230 likes | 455 Views
MGMT 580 – FINAL PROJECT. Cesar A. Marrero. Agenda. Introduction Popularity of the Boeing 737 Reliability Program Failures of the Boeing 737 Evaluation: Defective Wiring (TWA Flight 800) Conclusion. Introduction. Boeing 737 – the workhorse for low-fare airlines around the world
E N D
MGMT 580 – FINAL PROJECT Cesar A. Marrero
Agenda • Introduction • Popularity of the Boeing 737 • Reliability Program • Failures of the Boeing 737 • Evaluation: Defective Wiring (TWA Flight 800) • Conclusion
Introduction • Boeing 737 – the workhorse for low-fare airlines around the world • Easier and less expensive to maintain • Fewer parts than older models • Quick turnaround at the terminals
Boeing 737 – Popularity • Over 7,500 aircraft delivered to date • Record-breaking orders of any model in a single year • 1,124 net orders of the next-generation version (models 700, 800, and 900) in 2012 • 914 orders for the 737 MAX version
Reliability Program • Entire System • Common components reused in all airframes • Unchanged fuselage • Changes primarily to wing structure and engines • Airframe is quite cost-efficient • Redesigning fuselage would not provide much improvement • Increased costs with two separate production lines
Reliability Program • Humans in the System • Commonality of airframes promotes familiarity • Training costs are significantly reduced • Employees use a common set of tools and procedures
Reliability Program • Maintenance of the System • Interchangeable parts • Standard technical documentation • Longevity efforts
Reliability Program • Simplicity of Design • Greater turnarounds for airline carriers • Maximize the use of their fleet • Low stance on the ramp • Easier to maintain and load • Servicing can be done at ground level • Baggage can be loaded from the ground • Last minute cargo/luggage additions
Reliability Program • Redundant and fail-safe features • Two engines per aircraft, even though only one is needed to fly • Two electrical systems • Two fuel systems • Emergency Oxygen system • Triple Rudder system
Reliability Program • Manufacturing Methods and Purchasing Requirements • Assembly line production, similar to the automotive industry • Accelerated production • Reduced production costs • Fewer order backlogs and customer waiting times
Reliability Program • Maintenance of complete product or system performance records • Production and maintenance logs • Records failures, replacements, repairs, warnings, field tests, and operating conditions • Influences changes in the airframe • Improves manufacturing methods • Modifies quality checks • Identifies most reliable components • Extensive field testing before components are fielded
Reliability Program • Communication • Valuable collaboration between customers, chief mechanics, and field service reps • Efforts ensure new version of 737 continues the trend of simplicity, reliability and low cost. • Airlines can choose a version of 737 with latest cockpit displays or commonality with older models
Failures of the Boeing 737 • Events influenced dramatic changes in the inspection and maintenance process • TWA Flight 800 – Exploded, killing all on board • Southwest Flight 812 – Peeled exterior skin
TWA Flight 800 • Exploded 12 minutes after take off • Boeing Model 747, not 737 • 230 on board killed • Cause determined to be faulty wiring • Spark caused ignition of fuel fumes • FAA ordered Boeing to inspect all airframes, especially the older 737 model
Southwest Airlines Flight 812 • Loss of cabin pressure, caused crew to perform emergency landing • Cause determined to be manufacturing flaws on the fuselage skin • Rivet joints not aligned or overlapped, causing fatigue on external skin • Skin peeled off, causing a rapid loss of cabin pressure • Not first time skin peeled-off
Evaluation of Defective Wiring Machinery / Equipment People • Cause and effect diagram: Aircraft Explodes Inexperienced maintainers Different fuel mixture Substandard cables Insufficient quality control Missing inspection steps Insufficient testing tools Inadequate testing tools Failure to detect defective cables Materials Methods
Machinery / Equipment • Insufficient testing tools • NO tools available to detect fuel leaks • Inadequate testing tools • NO tools to detect electrical shortages
Methods • Missing inspection steps • NO instructions on how to inspect for fuel leaks around electrical wiring • Insufficient quality control • NO formal QC oversight when inspecting the areas where fuel cells and electrical wiring are combined
People • Failure to detect defective cables • NO training • Unable to physically view defective cables • Inexperienced maintainers • NO experienced workers/mentors
Materials • Substandard cables • Outsourced cables delivered by sub-contractors • Different fuel mixtures • Lack of standard fuel operations at airfields world-wide
Corrective Actions • FAA ensure corrective actions are complied with • Boeing ensures employees receive immediate maintenance notices • Boeing consider redesigning electrical wiring near fuel systems • Boeing consider improving fuel leak detectors
Conclusion • “Reliability, or quality over the long term, is the availability of a product to perform its intended function over a period of time and under prescribed environmental conditions.” (Summers, 2010). • Based on this definition, the Boeing 737 has exceeded these conditions • Surpassed their intended function by extending its lifespan beyond the prescribed maximum of 75,000 flights.
References Boeing Website (2013). The Boeing Next-Generation 737 Family -- Productive, Progressive, Flexible, Familiar. Retrieved August 16, 2013 from http://www.boeing.com/boeing/commercial/737family/background.page Dummeyer, D. (2013). Boeing Quarterly Reports (2Q13). Retrieved August 16, 2013 from http://www.boeing.com/commercial/aeromagazine/articles/2013_q2/pdf/AERO_2013q2.pdf Brady, C. (1999). Boeing 737 Production. Retrieved August 15, 2013 from http://www.b737.org.uk/production.htm Irving, C. (2012). Is Boeing’s 737 an Airplane Prone to Problems? - Newsweek. Retrieved August 17, 2013 from Newsweek Magazine at http://www.thedailybeast.com/newsweek/2012/03/19/is-boeing-s-737-an-airplane-prone-to-problems.html Spicer, K., Angers, S. (2002). Boeing: The Secret Behind High Profits at Low-Fare Airlines. Retrieved August 15, 2013 from Boeing website: http://www.boeing.com/commercial/news/feature/profit.html Summers, D. (2010). Quality. New Jersey: Prentice Hall