generated using down-conversion techniques
28. EIT WITHOUT ANY LASER BEAMS
29. 29 CONVENTIONAL EIT A beam on resonance with atomic level will be strongly absorbed
Due to scattering into
A strong laser beam resonant with and will split the original state into dressed states and
There are now two ways (Feynman diagrams) to reach state
Via (negative detuning)
Via (positive detuning)
These two probability amplitudes cancel each other
The scattering is completely eliminated
We would like to avoid laser beams
(for single photons)
30. 30 EIT WITHOUT LASER BEAMS Instead of splitting an energy level, we tune between two of the resonant modes of a cavity
Photons in a wave guide are coupled to the ring resonator but not directly to the atoms
The probability amplitudes for scattering by the atoms cancel out as before
31. 31 ENHANCED TWO-PHOTON ABSORPTION WITH NO SINGLE-PHOTON SCATTERING Two-photon absorption can still occur via other pairs of intermediate states
We estimate that the two-photon absorption can be four orders of magnitude larger than the single-photon absorption
Ideal for Zeno gates (quant-ph/0603044)
32. SUMMARY
33. 33 SUMMARY The failure modes of LOQC can be suppressed using the Zeno effect
Requires strong two-photon absorption
Two-photon absorption can be enhanced using small cavities and EIT without laser beams
Entangled photon holes are somewhat analogous to the holes of semiconductor theory
Bell’s inequality can be violated using single-photon detectors
Macroscopic effects of entanglement can be observed using classical input states and classical detectors