1 / 22

Looking for patients in guidelines

Looking for patients in guidelines. Development of a search filter for identifying articles addressing patient issues Lian Hielkema (Dutch College of General Practioners), Monique Wessels (Dutch Association of Medical Specialists) International Clinical Librarian Conference 2011

ajay
Download Presentation

Looking for patients in guidelines

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Looking for patients in guidelines Development of a search filter for identifying articles addressing patient issues Lian Hielkema (Dutch College of General Practioners), Monique Wessels (Dutch Association of Medical Specialists) International Clinical Librarian Conference 2011 Birmingham, 13-14 June 2011

  2. Introduction • Methods • Results • Conclusion

  3. NHG – Dutch College of General Practitioners Orde – Dutch Association of Medical Specialists

  4. Benefits of public involvement (NHS) • better outcomes of treatment and care • a more satisfying experience for patients of using health services • sharing responsibilities for healthcare with the public • more appropriate use of health services

  5. Viewpoint of our two organisations To give patient participation a regular place in guidelines, in order to achieve a more demand-based care by incorporating aspects of patients' perception and experience and their information needs

  6. Methods • Definition and scope • Construction of concept-filters • Validation database • Adaptation of concept-filters

  7. Definition and scope (SIGN) • experiences (condition, diagnosis, treatments, follow-up care and QoL) • (information) needs and preferences • participation in decision-making • overall satisfaction with care received

  8. Construction of concept-filters (for Medline via OVID and via PubMed) Terms derived from: - filter patient issues SIGN - Greenhalgh, T. User involvement in health care (Wiley, 2010) - analysis of known articles

  9. Validation database • guidelines SIGN • Longtin Y et al. Patient participation: current knowledge and applicability to patient safety. Mayo Clin Proc. 2010 85(1):53-62 • guideline diabetes self-management education Result: 176 references

  10. Adaptation of concept-filters • Computerized analysis of MESH-terms of articles in validation database with open source MESH-analysing apps • Manual analysis of missed articles: • 23 (concept OVID-new filter), • 6 (concept PubMed-new filter), • 1 (OVID-SIGN filter)

  11. Part of one of the filters (PubMed-new) • (Patient Participation[Mesh] OR consumer participation[Mesh] OR Professional-Patient Relations[Mesh] OR Patient-Centered Care[Mesh] OR Patient Preference[Mesh] OR Patient Satisfaction[Majr] OR Patient Education as Topic[Mesh] OR Attitude to Health[Mesh] OR Patient Acceptance of Health Care[Mesh] OR Health Knowledge, Attitudes, Practice[Mesh] OR Focus Groups[Mesh] OR Quality of Life[Majr] OR Self Care[mh:noexp] OR Self Concept[Mesh] OR Self-examination[Mesh] OR Cooperative Behavior[Mesh] OR Adaptation, Psychological[Mesh] OR Decision Support Techniques[Mesh] OR Self-Help Groups[Mesh] OR Community Networks[Mesh] OR Emotions[Mesh] OR Consumer Satisfaction[Mesh] OR Needs Assessment[Mesh] OR Personal Autonomy[Mesh] OR Patient Advocacy[Mesh] OR Life Change Events[Mesh]) OR (patient perspective*[tiab] OR patient's perspective*[tiab] OR patient desire*[tiab] OR patient's desire*[tiab] OR "patient's desires"[tiab] OR patient view*[tiab] OR patient's view*[tiab] OR patient expression*[tiab] OR patient's expression*[tiab] OR patient attitude*[tiab] OR patient's attitude*[tiab] OR patient involvement*[tiab] OR patient's involvement*[tiab] OR patient decision*[tiab] OR patient's decision*[tiab] OR patient activation[tiab] OR patient's activation[tiab] OR patients activation[tiab] OR patient empowerment[tiab] OR patient participation[tiab] OR patient's participation[tiab] OR patients participation[tiab] OR patient collaboration[tiab] OR patient's collaboration[tiab] OR patients collaboration[tiab] OR expert patient*[tiab] OR consumer participation[tiab] OR consumer perspective[tiab] OR consumers perspective[tiab] ……..

  12. Results • Validation of concept-filters • Tables • Comparison

  13. Validation of concept-filters • testing in practice • 3 subjects primary care (PubMed-filter) • 3 subjects secondary care (OVID-filter) • sensitivity, specificity, precision, accuracy

  14. General crosstable precision a/(a+b) sensitivity a/(a+c) specificity d/(b+d) accuracy (a+d)/(a+b+c+d)

  15. Pubmed-new:dyspepsia precision 74.0% (53-88) sensitivity 83.3% (62-95) specificity 98.0% (96-99) accuracy 92.0%

  16. PubMed-new:BPH, chlamydia, dyspepsia precision 79.3% (69-87) sensitivity 90.1% (81-95) specificity 98.8% (98-99) accuracy 98.3%

  17. OVID-SIGN:ICD, cataract, spina bifida precision 21.2% (16-26) sensitivity 98.4% (91-99) specificity 69.1% (65-72) accuracy 71.4%

  18. OVID-new:ICD, cataract, spina bifida precision 77.0% (65-86) sensitivity 90.5% (80-96) specificity 98.0% (96-98) accuracy 97.0%

  19. Comparison

  20. Conclusions • a never-ending story? • you can’t have it all • work in progress

  21. Contact information • m.wessels@orde.nl • l.hielkema@nhg.org

More Related